Mafia #53.5 Rock the Vote

I just don't know who to trust at this point and for rb to come out and plainly say he is detective and for everyone to believe him is what we have been doing the game and we have only taken out one mafia player. I hope dawg is mafia and we can get another mafia hung...I guess then it will be more believable for me follow Rb at that point but for now I am not following him.
 
jpappy789 said:
MC if Jm was a cop he would know the order of the investigations because he is allowed to communicate with the detective. I don't know where Rb claimed to be anything but the det either. If you are innocent, which I think you are, you are just playing into the mafia's hands by throwing out confusion.

I don't understand why there would be an extra investigation allowed unless it was a mistake by JL. It happens, and I've done it before as a mod. I really think JL should tell us if something outside the rules happened.

Dawg, don't you think the real detective would have come out by now? I think it's funny that you and noods (who I am 90% sure are in fact mafia) would try to disprove Rb and Jm rather than claim to be the detective yourself. That would have been a more effective strategy. Unless we were blessed with an inactive detective there should be no reason for them to sit back and let us be fooled by Rb and Jm.
Click to expand...

# 1. "if" Jm was indeed a cop why did he post 5 investigations when there have only been 4 nightfalls? And better yet, RB only posted 3. Can't seem to get thier stories straight.....

#2. If this is in fact the case then this entire game could be over.

#3. There still are 2 or 3 fairly inactive players, so this could in fact be the case. I still call BS on RB's claim as the detective.
 
mostlycichlids said:
I just don't know who to trust at this point and for rb to come out and plainly say he is detective and for everyone to believe him is what we have been doing the game and we have only taken out one mafia player. I hope dawg is mafia and we can get another mafia hung...I guess then it will be more believable for me follow Rb at that point but for now I am not following him.
Click to expand...
Give me one reason why Rb would pull a stunt like this if her was not the detective.

Dawg was the leading candidate as I have already pointed out. If he was innocent all Rb and Jm would have to do is sit back and let him be lynched...they win.

Even if lucky is mafia and still lynching an innocent meant the game would not end after tonight, they would know that so lynching a hypothetically innocent Dawg would just get both of them into trouble the next day.

I just don't see any way around this.
 
jpappy789 said:
Ok.

So we have lynched four people (Kash, Luv, Wycco, Rocker), which means four nightfalls.

That means four investigation results. Plus an extra one they received during day 1.

Sounds believable to me.
Click to expand...
makes me wonder if they knew Kash was the doctor...
 
jpappy789 said:
MC if Jm was a cop he would know the order of the investigations because he is allowed to communicate with the detective. I don't know where Rb claimed to be anything but the det either. If you are innocent, which I think you are, you are just playing into the mafia's hands by throwing out confusion.
Click to expand...
You are right he only said he was the detective...I had to go back and read...I must of got confused. I am just more curious of why they wait till now to start helping the town esp. after a couple cops have already died.
 
noodles62 said:
# 1. "if" Jm was indeed a cop why did he post 5 investigations when there have only been 4 nightfalls? And better yet, RB only posted 3. Can't seem to get thier stories straight.....

#2. If this is in fact the case then this entire game could be over.

#3. There still are 2 or 3 fairly inactive players, so this could in fact be the case. I still call BS on RB's claim as the detective.
Click to expand...
Please read JL's latest post, think it over, then post...
 
mostlycichlids said:
You are right he only said he was the detective...I had to go back and read...I must of got confused. I am just more curious of why they wait till now to start helping the town esp. after a couple cops have already died.
Click to expand...
we are down to the wire right now, and with the number of cops down, we decided it was better to have Rb and I come forward to get rid of at least two mafia.
 
jpappy789 said:
Please read JL's latest post, think it over, then post...
Click to expand...

not sure if you are referring to point # 1, 2 or 3. can you clarify?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom