Mafia 56. An Unknown Evil. THE GAME....

It isn't a ploy Ogre. If you are our town assassin like you say, why wouldn't I want to keep you in the game??
 
c'mon Ogre...what are your thoughts above any of the people who are in fact voting for you. You're not searching out for anyone else yourself - just fingering those who are questioning you.

Luvbugz...I don't get it, you say that one hit sounds mafia (the pappy one) but perhaps Ogre is telling the truth - but if Ogre hit pappy and your reading of wyccos style is accurate....this hit would sound town not mafia.

this 'lynch me lynch me its the only way' sounds like new levels of bs, when at the same time you're suggesting that the people who are 'out to get you' are also evil - they are surely just taking your advice...oh yeah...except you're just pointing at e.g. me for some reason despite the fact that I havn't even voted for you. lololol.
 
actually I would love to ID some other suspects...but last we heard there were no confirmed cases of possession, and I reckon there is 1 or at the absolute max 2 more KGB (and I do think its more likely to be 3 in total)...so its not like there's a huge pool available...
 
well, i might as well jump on the train and vote ogre, this vote is prob. a tempory vote tho. ill see what else i can dig up from going back in the thread.


I vote to lynch Ogre.
 
Holy cow guys, the Ogre/Coler back and forth today was a great read and will hopefully tell us something.

OgreMkV said:
Again, I'd just like to remind everyone that most everyone is using (as a basis to lynch me) arguments and information that I have already stated and freely admitted too.

Just my opinion, I think all the KGB is dead. There's just not enough room in this game for 3 KGB, an equivalent number of CIA, and then an undead and anti-undead teams. If there's 2 of each on these teams, that's 8 players out of 15, add in the mayor and that's nine. If each team has 3 players, then that's a total of 13 out of the 15 players. And then, everyone has a role, which is what I said in the beginning.

Good luck guys.
Click to expand...

Ogre here's the thing. I kind of want to believe you because I still can't figure why you would have slipped KGB if you were one. There is only one way I could see it happening. If you are KGB but can not communicate you could have named that list of past roles and inserted KGB hoping everyone would gloss over it except for the other KGB. But since the whole point of the game is picking up on these kind of details you should have known it would be noticed. I dunno it becomes WIFOM after that.

OgreMkV said:
Coler, I said Kash was innocent, you jumped me on it, then you have her as innocent.

Kash posted the sequence of events and makes what I consider an invalid assumption, yet you consider her to be 100% accurate.

Kash, how are there 3 assassination attempts last night and how do you know one failed???

Let me try this again. I KNOW THAT JPAP WAS NOT KILLED BY THE KGB!
Click to expand...
Eeek, why did you use your powers on Day 1? Is that part of your role? Why was Pappy such a likely target?
Luvbugz said:
Okay bear with me because I am thinking out loud now:

Notice the difference in deaths?? One sounds very mafia (CIA, KGB, whatever you wanna call it) with concrete blocks. The other one is more mysterious with the person just dropping dead. This is the only thing right now that makes me thinking Ogre might be telling the truth. He could quite possibly be the CIA assassin that screwed up and took out our mayor. Since we know the evils are pretty much out to work for themselves, the other could be a demon, undead, vampire whatever you wanna call it assassin that decided to take out JL.

I am really not sure what to think at the moment. I am almost tempted to pull my vote from Ogre and let our townie assassin take him out. Even if he is our townie assassin, I do believe he will be taken out by the other assassin. If he isn't, the townie assassin will take care of him for us. See what I am saying here??

I do think as a town we are over focusing on one person and letting the other evils slink back outta the limelight. I would like to see other people's lists of who they think is/isn't suspicious (besides Ogre).
Click to expand...
We have to lynch Ogre. Why you ask? If we let Ogre go another day then if there are KGB or other Evil roles out there they will take him out. Which means the Town will lynch another player and there is a chance we take out an Innocent. So if we let Ogre go we risk loses an extra Innocent for our trouble. PLUS, by knowing Ogre's role we can validate the things he has said over the past few days.
 
ZSandmann said:
Holy cow guys, the Ogre/Coler back and forth today was a great read and will hopefully tell us something.



Ogre here's the thing. I kind of want to believe you because I still can't figure why you would have slipped KGB if you were one. There is only one way I could see it happening. If you are KGB but can not communicate you could have named that list of past roles and inserted KGB hoping everyone would gloss over it except for the other KGB. But since the whole point of the game is picking up on these kind of details you should have known it would be noticed. I dunno it becomes WIFOM after that.


Eeek, why did you use your powers on Day 1? Is that part of your role? Why was Pappy such a likely target?

We have to lynch Ogre. Why you ask? If we let Ogre go another day then if there are KGB or other Evil roles out there they will take him out. Which means the Town will lynch another player and there is a chance we take out an Innocent. So if we let Ogre go we risk loses an extra Innocent for our trouble. PLUS, by knowing Ogre's role we can validate the things he has said over the past few days.
Click to expand...


That makes sense.
 
I just hate that no one else is really speaking up. I see people viewing the thread, but no one else is adding their two cents on this matter. Seeing alot of vote and runs. (Or post some jibberish and then run).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom