Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

IceH2O said:
FDs vote was the kill vote but in this game of no voting that means either nothing at all or Luv is also mafia and Noodles at a lesser extent a possible mafia and she saved them. I'm just not sure that Jpap would park on Noodles and move at a later time. So Noodles is pretty cleared to me. So its possible that Luv is mafia. If Luv is mafia it doesn't clear DD thou. DD might be pointing fingers in that direction but not voting her when they were tied is scummy imo.

13 players voted out of 17

No votes from

JL
Dopey
TRS
DD, the only 1 that was active at the time.
Click to expand...


What is your reasoning for thinking I am mafia Ice? Is it still over the pizza comment? Truly the only reason I said you (Ice) and DD only got it is because no one else referred to the joke directly. Everyone else seemed to just be chiming in with what they liked on their pizzas. I wasn't even sure if Kash got it. Maybe I didn't give everyone else enough credit.

Here is my list:

DD: Didn't vote at all last night, but kept pointing towards me all day yesterday saying she would probably vote for me. I think that DD is mafia. She knew Noods, me , and MC weren't mafia (she couldn't have known MC was the SK) and therefore didn't wanna draw too much attention to herself by making a tie breaking vote. None of them were mafia, so she wasn't gonna lose any buddies, so she didn't care.

Kash: Very quiet this time around. Don't know if that is just because she isn't having to defend herself from the get go or not. Still up in the air.

Rich: Looks like he is defending DD today. Hmmmm.

JM: Hmmmmm...

Noods: Has totally fooled me before. I thought for sure she was mafia my first game, but she was communicating innocent. I don't know what to think, but does seem like she is trying to help the town; more so then some.

Ice: The whole Coler/Ice thing yesterday was weird. Don't know if he is riding Coler's innocent coat tails or is truly trying to help the townies. So far, has been makin some great points and been somewhat helpful.. Dunno..

JL: Doesn't post or vote first day. Comes in outta the blue on the second day, votes DD first thing. Gives what I think is a decent reason for not being on the first day. Up in the air.

TRS: Usually comes in guns a blazin' to every game. Where is he?

Dopehand: ?????
 
i do also think that it is pretty suspicious that all of a sudden JL came out of nowhere out of left field and voted.

honestly, both of you could be mafia at this time, but i am actually leaning more towards JL...the way they just came out and started pointing fingers at DD in such a small time frame is almost screaming ulterior motive to me. it just seems like someone is behind the scenes telling you what to do; your vote is just to sporadic for my liking and is just too all-of-a-sudden. still, i think it would be very unwise for the mafia to just start out like this after jpap got tagged by the MC.

DD has had her share of strange activities as well. not voting yesterday may raise some flags, but then again most votes yesterday were totally random and based on little to nothing. still, she's not really any higher on my list than noddles and luvbugz, who i had some mediocre suspicions for yesterday.

i really think it just happened by chance that MC ended up dying right at the end, and voted for himself to get someone else to think he was an innocent and save him.
 
Luvbugz said:
What is your reasoning for thinking I am mafia Ice? Is it still over the pizza comment? Truly the only reason I said you (Ice) and DD only got it is because no one else referred to the joke directly. Everyone else seemed to just be chiming in with what they liked on their pizzas. I wasn't even sure if Kash got it. Maybe I didn't give everyone else enough credit.

Here is my list:

DD: Didn't vote at all last night, but kept pointing towards me all day yesterday saying she would probably vote for me. I think that DD is mafia. She knew Noods, me , and MC weren't mafia (she couldn't have known MC was the SK) and therefore didn't wanna draw too much attention to herself by making a tie breaking vote. None of them were mafia, so she wasn't gonna lose any buddies, so she didn't care.
Click to expand...

this is actually a very good point, although it is a bit of speculation. i'll have to go through the thread to find and good evidence to back it up...
 
I might as well put my vote out here: I VOTE TO LYNCH DANGERDOLL for the reasons I have listed above.
 
rich311k said:
Now we are slinging. Something to read. I think all logic at this point must be based on thin arguments right now, of course that is the point of the game too.

DD you did not think your vote would matter? as of course it surely would have or just did not want get in the middle of it all?
Click to expand...
show me where it would have mattered, rich

Luvbugz said:
What is your reasoning for thinking I am mafia Ice? Is it still over the pizza comment? Truly the only reason I said you (Ice) and DD only got it is because no one else referred to the joke directly. Everyone else seemed to just be chiming in with what they liked on their pizzas. I wasn't even sure if Kash got it. Maybe I didn't give everyone else enough credit.

Here is my list:

DD: Didn't vote at all last night, but kept pointing towards me all day yesterday saying she would probably vote for me. I think that DD is mafia. She knew Noods, me , and MC weren't mafia (she couldn't have known MC was the SK) and therefore didn't wanna draw too much attention to herself by making a tie breaking vote. None of them were mafia, so she wasn't gonna lose any buddies, so she didn't care.

Kash: Very quiet this time around. Don't know if that is just because she isn't having to defend herself from the get go or not. Still up in the air.

Rich: Looks like he is defending DD today. Hmmmm.

JM: Hmmmmm...

Noods: Has totally fooled me before. I thought for sure she was mafia my first game, but she was communicating innocent. I don't know what to think, but does seem like she is trying to help the town; more so then some.

Ice: The whole Coler/Ice thing yesterday was weird. Don't know if he is riding Coler's innocent coat tails or is truly trying to help the townies. So far, has been makin some great points and been somewhat helpful.. Dunno..

JL: Doesn't post or vote first day. Comes in outta the blue on the second day, votes DD first thing. Gives what I think is a decent reason for not being on the first day. Up in the air.

TRS: Usually comes in guns a blazin' to every game. Where is he?

Dopehand: ?????
Click to expand...
you are crazy, there was no tie last night.... did you miss that post?

jm1212 said:
i do also think that it is pretty suspicious that all of a sudden JL came out of nowhere out of left field and voted.

honestly, both of you could be mafia at this time, but i am actually leaning more towards JL...the way they just came out and started pointing fingers at DD in such a small time frame is almost screaming ulterior motive to me. it just seems like someone is behind the scenes telling you what to do; your vote is just to sporadic for my liking and is just too all-of-a-sudden. still, i think it would be very unwise for the mafia to just start out like this after jpap got tagged by the MC.

DD has had her share of strange activities as well. not voting yesterday may raise some flags, but then again most votes yesterday were totally random and based on little to nothing. still, she's not really any higher on my list than noddles and luvbugz, who i had some mediocre suspicions for yesterday.

i really think it just happened by chance that MC ended up dying right at the end, and voted for himself to get someone else to think he was an innocent and save him.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't say that anyone is actually behind the sidelines telling JL what to do, he's a big boy... can handle himself rather well... BUT you have something there. He came out rather strong with lots of assumptions for having "so much to read" in such a little time frame... that is where I find most of my suspicion for him.

Luvbugz said:
I might as well put my vote out here: I VOTE TO LYNCH DANGERDOLL for the reasons I have listed above.
Click to expand...
LOL you kill me, girl
 
Dangerdoll said:
you are crazy, there was no tie last night.... did you miss that post?
Click to expand...


thats not really that great of a defense there was a tie for an hour and it was only broken with 5 minutes remaining untill night. im not saying you are mafia because you didn't vote, it could be you thought they were all good suspects and were just going to let it play out, however if bugz or noodles turn out innocent i would be highly suspicious that you were mafia
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom