Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

[noodles62]

I am going to go ahead and move my vote. I was going to a few hours ago but wanted to wait.....JL has good instincts and if he is innocent, which I believe him to be, I will take his lead and vote for Dope. I see Dope as mafia more than I see Kashta...If I am wrong about JL, then I deserve to be hit tonite.

I retract my vote for Luvbugz and vote to lynch Dopehand.

 

[IceH2O]

This is where my suspicions on Dope are building. He was here first day, but did not participate at all.

Originally Posted by jpappy789
Dopehand- was online today at 5:14 pm (CST)
JL- last post was yesterday morning in the sign up thread
Agassizii- on today at 4:13 pm (CST)
TRS- was on the site yesterday

(I think the times are correct)

So out of all of them only the total newbs were on AC today but have not posted...what are the chances that both pulled a 3L? LOL

I went back and pulled this up. Remember this?? Agass and Dope were on the first day and probably recieved their pms where as by the timing TRS and JL did not.

MC started by voting for Dope because he was on but not posting. Jpap pretty much talked him outta it. Read below:









Jpap protecting Dope??? That is what it looks like to me....

See this is where you kill me.

Why is Jpap protecting Dopey and not Agi? Jpap pointed out that both of them were online to get their pms and knew the game had started.

I'm starting to think Kash is innocent and we've been right about you all this time. I also think Agi is mafia.

I retract my vote on Kash and vote to lynch Agi.

Luv saying pg 3 doesn't help me I don't know how many posts per page you use I use 40 so give me post numbers so I can check it out better.I'm going to look in the eman time but its much easier for others.


Noodles, all due respect but you're nuts. Are you buying Luvs reasoning? You were just voting her and now are voting for her latest suspect. I think you were right and Luv is mafia. I think JL is wrong about Dope. If Dopey wanted a good place to hide wouldn't it be best to have stayed on Fire and lynched a mafia?

 

[IceH2O]

Noods, there is a difference between hiding and not being on the site at all.

TRS was last logged on at 12:53 pm CST on Friday. The game started at 6:15 PM that same day. There is no way that TRS got his PM then, unless I am missing something here. TRS does not know his role therefore there is no way to say for sure that he is a mafia hiding.

And I am curious as to why you are giving JL a pass. He is in the same situation, and actually knows more about the game than TRS. It makes more sense to vote JL because he should be posting. But same thing, JL was last on AC on Friday and wouldn't have a PM. If anyone should be questioned it is Dopehand who was online yesterday but stil hasn't posted. Yet you go after TRS?

I vote to lynch Noodles

Best I got so far.

You missed a very important post Luv. Jpap voted Noodles for going after TRS not Dopey. Here Jpap is protecting TRS not Dopey. He actually thinks Dopey should be looked at out of the 3 named.

 

[IceH2O]

Start at post 108 and basically through 130 or so to get the full effect of what Luv is saying.

 

[noodles62]

See this is where you kill me.

Why is Jpap protecting Dopey and not Agi? Jpap pointed out that both of them were online to get their pms and knew the game had started.

I'm starting to think Kash is innocent and we've been right about you all this time. I also think Agi is mafia.

I retract my vote on Kash and vote to lynch Agi.

Luv saying pg 3 doesn't help me I don't know how many posts per page you use I use 40 so give me post numbers so I can check it out better.I'm going to look in the eman time but its much easier for others.


Noodles, all due respect but you're nuts. Are you buying Luvs reasoning? You were just voting her and now are voting for her latest suspect. I think you were right and Luv is mafia. I think JL is wrong about Dope. If Dopey wanted a good place to hide wouldn't it be best to have stayed on Fire and lynched a mafia?

I understand what you are saying and I know it looks odd that I voted Bugz and them moved to her top suspect. To be honest tho, I was thinking about voting Dope since this morning. I have said many times that I have a bad feeling about Bugz that wont go away. The past day or two you and her have had quite a bit of dialogue which "seemed" (my interpretaion) like you had her leaning innocent. I tried to use this to quell my suspicions. No one has been looking at or questioning Bugz for a few days (RL time) so I thought maybe I was the only one thinking that way, so I must be wrong. I would be happy to change my vote back to Luvbugz if I thought others would also. I see no point in being a lone vote on what is most likely my last night...

 

[noodles62]

See this is where you kill me.

Why is Jpap protecting Dopey and not Agi? Jpap pointed out that both of them were online to get their pms and knew the game had started.

I'm starting to think Kash is innocent and we've been right about you all this time. I also think Agi is mafia.

I retract my vote on Kash and vote to lynch Agi.

Luv saying pg 3 doesn't help me I don't know how many posts per page you use I use 40 so give me post numbers so I can check it out better.I'm going to look in the eman time but its much easier for others.


Noodles, all due respect but you're nuts. Are you buying Luvs reasoning? You were just voting her and now are voting for her latest suspect. I think you were right and Luv is mafia. I think JL is wrong about Dope. If Dopey wanted a good place to hide wouldn't it be best to have stayed on Fire and lynched a mafia?

if you think Bugz is prob maifa then why the vote on Agass and not her? I agree that Agass is prob mafia, and has been told to lay low. easiest way to keep him from getting lynched. We cannot win unless we take them all out. With FD and Jpap gone, that leaves Bugz at the helm and Agass in the wings......heart still beating.......

 

[IceH2O]

I understand what you are saying and I know it looks odd that I voted Bugz and them moved to her top suspect. To be honest tho, I was thinking about voting Dope since this morning. I have said many times that I have a bad feeling about Bugz that wont go away. The past day or two you and her have had quite a bit of dialogue which "seemed" (my interpretaion) like you had her leaning innocent. I tried to use this to quell my suspicions. No one has been looking at or questioning Bugz for a few days (RL time) so I thought maybe I was the only one thinking that way, so I must be wrong. I would be happy to change my vote back to Luvbugz if I thought others would also. I see no point in being a lone vote on what is most likely my last night...

If she had shown on the wanted poster I'd jump but she wasn't.

I did have her leaning innocent but some of the posts she puts out bother the heck out of me.

I want to see more and research more before I'd vote her. If I remember correctly she wouldn't vote Fire because I was there but she had no problem following me to Kash.

 

[IceH2O]

if you think Bugz is prob maifa then why the vote on Agass and not her? I agree that Agass is prob mafia, and has been told to lay low. easiest way to keep him from getting lynched. We cannot win unless we take them all out. With FD and Jpap gone, that leaves Bugz at the helm and Agass in the wings......heart still beating.......

Kind of answered it before I saw your post but to add..

I would only be the 2nd vote on Luv, no one else really has her as a suspect.That would tie her with Agi but keep JL close enough to have Agi sneak in with a vote and make it a 3 way tie. We'd risk losing JL. Also Rich has JL as a top suspect and he could cause a 3 way tie. Not to mention Kash won't stay on herself and we don't really know which way she'd go.

 

[noodles62]

If she had shown on the wanted poster I'd jump but she wasn't.

I did have her leaning innocent but some of the posts she puts out bother the heck out of me.

I want to see more and research more before I'd vote her. If I remember correctly she wouldn't vote Fire because I was there but she had no problem following me to Kash.

Her not being on the poster was another reason I have been doubting my judgement....

Kind of answered it before I saw your post but to add..

I would only be the 2nd vote on Luv, no one else really has her as a suspect.That would tie her with Agi but keep JL close enough to have Agi sneak in with a vote and make it a 3 way tie. We'd risk losing JL. Also Rich has JL as a top suspect and he could cause a 3 way tie. Not to mention Kash won't stay on herself and we don't really know which way she'd go.

Makes perfect sense. I retract my vote on Dopehand and vote to lynch Agassizii
That puts four votes on him; JM cannot change, so we are safe there. We shall see how the others play it out.

 

[IceH2O]

Rich, I'll address this to you because you're the one asking. I am the best target now. I drew so much suspicion because I went after Ice. And that put me in the middle of things along with JL and Ice. It's impossible for us tell whether to believe JL or Ice at this point because they're both too good and they've both been the most influential players we have. With all three of us still in the game, the town is going to keep going back and forth trying to figure out who they can listen to. But the odds that JL and Ice are BOTH mafia is extremely low. The only way the town will be able to choose between them now is if I'm gone.

Since Fire turned out to be mafia, we can afford to lose another innocent without it costing us as much. So take me out with the next lynch. My role will be revealed then as innocent then, but it won't matter as long as you make sure you also lynch either JL or Ice the very next night. (It doesn't matter which one you pick between JL or Ice, the town could flip a coin on that call.)

JM protected himself until he comes back to help us. I'll be gone from the lynch.... Noodles will get hit now... and either JL or Ice will also be gone. That leaves either JL or Ice (whichever survived) still to help you unravel this with JM still able to protect.

One of the things thing that kills me about Kash is this post. Jm isn't going to be back till Thursday so he can't protect,unless as pointed out by me earlier Z let him send in multiple protections to cover all nights till he gets back.

If we lynch Kash tonight and she is innocent then lynch me and I'm innocent natural reaction is lynch JL and we possibly lose 3 innocents.

If Kash is mafia then no one follows her idea and if JL has ben playing us he gets off free because obviously we don't take anything she says as truthful. This scenario coupled with the pointing out I still haven't been hit but not pointing out that JL also hasn't been hit is why I kept my vote on Kash for so long.

I'm still debating if I want to go back there or not but since JL isn't around to answer questions it might be the safer route to follow thru on Agi.