Mafia 46: In the Dark

so then how will we know the player is out? sorry if I am not getting this...


not getting this unless what you are saying is G is dead.... G has posted today

If they stop playing... like noods and John.

I know John said he was working, but he hasn't posted yet either. So I think we have to assume at this point that JOhn and noods were on opposite teams and both got eliminated via ice's rules last night.

Rich's implication is that he is on one of the communicating teams, but his statements implying that he knows LadyG is mafia don't make sense in the context of the rules because the mafia don't have investigations... all they know is that the turn didn't work and the person stops posting... since LadyG is posting, the only way Rich can know her status is if he is mafia and she is innocent.

I'm willing to lynch rich because I think it more likely that he's blowing smoke up our collective *sses.

I vote to lynch Rich... tomorrow is going to be crazy.
 
I only have a couple minutes here right now, and hope to get back on after a while but I read through what has transpired since I was here last. I don't really have time to pull posts right now but I want to ask and answer a couple things I read.

First about Rich and I being "team mates" how many times have you guys really seen the mafia "teams" vote the same player? Yes, when there is a "train" going on a certain player and there is actually a team of Mafia maybe..but in this style game there were only 3 Mafia at the time (if they got their turn victim) why would 2 of the three vote the same player?

Second, I would be willing to change my vote to Rich I do believe him to be mafia also..he and Lucky are my top suspects right now.

To Lucky...how can you be sooooo sure about my being mafia? As far as I know the only way to be 100% certain about another player is A) they are your team mate, which I know I am NOT. B)Investigations, which again I know we don't have this game. What I see is you have experienced players with you, (Dawg was one) that have let you know or you have read past games and you know how easily ppl will jump to me. The town will decide, but you are blowing alot of smoke with your "I know she is" "Vote with me you wont regret it" posts.

Also to you Lucky, you DID say in your post that you voted me (last night) that you voted me to get ppl to talk, how are you now denying that?

And to whoever it was that said something about me "suddenly going to investigation mode" Sorry, I actually had a little time to read through and bring out some points..normally I only have like a half hour or so on here which gives me enough time to read through and post a quick thought or two. I simply had more time this morning and was able to actually post a bit more thoruough thoughts.
 
If they stop playing... like noods and John.

I know John said he was working, but he hasn't posted yet either. So I think we have to assume at this point that JOhn and noods were on opposite teams and both got eliminated via ice's rules last night.

Rich's implication is that he is on one of the communicating teams, but his statements implying that he knows LadyG is mafia don't make sense in the context of the rules because the mafia don't have investigations... all they know is that the turn didn't work and the person stops posting... since LadyG is posting, the only way Rich can know her status is if he is mafia and she is innocent.

I'm willing to lynch rich because I think it more likely that he's blowing smoke up our collective *sses.

I vote to lynch Rich... tomorrow is going to be crazy.


I did say that. Lucky said he knew. Post 694. I just posted the rules since we were asking about them.
 
Day 3



Lucky-1- LG(651)


LadyG-1- Lucky(673)


Rich-1- Ogre(701)






Bala hears a faint ticking somewhere in town but can't pinpoint it.
 
I am not dead, well unless you consider being in Columbus, Georgia dead (which some might). Work has been crazy.

I have skimmed the thread and will study more in a bit. This after nightfall vote that would saved Dawg from being in a tie has me concerned. I have not read the explaination, If someone knows where it is maybe they can quote it. If I find it I will quote it.

Not much time, will explain later
I retract my vote on Lady G, and vote to lynch Ogre

I can't see how lucky can't be the number one suspect. I still have MC as a suspect. I don't think mafia would vote for mafia, unless they were sure it would not cause a lynch. Maybe lucky was just too late for the save. For now I am okay with half-way trusting the four the who voted for Dawg (Cnote, Mael, Ogre, Opi). I find the ones that voted for Ogre suspect (MC, Noodles), but CJ was innocent and Dawg jumped on there late.

I still like MC as mafia and can see how Noodles could be mafia also. My guess is one (but not both) is mafia. I really can't see how this late vote change, so late it was nightfall, by lucky can't be a motivating reason and almost proof that lucky is mafia.

I vote to lynch luckydud13.

If I can find the reason for the late change, I might change.
 
OK, YAY! John isn't dead. Unfortunately, if my suspicions about noods are correct, she was a communicating townie. That means that the innocent team and the mafia team are tied right now. It also 'kinda good' because with three mafia targets it makes things a little easier.

My current list is Rich and Lucky... almost 99.9%
LadyG is still iffy for me.
DD too
John... neutral
the rest are leaning innocent with C-note leaning the most.
 
[AC] maelstrom;1817873 said:
Noodles - neutral, leaning innocent.
Ogre - strong leaning towards innocent
Mostlycichlids - have no read on them
Rich - suspect mafia
Dawg Dead Scumbag
DD - neutral
Jbradt - dead innocent
Opi - have no read on them.
Lucky - strong leaning towards innocent
Cj - dead innocent
JL - have no read on them
Jarred - dead innocent
LG - suspect mafia
[AC] C-Note - I don't see what others see in them being mafia. I am not calling them innocent but I don't see it as yet so someone wants to make a case I will listen but otherwise I have a mild leaning towards innocence.

Ok that's about where I am on individuals presently.

How can you have Luck as "strong leaning towards innocent"?
 
AquariaCentral.com