Mafia #45: Cabin Fever...The Play

Status
Not open for further replies.
Alrighty...I'm not buying it from Ogre just on his say so. This could be read as desperation play...the question is why would a bellhop come out on day 2 ? No need for it...far to early to do it just to save his innocent skin if facing the mob...ALso Ogre doesn't seem to have read the role description...which you would be very careful to do if you were a power role...I am calling the move as scummy pending developments.
 
Sure, I'll say, after reviewing the rules. I'm the bellhop. With Cat dead and the suitcases being totally random AND passed on to another innocent if I die, then there's no reason for me not to come out.

I reiterate, noods is my top suspect for an accomplis. I HIGHLY suspect lucky of being the other one. I have no idea who the madman is.

Yes, but you said you had information - what would that be?
BTW, you are dead wrong about me.....
 
I am buying Ogre's story. As soon as he implied his communication, I immediately deemed him bellhop which fit into the scenario in my head nicely. I agree with his statements about how he wouldn't be so obvious about communicating if he were the madman. And to me, he doesn't see to fit into the madman position.

Ogre- I'm unsure of your position on Noodles. While my concerns about her have been growing, she's not yet on my short list. However, I will stand by you on Lucky being an accomplice. As said in my previous post, he was beginning to strike me as one.

Therefore, I vote to banish Lucky.
 
I'm willing to make it a Lucky/Noodles race tonight.

Coler, you push for me to verify what I'm saying (by reveiling), then you say there's no need for me to come out. Whatever. I think I explained pretty well why I wanted to come out at this point.

If I'm lynched or the madman gets me, then everyone will see the truth of what I've said AND it give the detective another safe night.
 
Still no "info" from Ogre....if you reveal the info you may get hit by the murderer if you an inno, or banished if you are evil - either way you are out, but if the info can help the town then why not come out with it? If you are indeed the bellhop the suitcases will be passed on.........
 
Still no "info" from Ogre....if you reveal the info you may get hit by the murderer if you an inno, or banished if you are evil - either way you are out, but if the info can help the town then why not come out with it? If you are indeed the bellhop the suitcases will be passed on.........

I've given what I can that will help the town.
 
I will make one last appeal and a request for a slight change in plans. I am requesting that everyone vote for noodles. If you are innocent and think that there is a chance I'm telling the truth, then vote for noods.

If she is a madman's accomplis, then the following players are innocent... or at least not the madman or his accomplis: Dawg, Coler, and LG. If noods is not an accompliss, then one of these three are.

Take a look close look at Lucky's posts around nightfall for reasons to suspect him.
 
I will make one last appeal and a request for a slight change in plans. I am requesting that everyone vote for noodles. If you are innocent and think that there is a chance I'm telling the truth, then vote for noods.

If she is a madman's accomplis, then the following players are innocent... or at least not the madman or his accomplis: Dawg, Coler, and LG. If noods is not an accompliss, then one of these three are.

Take a look close look at Lucky's posts around nightfall for reasons to suspect him.

You sound pretty desperate to get me out of the picture Ogre. Wonder why? hhhmmmmm. I think my vote will stay where it is; right on Ogre. You sound so sure of yourself in the beginning of the quote and them you backtrack. You either really have no idea what role I have in this game and are just grasping at straws like the rest of us, or you do know (and are evil) and are just trying to sway the townies to get me out of the way....

I for one am not convinced you are the bellhop cause your role is really insignifant. the Bartender was taken out early therefore could not pass on any info to you, whether true or false, and the suitcases live on after the bellhop dies anyway. Sounds like a desperate plea to get me out of the way.
 
Wow things are truly heating up.

So I am now alarge suspect now eh?
Funny, you guys seem think that there is a deeper meaning behind my noobiness, like I am hiding something? Well, first of all, try reading the directions to this game at 4 in the morning. Then remember your very first game. I am just going to take an average here and say the average age you were at your first game is 30 (for everyone) now divide that by two. Yep thats my age. I am 15 and this is my first game, I have no alternative reason for being a noob. And honestly If I wasn't a noob, I would try my best Not to be a noob my first game, which I am so sure that is what you did your first game, was try to make a good impression.

But back to the subject, I find ogre's accusations to be a wild stab in the dark, I think he might be on to something with noodles just because of the points ogre made. But what is even more disturbing is how he is so eager to jump at me. I had made really no comment about ogre, and yet she is hell bent to get me outa the game. I think that ogre just wants me out of the game because that they think I am somehow associated with noodles. But if you go back and look at my posts, asking when nighfall was, and etc. I believe ogre just thought of me and noodles both as noobs, that is why ogre is trying to sway the rest of the hotel against me and noodles.

But I am in no way connected to noodels I can assure you beyond experience (no pun intended). So I find it odd that ogre is able to persuade the whole hotel just by using false accusations about our experience and twisting those to make something that suits them.

I retract my vote on RB, and vote to banish Ogre
 
Noods is right.

After reviewing the rules, I can see no feasible way for the bartender to have passed any information on to you. The bartender tidbits don't occur till much later in the evening. So, either you are lying, or there is cheating going on. Either way, I can't believe you, Ogre. Sorry. For now, my vote will remain on Lucky...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
AquariaCentral.com