Mafia 50/50 The play..back to Basics..almost

[The Zigman]

I am leaning towards a vote for Cj.
I cant understand how he can be so certain who to vote for, and cast his vote so early with nothing to go on.. and have nothing to back up his decision... unless he knows who his team mates are...

 

[Dangerdoll]

Backtracking again here.. forgive me, I'm probably going to do a lot of that today.

DD.. I'd like to know something about this statement. Did you actually intend to say that (at that time) you wanted to vote for CJT... then you noticed a second vote had been made against him so yours would have made it 3... and THIS fact is what changed your mind? If that's true, are you only planning to vote against someone if they don't have a chance of getting killed?

The reason I was uncomfortable voting for cjt initially is solely because rich was voting... Not because rich was 3rd in line, but because I feel like rich is part of the mafia. I have a feeling about luv at this point also.... she seems shady too, so that would make 3. UNLESS, rich is voting cj to throw others off...

I didnt even notice this until I was reading again and noticed it pointed out by Blue. This is very interesting. I am always cautious of DD but would she really be so careless of slipping up? hhhhmmmmm

I have nothing to slip up about, noods

Also, something is striking me weird about DD this game, she doesnt seem to have come up on anyones radar other than hear and there. I find that odd. I know DD is an excellent player, and while I know she works during the day, I expected more posts from her at this point.

ok, since it's so mysterious that I could be doing something other than watching the game, today at work, had to do 2 days worth of work because I will be off tomorrow. Being off, doesn't necessarily count me as planted on the PC for the day, I will be taking a 3 hour (each way) drive to look at some puppies... chances are good, I will also be bringing one home. This weekend, I will be having company, a lot of it... so with that, and picking up a puppy tomorrow, there are lots of preparations I have been making... you know, cleaning the house, re-puppy proofing everything, all that fun stuff.

What I find odd is the fact that you keep trying to manipulate different things from people, making it seem like there is something sinister going on.... so with that, and now have added you to whom I think may have their meatballs on the stove.
For now, I will go with voting Cjt.... for my suspicions of his post. He hasnt satisfied my curiosity one bit...

I vote to lynch cjt

 

[Dangerdoll]

you'll note, I went with cj, despite my suspicion of rich... yes, I am aware of it... my suspicicion on cj, is more so than my suspicion on rich, and out of my list, cj is the most I am suspicious about.

 

[The Red Severum]

For a while there, I thought blue was mafia. I had no doubt, and that is why i voted for her. Then she had some valid points that in my mind took her off the chopping block for now.
Then noodles starting posting a lot and took the attention off of her and put it on everyone else, which the mafia is trying to do. Which is why she got my vote (for now)
We all no about cj so I shouldn't have to go into this.
Then you have someone like JL who pisses me off more then you can believe. But he has some valid points.
Then you have someone like Doll who I am having trouble trying to figure out. Some things you do point like you are mafia, then you do other things that make you out of the limelight.
But now you have some like kashta who calls everyone else unhelpful but I don't really see her do much. Which right now, she is on the top of my list, over noodles.
but by the looks of it, cjt is going to get lynched. which I am not sure is such a good thing..

 

[The Red Severum]

and rich, is so/so like DD. forgot to add that..

 

[Rbishop]

Bala looks at the clock..about 2 hours to go....

Last update on votes in one hour....

 

[Blueiz]

What I find odd is the fact that you keep trying to manipulate different things from people, making it seem like there is something sinister going on.... so with that, and now have added you to whom I think may have their meatballs on the stove.
For now, I will go with voting Cjt.... for my suspicions of his post. He hasnt satisfied my curiosity one bit...

I vote to lynch cjt

I am glad that you have noted that I have been posting my thoughts. Where are yours, other than defending yourself?

Im really surprised that you had to "add" me to who you think may have there "meatballs on the stove". Everyone has "there meatballs on the stove" in my book, Im just trying to determine which one is the hottest.

(in the off chance, are you cooking spaghetti for supper..lol)

 

[noodles62]

The reason I was uncomfortable voting for cjt initially is solely because rich was voting... Not because rich was 3rd in line, but because I feel like rich is part of the mafia. I have a feeling about luv at this point also.... she seems shady too, so that would make 3. UNLESS, rich is voting cj to throw others off...


I have nothing to slip up about, noods

ok, since it's so mysterious that I could be doing something other than watching the game, today at work, had to do 2 days worth of work because I will be off tomorrow. Being off, doesn't necessarily count me as planted on the PC for the day, I will be taking a 3 hour (each way) drive to look at some puppies... chances are good, I will also be bringing one home. This weekend, I will be having company, a lot of it... so with that, and picking up a puppy tomorrow, there are lots of preparations I have been making... you know, cleaning the house, re-puppy proofing everything, all that fun stuff.

What I find odd is the fact that you keep trying to manipulate different things from people, making it seem like there is something sinister going on.... so with that, and now have added you to whom I think may have their meatballs on the stove.
For now, I will go with voting Cjt.... for my suspicions of his post. He hasnt satisfied my curiosity one bit...

I vote to lynch cjt

DD, I find it hard to believe that you would slip up; you are too experienced for that. (but stranger things have happened) My initial instincts led me to vote for Blue right out of the gate; so, is she fishing here and trying to get votes out there for you? or is my initial impression of her clouding my judgement? I have never played with Blue before so not sure.........
My gut tells me to switch my vote as it is totally useless where it is at the moment.....I need to review more.....quickly! there are quite a few players I am leery of.

 

[The Zigman]

mmm Spaghetti...

I vote to lynch CJT


either he is being coached on who to vote for, or he is a clueless as I am...

 

[Kashta]

sorry kash, posted it to quick, and didn't reread it. What do you think you have done towards the game (just wondering)

Thanks TRS. Now I see what you're asking. Frankly, I don't think the experienced players here expect a whole lot from the new players. Look how many of them have mentioned their reluctance to vote us out after the first day is over. I also found out before this started that we don't need to worry a lot about that first day because everything is so random. So one thing I brought to the game right away was an awful lot of enthusiasm to jump right in and help stimulate a some discussion... (and in the process, I learned how fast THAT can backfire). But.. whatever.. that's okay too. I figure if I can't take the heat as well as anyone else, then I've got no business being here. So... I guess, the best answer I can give you is just say... I'm doing the best I can with whatever I can figure out along the way to keep up with everyone else.

So now in this game, itself...

What I'm doing is paying a lot of attention to what people say and how they act. Half the players are innocent and half the players are lying like crazy while pretending to be innocent. So my focus is to question (in my mind) everything people say and everything they do.. particularly, in relation to each other. So I'm doing that. For todays vote, for example (since that's what prompted your question anyway), I looked at everyone here and read through all the posts a few times. Then I tried to figure out which townies seem most credible vs. which ones make me believe they have something to hide. In your case, there is no possible way I can know whether you are an innocent or a mafia player. So I use my best judgement to decide for myself whether I think you're being open and direct or whether I believe you're trying to hide a mafia agenda. I won't know if I got that choice right or wrong until you get lynched or the game comes to an end. The longer this game progresses, the MORE complicated it gets. And that's what I've done in the game today. I've narrowed down the possibilities to 4 of MY top suspects. I just posted my guesses/hunches/judgements here for everyone else to see. And within a real short time, I have to choose one over the other 3 and get my vote made within the time given. The 4 names on my list are the ones I'm most reasonably certain about right now. And that's it. We'll find out if I was right or wrong for one of those in about an hour and half.