Cycle (the product)

Safe Start Update

Put my bottle of safe start in last night and am very impressed. Lemme give you some background first. Set up our 29g exactly two weeks ago. 5 days after that, added a serpae tetra and gold barb for cycling. Since putting the fish in, I have had a hard time maintaining low ammonia levels. Testing everyday, ammonia reading between .25 and .5 and nitrites and nitrates at 0. I was doing a 50% water change every other day and still could not get the ammonia down and could not get a nitrite reading above 0. 24 hours after adding the Safe Start, my ammonia is now reading between .25 and 0, nitrite and .25 and nitrate at 5.0. I do not believe these reading magically happened naturally over 1 night. I fully believe the Safe Start really jumped kicked my cycle. I will continue to test everyday and will update how long before ammonia and nitrite are at 0.

P.S. I know many here disagree with fish in cycling and will call what I am doing hurting the fish especially considering my high ammonia levels. This is the route I chose and I was doing everything I could to try and keep the level down. Lets try to save any issues you might have with this for the many threads dedicated to fish-in or fishless cycles and keep this thread on track regarding products for cycling assistance.
 
Last day of week one using safe start and at:
3 ppm ammonia
off-the-chart nitrites
20 nirates

The second set of bacteria is slower forming (which I believe is to be expected), but getting there. I been having to add ammonia more frequently or larger amounts to maintain 2-3 ppm.
 
Those are very encouraging results. Is there a date code on the bottle?

If you are referring to my results...no, could not find a date code on the bottle.

Also, an important thing the guy at the LFS said was not to change the water after putting in the stuff. I thought about calling Tetra and verifying this with them.
 
I don't know how long you would want to wait on the water change, if it is bacteria they will colonize on stuff so the free floating stange would be non existant wouldn't it? Like, I wouldn't change the water in the first day or maybe 3 but after a week I don't think I would wait?
Call the 1-800 # if there is one?
GL
 
I don't know how long you would want to wait on the water change, if it is bacteria they will colonize on stuff so the free floating stange would be non existant wouldn't it? Like, I wouldn't change the water in the first day or maybe 3 but after a week I don't think I would wait?
Call the 1-800 # if there is one?
GL

Yeah. Sorry, I did not clarify more. I was referring to my daily 50% water changes. I am still going to do a 15-25 percent change this Saturday.
 
If you are referring to my results...no, could not find a date code on the bottle.

Also, an important thing the guy at the LFS said was not to change the water after putting in the stuff. I thought about calling Tetra and verifying this with them.

Both sets of results show activity. I don't have my water log from when I used it but it clearly made no difference. There is not a lot of stock turn over at my chain store so I wonder if I got an old bottle.
 
Both sets of results show activity. I don't have my water log from when I used it but it clearly made no difference. There is not a lot of stock turn over at my chain store so I wonder if I got an old bottle.

I know mine was a brand new bottle to my LFS cause I went in on Wed and he did not have any. Was getting a new shipment the next morning. So I am assuming the bottle I picked up the next morn was pretty fresh.
 
I recently used Dr. Tim's One and Only Nitrifying Bacteria and made a log about it here: http://www.aquariacentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=183858

I was impressed with the results, but you can see for yourself how things went in the log. Hope this helps.

On a more on-topic note, I used Cycle before, but it did nothing for me. However, I could have had a bad batch as it seems some people here have had luck with it.
 
I don't know how long you would want to wait on the water change, if it is bacteria they will colonize on stuff so the free floating stange would be non existant wouldn't it? Like, I wouldn't change the water in the first day or maybe 3 but after a week I don't think I would wait?
Call the 1-800 # if there is one?
GL

Here is the response I got from Tetra when I asked about the water changes and told them the LFS guy said not to do water changes:

Hello,
That is correct. They are trying to avoid you doing a water change right now and getting rid of all the good bacteria before it settles it. Be very careful not to over feed and do not do a water change for the first 2 weeks. After that your ammonia should begin to come down and the bacteria will be attached so a partial water change would be good.
Best regards,
Tetra Care
 
AquariaCentral.com