Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

[noodles62]

I don't think dope is mafia, and i don't even think luv is mafia. I just feel like people are pushing dopehand, because of small things that IMO don't point in the direction of mafia.

Can you give us any evidence to prove who is and who is not mafia? Just stating "I dont think" or " have a feeling' is not good enough. This is not a game based on psychic instincts.

 

[The Red Severum]

Fine, by the stuff dope has been posting, he has his own thoughts, which means he is not getting coached. Some people seem to be pushing dope for not apparent reason, where there is bigger subjects out there.

 

[noodles62]

Fine, by the stuff dope has been posting, he has his own thoughts, which means he is not getting coached. Some people seem to be pushing dope for not apparent reason, where there is bigger subjects out there.

Who are your top 3 suspects? I know one is JL, but who are the other 2?

 

[Luvbugz]

Who are the bigger people now TRS?? According to you, I was mafia. Now I am not. Noods was mafia. Now she isn't. So, who is mafia now??

I am hesistant to vote TRS. The reason being he is always erratic. Does erratic equal mafia?? I am not sure. I need more to go on with him. His behavior has been exploited by the mafia more than once, as the last games he was innocent. With that said, all of my mafia suspects have not been pointing fingers at all towards TRS. Makes me wonder why.....

 

[The Red Severum]

JL and AG for now, don't have a third one. I could say rich, but thats another dead end because he just flies under every ones radar. No one has brought me up, because there has been only 4 people posting the last 2 days.

 

[noodles62]

Who are the bigger people now TRS?? According to you, I was mafia. Now I am not. Noods was mafia. Now she isn't. So, who is mafia now??

I am hesistant to vote TRS. The reason being he is always erratic. Does erratic equal mafia?? I am not sure. I need more to go on with him. His behavior has been exploited by the mafia more than once, as the last games he was innocent. With that said, all of my mafia suspects have not been pointing fingers at all towards TRS. Makes me wonder why.....

Good points. I will think very carefully befroe I place a vote on him, if I do....I am trying to look at everyone and am getting a bit confused.....

Perhaps it is time for another list? time for another list. maybe this will help clear my mind.

Noods: innocent, of course!
Bugz: I am stuck on her role! Very well could be innocent but things arent sitting right for me......my vote is on her, but will most likely change.
Kashta: possibly mafia altho I am having a hard time coming up with a case against her. Would like to hear more from her today....
JM: Doc/innocent
Dope: leaning mafia for me right now.
TRS: radical play style, dangerous; possible mafia...?
Agass: not playing??? but that does not give him automatic innocence
Ice: very hard to read but has not given me any reasons to think mafia
Rich: very middle of the road - typical for Rich. Would love to hear more from him. I am concerned that no one has really "looked" at him....
JL: also hard to read, but again has not given me any reason to doubt him.

 

[noodles62]

Perhaps it is time for another list? time for another list. maybe this will help clear my mind.

Oops! Thought I corrected that!

 

[Luvbugz]

This is where my suspicions on Dope are building. He was here first day, but did not participate at all.

Originally Posted by jpappy789
Dopehand- was online today at 5:14 pm (CST)
JL- last post was yesterday morning in the sign up thread
Agassizii- on today at 4:13 pm (CST)
TRS- was on the site yesterday

(I think the times are correct)

So out of all of them only the total newbs were on AC today but have not posted...what are the chances that both pulled a 3L? LOL

I went back and pulled this up. Remember this?? Agass and Dope were on the first day and probably recieved their pms where as by the timing TRS and JL did not.

MC started by voting for Dope because he was on but not posting. Jpap pretty much talked him outta it. Read below:

I suppose that since there are no UDs the mafia would want to get non-participating players out of the way early, but that is assuming those players are still innocent.

I don't agree with that logic. Why would you want someone around not contributing...I mean on day one there is a 50/50 chance they are either mafia or innocent right? Yes in a lot of the games the UD's are innocent but you never really know till balla reveals their identity.

How did what I say not make sense? A lot of the time (almost every game) the UDs hurt the town's numbers. This time around the mafia have to get rid of them. They know who is who, so they can target lynch the possible players who would otherwise UD rather than waste a hit on them which could be put to better use, like ousting a vet.

Even if they are not participating, if they are innocent they still keep us in the game longer. I don't know, I tend to lean to Coler's side on this argument.

Basically it comes down to this: are you willing to take a chance if they are not scum?

Jpap protecting Dope??? That is what it looks like to me....

 

[Luvbugz]

Oh, BTW this reasoning is also why he voted for Noods who first voted for TRS.

 

[Luvbugz]

I am really horrible at muli - quoting. It is all on page three. It looks to me that Jpap is talking MC outta voting for Dope by saying he is probably innocent.