Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

[catfish69hunter]

Not jumpy just trying to make sense out of u, Cat. Thanks for the present, but all it will do is confirm whether or not u sent the present. That is if you or myself are not hit tonight. And as I stated only an innocent who would wish to become evil would open it so why is opening it even a question?

Sorry you have wasted your efforts. I wish u and the innocent communicators had been paying better attention. I just want to point out that I tried to get pple to realize that V2K and DD were most likely innocent. Why would an evil do that? Also if I were evil, I wouldn't have tried to vote out Noodles both days as I would have wanted to keep up the numbers of the evils, even if they weren't communicating they could still help. So are you sore b/c I voted for you and called u out on your theory about me and Dawg?

First I doubt they will try to hit you because then they would openly confirm that I am indeed who I say I am. Thats just it its a risk and we dont know that the present is the change a person or if its the double vote.

As for what you did earlier look at it from my point of view. Trying to point out DD and V2k as innocent was looked at as she may be trying to cover for people. As for noodles No one KNEW she was evil till she had to leave. I myself was seeing her as blitzen or rudolph. (Wow yes i was wrong.) As for my theory I'm not sore but I felt that you played it down because I hit something that may have been too true. I mean the best move a mafia can make is to play down or just plain ignore somethig someone said. Right? Thats all I'm trying to say.

 

[Sploke]

plant is evil
-plant declines present - bad
-plant gets doubling present - bad (2/3)
-plant gets turn present - good (1/3), but a pre-emptive lynch is almost as good in this case

Plant is good
-plant declines present - good
-plant gets doubling present - good (2/3)
-plant get turn present - bad (1/3)

 

[catfish69hunter]

I think you panicked needlessly. The day had just started. I wasn't going to vote you again as Dawg had you high on his suspects and he was DD's nail in the coffin. I don't think that many pple if any have even voted.

Well between you, Virt and hooked as he said after nightfall when he made it back. All of you would have voted me and dawg had it ot for me. so with that said i was looking at a 4 vote count in my mind. I was trying to look for a good route to take to prevent the loss of another comming elf.

 

[Sploke]

that should have said, if plant is innocent and gets the doubling present, that could be good or bad depending on how good a handle she has on who is innocent/evil. I would guess that if she were evil, she would just decline it, unless she wanted to switch teams.

 

[catfish69hunter]

plant is evil
-plant declines present - bad
-plant gets doubling present - bad (2/3)
-plant gets turn present - good (1/3), but a pre-emptive lynch is almost as good in this case

Plant is good
-plant declines present - good
-plant gets doubling present - good (2/3)
-plant get turn present - bad (1/3)

Here is what I see. if she opens it then we would have a next night lynch on our hands.

 

[Sploke]

And the next night, the lump of coal will be delivered as well, so we will be down another innocent one way or another when that happens.

 

[Sploke]

Here is what I see. if she opens it then we would have a next night lynch on our hands.

you mean if she opens it, and gets the turn present? Thats like a 1/6 chance. But yes that would be good.

 

[plantling]

First I doubt they will try to hit you because then they would openly confirm that I am indeed who I say I am. Thats just it its a risk and we dont know that the present is the change a person or if its the double vote.

As for what you did earlier look at it from my point of view. Trying to point out DD and V2k as innocent was looked at as she may be trying to cover for people. As for noodles No one KNEW she was evil till she had to leave. I myself was seeing her as blitzen or rudolph. (Wow yes i was wrong.) As for my theory I'm not sore but I felt that you played it down because I hit something that may have been too true. I mean the best move a mafia can make is to play down or just plain ignore somethig someone said. Right? Thats all I'm trying to say.

If they hit me then it keeps me from confirming that you sent me a present.

I have no idea what u are trying to say. Who would I be covering for by stating who I think is most likely innocent???

You guys are chasing your tails in the innocent chatroom.

plant is evil
-plant declines present - bad
-plant gets doubling present - bad (2/3)
-plant gets turn present - good (1/3), but a pre-emptive lynch is almost as good in this case

Plant is good
-plant declines present - good
-plant gets doubling present - good (2/3)
-plant get turn present - bad (1/3)

Like I said I don't see why there is a question of whether or not I open the present. It's a bit too risky IMO.

 

[plantling]

GAH, you two are overthinking the present!!!

 

[Sploke]

Well, if you get it and don't open it, that serves two purposes if you are evil. 1), you get to stay evil without risking being turned, and 2) you don't have to confirm cat as innocent, thereby keeping the elves at an advantage by keeping the townies from identifying a for-sure innocent.