Mafia 46: In the Dark

[luckydud13]

But still don't you feel as if this is a ploy to drag our attention away from the maelstrom incident?

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Sorry, I forgot to ask...Ogre, who is this player?

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

But still don't you feel as if this is a ploy to drag our attention away from the maelstrom incident?

Eh, I didn't get that feeling Lucky. I don't think C note was giving mael a pass, just commenting on Dawg...at least that's how I saw it. Go with what you think.

 

[luckydud13]

And I think that the timing of that was very suspicious to me.

 

[noodles62]

Noodles and gunslinger... you guys are making me nervous. It's day one. Only the four commincators can know other peoples roles... and they only know one other. It's true that mafia know everyone else is innocent, but that really doesn't change the problem with your statement.

The other half is 'he's just stabbing in the dark'. Aren't we all. If you can prove to me that you know a mafia and you aren't one yourself, then I'll vote who you suggest. Until then, your statements are just obvious comments that every player with more than two games ought to know.

There's one player that I can always tell when he's mafia because he has a tell. And gunslinger, you are acting like that player, when he's mafia.

I have played enough to know that we are all stabbing in the dark on day one (w/ the exception of the "four") but any other player would state that they "just have a hunch - or a gut feeling" and not blatantly refuse to answer the questions...just seems kinda scummy....I am not suggesting a vote on anyone at this point, just stating what I see that seems out of place....Isn't that what we are all trying to do to save Acville??? oh! - with the exception of maelstrom :lipssealedsmilie:

 

[noodles62]

But still don't you feel as if this is a ploy to drag our attention away from the maelstrom incident?

Lucky, would you please "quote" the person/comment you are respionding to? The thread does not always flow and it is hard to know who you are talking to; responding to.....

 

[cjtabares]

The first half of the bolded bit does not flow from the other as an either or. If the very first vote of the very first day exercises the town to the extent it does in some of the townies then I would be interested to know who of the townies says it is a scummy vote and who say they don't hold that view and comments like 'I would like to see it explained' or 'I am uncomfortable with this' or similar are in my opinion just so much bs. If you think I am mafia because of this vote or otherwise say so.

I originally did not think you were mafia, but your avoidance of all the questions of why has put you on the top of my list. Your explanation that it is the first night dose not cut it, I fell that a random vote with that much time left until nightfall seem scummy. There is still a lot of info that can be found, so it seems you know something I do not.

 

[noodles62]

Lucky, would you please "quote" the person/comment you are respionding to? The thread does not always flow and it is hard to know who you are talking to; responding to.....

Oops! "respoinding" = responding! LOL

 

[luckydud13]

Noodles please reread, the person that it was directed towards answered in the next post after my question was asked.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

So you're trying to say that maelstrom's vote makes sense to you? I understand that there's nothing to base your vote on, but what I don't understand is why he/she decided to place an early vote and why he/she choose DD, which they have not addressed yet. If they would have said "So and so did this and that's why I am voting for them" we would't be in this situation. Not everyone would have agreed with the reasoning but at least it would be there. Instead they said that they have little to go on but are voting for DD anyways...I think most of us want to know what that "little" bit of info is...

This is complete bs I never said I haid info. Referring to an earlier post by someone else I did not claim my vote "made sense" statistically.