Mafia 54:Vampires Return (The Play)

[paperdragon]

Wycco and Coler are still at the top of my list.

 

[Zaffy]

Zaffy,

This just about seals it for me -



Now, as far as I know, lanimret has never played mafia, but they claim to know you pretty well.

I know you are new and I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt, too many new players think winning is not getting killed, but that is not the case. It is about teams. A team that knows who their teamates are and a team that has to figure out who their teamates are.

I am not suprised you have not voted yet. Any suspects?

Lanimret and I were roommates long ago, and I was best man in his wedding. So, I guess you could say we know each other. But he's never played mafia with me. It's true that I'm not the type of person to throw someone under a bus so I can get ahead.

I'm the only person I know for a fact that is on my team. So doesn't that mean I should protect myself over Kash and DD who I'm uncertain about? The fact is, they each had about an 11% chance to be scum. I know that I had a 0% chance to be scum. So the safest bet for the town was for me to save myself.

I got my numbers from 19 players in the game. Of those, 18 roles are not known to me. 2 vampires at the time, so 2/18=11.1% that anyone else is a vampire. This is the only thing I knew for certain.

 

[johnlarson66]

jpap,

I thought I skimmed! The post was to Zaffy.

Here it is again -

Zaffy,

This just about seals it for me -



Now, as far as I know, lanimret has never played mafia, but they claim to know you pretty well.

I know you are new and I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt, too many new players think winning is not getting killed, but that is not the case. It is about teams. A team that knows who their teamates are and a team that has to figure out who their teamates are.

I am not suprised you have not voted yet. Any suspects?

 

[Zaffy]

...

I am not suprised you have not voted yet. Any suspects?

I forgot to address your direct question.

I do have suspects, I think giving a list is a great way to give the vampire team intelligence reports on who's hot and who's not.

I have not voted because I want to vote for who's in 2nd place behind me later in the day. It's the only logical vote for me at this time.

 

[Coler]

Jpap - I lean him innocent
RB - I am frustrated by his non participation. I can't call him (yes my vote is on him, looking to prod him into contributing something but to no avail). Innocent or Scum he is not helping right now.
Zsand - Gun to my head I lean him innocent. This is no real reflection on his likely status this early in the game however.
Jm - JM I have as a weak suspicion.
Annie - is this person even playing ? I can say nothing about Annie.
Kash - At this point having flipped and flopped a touch, I have Kashta as a suspect.
Ogre - Same comments as regarding ZS/
Zaffy - I have Zaffy as a suspect.
Noodles - I have no sense of Noodles at all.
Dawg - I have little to no sense of Dawg at all. I would not go so far as to say I lean them innocent.
Rocker - Same comment as for Dawg.
Wycco - I lean innocent.
DD - dead lynched known innocent.
Phoenixn7g - UD known innocent
Lanimret - I don't know. The fact that he and Zaffy know each other in real life is sort of concerning. I do indeed remember the game where wchicken was in this position with her partner. It does make me think that if Zaffy is a vampire he would be pretty comfortable reccomending a turn of Lanimret, who is of course very low on the radar as a total newb. As I have Zaffy as a suspect I must also I think consider Lanimret a suspect albeit with some reservations.
Rich - I don't know.
Paperdragon - I don't know.
JL - My hunchy suspicion is still present. JL is not posting with his usual fluency in my opinion. Whether that is because he is a vamp is of course not certain.

So my top pick is Zaffy. I then have...I guess Kashta.

My weak suspicions are Lam, JL, JM.

I'm hacked off at the non-participation - I'm sure that either there are good real life reasons for it (happens to the best of us) or it is a vampiric ploy (fair nuff play your game boys and girls).

Joking aside lets get some lists up as detailed as you can. It doesn't even matter so much whether you're right or wrong or what not - the main purpose would be so that if you are innocent and turned there is some record to refer back to, i.e. a complete reversal without good justification would stick out.

 

[johnlarson66]

JL, you are all over the place...

You quoted lanimret's vote and then said "I am not suprised you have not voted yet. Any suspects?"

HUH!? they voted in that same post.

You're usually a top poster in the game and are notorious for digging through posts, but right now you're creating more confusion than dirt...at least for me anyways.

The Kash v. Coler mini-showdown has a new twist...JL. I don't see the three being teammates just trying to stir up a bunch of controversy although since Zaffy is on the block and not Kashta I could see that plan working for the time being.

All I know is that the interactions between those three have been quite distracting and I'm pretty much ignoring it for now.

Suspect list:

Coler
Kash
Ogre
JL
maybe rocker or rb just because of how they are playing

Yeah I know there are only 3 vamps right now but probably only one or two on that list I would actually switch to voting for.

I already responded to the first part, but then there is the rest of the post. This part - "All I know is that the interactions between those three have been quite distracting and I'm pretty much ignoring it for now."

Then all three of us are on your suspect list. Did Zaffy turn you?

 

[noodles62]

I forgot to address your direct question.

I do have suspects, I think giving a list is a great way to give the vampire team intelligence reports on who's hot and who's not.

I have not voted because I want to vote for who's in 2nd place behind me later in the day. It's the only logical vote for me at this time.

hhmmmm, not wanting to put your suspicions and thoughts out there for the good of the town is not good. It helps no one except yourself. I also see that you intend to help yourself again with a late vote to save your skin. Not very townie like. The idea is to help eachother see things that are suspicious not hide and keep info to our selves....

 

[Coler]

Wycco and Coler are still at the top of my list.

Good gravy as flattering as it is I have no idea what I've done to deserve it.

I forgot to address your direct question.

I do have suspects, I think giving a list is a great way to give the vampire team intelligence reports on who's hot and who's not.

I have not voted because I want to vote for who's in 2nd place behind me later in the day. It's the only logical vote for me at this time.

Flat out wrong, in a game with turns in particular.

 

[jm1212]

Lanimret and I were roommates long ago, and I was best man in his wedding. So, I guess you could say we know each other. But he's never played mafia with me. It's true that I'm not the type of person to throw someone under a bus so I can get ahead.

I'm the only person I know for a fact that is on my team. So doesn't that mean I should protect myself over Kash and DD who I'm uncertain about? The fact is, they each had about an 11% chance to be scum. I know that I had a 0% chance to be scum. So the safest bet for the town was for me to save myself.

I got my numbers from 19 players in the game. Of those, 18 roles are not known to me. 2 vampires at the time, so 2/18=11.1% that anyone else is a vampire. This is the only thing I knew for certain.

while you may say that you are innocent, in reality, it looks more scummy than not. if Lan was being truthful, it would not be a thing that you were likely to do. if you had been "staked" and turned up innocent, then the people that voted to get rid of you would most likely be watched more carefully and cross-examined, which could lead to finding a vampire.

 

[Rbishop]

I'd like to hear RBishop's opinions- he's been hiding in the shadows only getting the bare minimum one line that doesn't say anything commital in it now and again.

Do you have a suspect list yet R. Bishop?




Yes, but as I said in an earlier post- the one that concerns me most in that list is JL. I can understand Kashta and Coler were pretty much arguing about symmantics- rather blind accusations at each other... but JL seemed to me to be egging them on. His backing against Kashta when she was lead- and then switching to Zaffy the moment he became lead also strikes me as a little "convenient".

To me in the battle of Kashta vs Coler, JL is the one that comes out looking suspicious.

Yes, but it is pretty short and not founded on much besdies irritation...but it really could be just a heat rash too...