Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

Kashta said:
I'm comfortable with my two leading suspects.. DD and Luvbugz. My vote could go either way between them, so I'll place the vote now...

I vote to lynch DangerDoll.

That gets this in for the day and I intend to vote Luvbugz tomorrow. (Or vice versa.) My reasons for both stated earlier this morning.

JM1212.. The only remaining question I have is this.... how many mafia games have you played before?

FireDancer was a question for me over her vote to save Luvbugz or not. With this question in mind, it's this post from her that's made that call for me. I've broken up FD's single post into multiple quotes to add comments between the paragraphs. Reading this with the notion these three are mafia teammates, I can see FD defending or being helpfully sympathetic toward both DD and Luvbugz while remaining carefully neutral about the others she names.

Here, FD defends DD:



Here, general comments. Then somewhat scolds JM but staying neutral about that too:



Here, defends Luvbugz again while explaining herself:



The rest is noncomittal... Mav, Ice, and JL:
Click to expand...
1 :D mafia 40 i believe...would've done more but then we had the whole volleyball season...
 
Dangerdoll said:
What I would like to know, Bugz, is your opinion on JL and Ice...
Click to expand...

I have suspicions on both. JL I keep flip flopping on. At first, I totally had him on the townie side. Now, I am not so sure, but still trying to give him the benefit of the doubt. Reason being: It would be a great mafia tatic to send in a player to stir up a bunch of stuff the second day. Point a bunch of fingers in the wrong direction. Act like they are actually kicking bushes for the mafia, but really trying to stir up the place to make it easier to pick off townies. It what Kash was beautiful at doing in the previous games.

Ice: Came in guns a blazing, but has been hiding in the background kinda since. The whole Coler thing is what is making me REALLY suspicious of Ice. Ice knows Coler's play style much better than the rest of us. He could have easily picked up on that Coler was a townie. The change of his vote from Coler to Noods is what is really waving a big red flag for me. I think he maybe using Coler's innocence. The "look he was innocent and I agreed with him therefore I must be innocent" thing. He would have known Coler was gonna get hit. Maybe that is why he changed his vote so quick? Also, last game Ice was a townie. He did a REALLY good job of beating around the bushes. As mucs, we took him out first thing because it woulda been too hard for us to fight against his logic. Remember the whole Kash pm thing??!? He had that sniffed out in a second! If he doesn't get hit tonight, I think he should really be looked at.
 
Looks like these are the votes still to be made:

Agass
Dopehand
FD
Rich
TRS
 
Wonder if FD will come in and vote at the last minute again?
 
Also, I forgot to add Ice isn't gunning for you DD. To me that really really kinda seals the deal for me on both of you. If you DD were innocent and Ice was mafia, I would expect him to be all over you for the lack of vote. He said eh looks kinda suspicious and then threw his vote my way. Pretty much tells me you both are probably working on the same team.
 
You know Luv you are the 2nd person to say if I don't get hit tonight I must be mafia. In doing so don't you think the mafia would in turn hit someone else so the town can lynch me instead? Do us all a favor and have your team man up and take me out themselves.

I'm liking my vote. Of the 5 no votes I'd guess only 2 will vote as the other 3 seem distracted.

DD will move to Luv to force a tie, Noodles will move to 1 or the other to put them ahead, then it'll be up to Rich and FD who goes next or make it tie again.

Luv thinks I'm not kicking bushes. As you pointed out the Kash pm from last game I grasped the DD no vote. As the no vote saved you and I had my reservations about you grouping me in with DD on that joke I am voting you. I think you're both scum.


List

DD
Luv

possible

FD- the vote to save Luv and kill MC, as pointed out by Kash the subtle protection of DD and Luv.

Jm- the whole Dr thing

Rich- not liking the accepting of DDs no vote

Kash- not really liking the thought that if I'm not hit I'm mafia, if FD is innocent Kash is mafia or vice versa
 
rich311k said:
Agass, Dopehand, TRS any of you guys planning on even offering an opinion before night fall? We would all love to hear your thoughts.
Click to expand...

And FireDancer.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom