Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

[johnlarson66]

i do also think that it is pretty suspicious that all of a sudden JL came out of nowhere out of left field and voted.

honestly, both of you could be mafia at this time, but i am actually leaning more towards JL...the way they just came out and started pointing fingers at DD in such a small time frame is almost screaming ulterior motive to me. it just seems like someone is behind the scenes telling you what to do; your vote is just to sporadic for my liking and is just too all-of-a-sudden. still, i think it would be very unwise for the mafia to just start out like this after jpap got tagged by the MC.

DD has had her share of strange activities as well. not voting yesterday may raise some flags, but then again most votes yesterday were totally random and based on little to nothing. still, she's not really any higher on my list than noddles and luvbugz, who i had some mediocre suspicions for yesterday.

i really think it just happened by chance that MC ended up dying right at the end, and voted for himself to get someone else to think he was an innocent and save him.

jm1212, you think my quick vote on DD is suspect and then in the NEXT paragraph you help make the case for voting DD. Her lack of a vote, when she was active in the game and had suspects is a very good reason to vote for her.

Me jumping in and voting for someone is pretty normal. Votes can be changed. If you think for a moment someone is telling me how to vote, then you need to go back and read some older games. I am sure if I had teamates they would be telling me not to jump in and start a fight with DD. Well maybe DD and I are teamates and I am doing it for distancing. The whole sidelines comment is classic noobatard. People on the sideline would tell me to do the exact oppisite. The mafia WILL hide in the shadows.

show me where it would have mattered, rich


you are crazy, there was no tie last night.... did you miss that post?



I wouldn't say that anyone is actually behind the sidelines telling JL what to do, he's a big boy... can handle himself rather well... BUT you have something there. He came out rather strong with lots of assumptions for having "so much to read" in such a little time frame... that is where I find most of my suspicion for him.


LOL you kill me, girl

I thought it was a tie. I was wrong. I still think DD's lack of voting is a bad thing. Top that with an OMGUS and I think we got one.

I still have so much to read. Everytime I click "unread posts" it brings me to the first one. I skimmed big time and the posts after nightfall have gotten most of my attention.

 

[Dangerdoll]

so why would an OMGUS vote justify being scummy?

 

[dirtydawg10]

You are sorry the SK was taken out? Why?

if anything, this is a good thing that he's gone. personally, i dont think that there was any planning to the hit. the SK just chose someone, but it just happened to be a mafia.

UMMM...in case you guys missed it the SK is the only person playing who took out any mafia so far. Granted it was probably random but it helped the Town none the less. I don't see why it wouldn't have been a benefit for the town to have the SK hitting more scum for us.

It would be great if Dawg and Firedancer picked up their pace and participated a little more. Maverick too......

The pace will be picking up tonight I assure you. I have a lot of reading to do and will be posting my comments. I was gone to NH Sunday and had a busy Monday back at work so I couldn't post from here. I'll be on at home quite a bit tonight looking into connections with JPap.

 

[IceH2O]

What is your reasoning for thinking I am mafia Ice? Is it still over the pizza comment? Truly the only reason I said you (Ice) and DD only got it is because no one else referred to the joke directly. Everyone else seemed to just be chiming in with what they liked on their pizzas. I wasn't even sure if Kash got it. Maybe I didn't give everyone else enough credit.

Its part the Pizza comment and part the possibility of you being team mates with DD and grouping me in as a third of your party plus the fact that while in a 3 way tie DD who pointed your way all day decided not to place a vote in your direction which in the end saved you.

show me where it would have mattered, rich


you are crazy, there was no tie last night.... did you miss that post?

You are joking right? It was 4-4-4 until FD came in and voted MC then he voted himself.

As for JL, I think his excuse is the truth. Doesn't mean I think he is innocent though I do like the thought process. I find its easier to figure the good from bad when you haven't been in the middle of it.



Still not sure who to vote for, maybe I'll take a page from DD and not vote since I'm not 100% sure of anyone.

 

[johnlarson66]

Okay, I have done some reading up to nightfall.

I am sure I skimmed some. Also knowing that MC was the SK and that Coler was innocent and jpap was mafia also put things in a different way than when I first read it.

Of everyone right now I am inclined towards Noodles...and kinda JM as well...sorta feeling it for MC...and Kashta actually - but these are basically so weak as ought to be considered random and not based on anything useful. Insofar as its D1, unless anything better presents itself that's sorta where I will be putting a vote ultimately...if I do vote.

Coler (innocent - killed by mafia) had the following suspects: Noods, JM, MC and Kash. He states that they are weak and basicly random. Coler has good instincts (when he is playing) and we now know he was innocent.

actually, if I werer to vote anyone today, it would be bugz... not ready to just yet though... so far bugz has claimed something odd in the beginning of the game and again here, bugz... your reason for voting MC is because he is the only one continuoulsy bringing up the whole Ice and DD joke thing..... I think O have been bringing it up and I believe Ice has too now... so now what? Nothing else looks as shady to me as this...

Here DD states that if she were to vote it would be for bugz, but not ready yet.

oh wait! looks like a 3 way tie, unless I counted wrong....

Here it is mentioned it is a tie (I think there is less than an hour left)

ya 3 way tie by my count as well

Confirmed it is a tie.

Mostly: Dawg(93) Luv(127) Kashta(156) Agass(161)
Red: --Noodles(100)--
Coler: --Ice(106)--
Noodles: Jpappy(108) Ice(173) Coler(195) Jm(203)
Dopehand: --Mostly(118)--
Luv: Mostly(136) Noodles(154) Rich(191) Mav(202)

Mod confirms the tie

I would still like the answers on why the votes for me from Kash and Agass...hopefully before night.

MC wants to know why Agass and Kash voted for him. Kash explained, looked like Agass just followed Kash

You seem the most suspicious to me, MC. I gave some examples in my post that weren't already mentioned. I didn't feel you were trying to stimulate conversation or unravel anything as much as looking to place scum labels wherever you could. There isn't a lot more than that to go on this day so that's how I voted.

Kash explains her vote, not real firmly, but at least she answered.

I dislike being a final vote on day 1. That being said, I don't feel quite right about Mostly, and I really don't like the vote on Luv right now. Especially as it is the first vote on.

I vote to lynch MostlyChiclids.

FD, out of no where, with not much time left, breaks the tie. Highly suspect. Admits to saving Luv (saved noods also). While I think no voting would have been suspect also, it should be noted that FD did decide MC's fate.

Well it looks as if I am done....this game kinda sucked anyway with only a little more than half the players playing......

I retract my vote on LuvBugs and I VOTE TO MYSELF (MC)

Seems like MC was kinda down in the dumps with the slow start and wanted to just off himself. I am not sure if he knew that FD had already killed him.

I think for day one, there was plenty of posts, keep in mind this is from someone that did not post at all. I think MC was excited about having such a cool power role and disappointed about it being a slow start.

 

[Luvbugz]

Its part the Pizza comment and part the possibility of you being team mates with DD and grouping me in as a third of your party plus the fact that while in a 3 way tie DD who pointed your way all day decided not to place a vote in your direction which in the end saved you.






You are joking right? It was 4-4-4 until FD came in and voted MC then he voted himself.

As for JL, I think his excuse is the truth. Doesn't mean I think he is innocent though I do like the thought process. I find its easier to figure the good from bad when you haven't been in the middle of it.



Still not sure who to vote for, maybe I'll take a page from DD and not vote since I'm not 100% sure of anyone.

No one more than me is shocked that DD did not vote for me. I waited all night for her vote. I truly did not think I would be here today hence my vote for her.

Where does that put FD then? I dunno. I truly think she is busy with her baby and didn't get to vote until the last second. At least she did vote.

 

[Luvbugz]

Also Ice, why would I point right to that fact minutes after the game was back on?? Don't you think I would be trying to help cover my buddies' backside??

 

[johnlarson66]

Its part the Pizza comment and part the possibility of you being team mates with DD and grouping me in as a third of your party plus the fact that while in a 3 way tie DD who pointed your way all day decided not to place a vote in your direction which in the end saved you.






You are joking right? It was 4-4-4 until FD came in and voted MC then he voted himself.

As for JL, I think his excuse is the truth. Doesn't mean I think he is innocent though I do like the thought process. I find its easier to figure the good from bad when you haven't been in the middle of it.



Still not sure who to vote for, maybe I'll take a page from DD and not vote since I'm not 100% sure of anyone.

I was doubting myself (mostly because I had skimmed) about the tie towards nightfall.

I quoted what went down in my last post. I am feeling better about my vote on DD. I also am concerned with FD, with her late minute vote. I also am a little concerned about a few comments Kash has made.

I think all of the people left on Colers list need some sort of look into.

I am also unsure why MC choose to hit jpap. Now that we know that jpap was mafia and that Coler was innocent. I think the votes on noods should be looked at first:

Noodles: Jpappy(108) Ice(173) Coler(195) Jm(203)

jpappy was mafia, Coler was hit by the mafia. That leaves Ice and Jm. I doubt if the mafia would double up on a player on day one back to back. maybe be the third vote, but that would be Coler who they hit.

Now jpap could have been voting for one of his teamates for distancing, but from my experience with jpap, I think that would be more agressive than he plays.

Ice, I just don't see him being the second vote with a teamate, not on day one and not with much reason.

Coler, mafia hit him - was this to sick people on Nods?

JM - not sure if they would vote with a teamate, but could see them doing it, mafia had no reason to think that jpap would be hit by the SK and his role known. It is better for the mafia to blend in than being a lone vote somewhere else. If noods is mafia, then this would clear JM. Besides that I would have JM slightly leaning mafia.

So with Colers list (Noods, JM, MC and Kash) I have the following thoughts:

Noods - leaning innocent, can't see jpap voting a teamate on day one.

JM - look above (slightly mafia)

MC - dead SK, not sure if he was hunting mafia or innocents.

Kash - I don't think she would have offed Coler after being named. I do think she would go after Ice or Dawg as far as hits (and maybe me - but I was not around) if she is mafia a stronger person is running things.

 

[johnlarson66]

As far as my excuse, I welcome you all to look at the pictures from myspace that I posted. We had a blast.

Ice, we will be having a Madden 10 tournament...

 

[jm1212]

I was doubting myself (mostly because I had skimmed) about the tie towards nightfall.

I quoted what went down in my last post. I am feeling better about my vote on DD. I also am concerned with FD, with her late minute vote. I also am a little concerned about a few comments Kash has made.

I think all of the people left on Colers list need some sort of look into.

I am also unsure why MC choose to hit jpap. Now that we know that jpap was mafia and that Coler was innocent. I think the votes on noods should be looked at first:



jpappy was mafia, Coler was hit by the mafia. That leaves Ice and Jm. I doubt if the mafia would double up on a player on day one back to back. maybe be the third vote, but that would be Coler who they hit.

Now jpap could have been voting for one of his teamates for distancing, but from my experience with jpap, I think that would be more agressive than he plays.

Ice, I just don't see him being the second vote with a teamate, not on day one and not with much reason.

Coler, mafia hit him - was this to sick people on Nods?

JM - not sure if they would vote with a teamate, but could see them doing it, mafia had no reason to think that jpap would be hit by the SK and his role known. It is better for the mafia to blend in than being a lone vote somewhere else. If noods is mafia, then this would clear JM. Besides that I would have JM slightly leaning mafia.

So with Colers list (Noods, JM, MC and Kash) I have the following thoughts:

Noods - leaning innocent, can't see jpap voting a teamate on day one.

JM - look above (slightly mafia)

MC - dead SK, not sure if he was hunting mafia or innocents.

Kash - I don't think she would have offed Coler after being named. I do think she would go after Ice or Dawg as far as hits (and maybe me - but I was not around) if she is mafia a stronger person is running things.

it is unfortunate that you feel this way...day one votes are usually made on tiny suspicions or totally random. yesterday, noodle's behavior cught my eye a few times, but so did LuvBugz. those suspicions were just little things and proved not to be worth anything.

today is a different story. both you and DD have brought up pretty vailid points about one another, and LuvBugz also brought up some pretty good points about DD that i also agree with.