Mafia 56. An Unknown Evil. THE GAME....

[Dangerdoll]

Ogre, what are your thoughts on Annie?

 

[jpappy789]

Pass the butter Noods

opcorn:

 

[OgreMkV]

[/COLOR]

That makes sense.

ummm... isn't that what I said.

Ogre, what are your thoughts on Annie?

The reason I voted Annie the first day was because Annie originally didn't want to vote me. After that, it didn't matter what I did... so I left my vote there.

Then there's the whole saving one's self. While, in principle, I agree that innocents should do this, and it was day one, I think it's better to have a conviction about someone and vote them regardless of your own fate (I hear a pot shouting "kettle, thou art black").

Then in post #325, Annie says that last game he was acting to do what was best for the town... I leave it to you to decide if self sacrifice or sacrificing another is in the town's best interest.

So that's one post today... I'd say that Annie is more of a suspect than most. No reason to voting me (unlike Coler and some of the others), just a defense and a vote for me and nothing.

I could see voting Annie at this point.

 

[Wycco]

52800 seconds until night fall... (9pm eastern US tonight)

Just a recap of votes:

7
Ogre: LuvBugz (278) DirtyDawg10 (281) Ice (282) DangerDoll (288) Annie (325) ZSand (330) Rocker (374)
1
Coler: Ogre (344)

4
Not Yet Voted
Kash, Rich, Coler, JM

DEAD:
Phoenix - Lynched
JohnL - Killed by a game player
JPappy - Killed by a game player

 

[Coler]

Quiet night, I hate when one candidate gets run like this. Compare Day 1 where we had three suspects versus today where it is pretty much unanimous to lynch Ogre.

agree

I just hate that no one else is really speaking up. I see people viewing the thread, but no one else is adding their two cents on this matter. Seeing alot of vote and runs. (Or post some jibberish and then run).

agree x 2

ummm... isn't that what I said.



The reason I voted Annie the first day was because Annie originally didn't want to vote me. After that, it didn't matter what I did... so I left my vote there.

Then there's the whole saving one's self. While, in principle, I agree that innocents should do this, and it was day one, I think it's better to have a conviction about someone and vote them regardless of your own fate (I hear a pot shouting "kettle, thou art black").

Then in post #325, Annie says that last game he was acting to do what was best for the town... I leave it to you to decide if self sacrifice or sacrificing another is in the town's best interest.

So that's one post today... I'd say that Annie is more of a suspect than most. No reason to voting me (unlike Coler and some of the others), just a defense and a vote for me and nothing.

I could see voting Annie at this point.

eh lol etc. I havn't voted you Ogre - I've been giving you every chance to put yourself out of the frame. If in fact you are who you say you are the last thing the town wants to do is to lose another power role, to a lynch or otherwise (DD is 99% a lost power role due to not being able to perform exorcisms).

its interesting that there is no one putting up a defence of Ogre. This is either because he's innocent as he claims, or he is the last KGB team member.

If the latter, that really goes some distance to explain why there is no other suspect at this point in time. Whoever is a demon/devil-worshipper/possessing type would seem to have no reason as a member of a distinct and KGB opposing evil team to try and help out the KGB. He/She/They would equally be happy to have an innocent up for the lynch.

What is most sticky regarding Ogre for me includes his advising us all to take a close look at who is pushing him for the lynch when he turns up innocent, and then naming me as a suspect for that reason. He pretty much had all his current votes before I ever started asking him questions. Albeit that I voted him last night I didn't then see myself as campaigning for his lynch necessarily. I would have thought if he was being bona fide he would have been much more curious about the quiet votes on him. This has elements of OMGUS to it.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

ummm... isn't that what I said.



The reason I voted Annie the first day was because Annie originally didn't want to vote me. After that, it didn't matter what I did... so I left my vote there.

Ummmmm...I did vote for you. When did I not want to vote for you. In fact, I was the first vote on you.

Then there's the whole saving one's self. While, in principle, I agree that innocents should do this, and it was day one, I think it's better to have a conviction about someone and vote them regardless of your own fate (I hear a pot shouting "kettle, thou art black").

Then in post #325, Annie says that last game he was acting to do what was best for the town... I leave it to you to decide if self sacrifice or sacrificing another is in the town's best interest.

In that game the Vamps were getting closer and closer to finding out Doctor. So I had the idea to allude to being the Doctor, so they would kill/turn me, and the Doctor would be safe another night. Yes, this was in the towns best interest IMO. Why are you trying to snow me???

So that's one post today... I'd say that Annie is more of a suspect than most. No reason to voting me (unlike Coler and some of the others), just a defense and a vote for me and nothing.

I'm voting for you, because I think the whole KGB/CIA thing is scummy.

I could see voting Annie at this point.

I have alot of RL issues. Weekends at my house are ridiculous. Hedonism at its worst.

Anyone who thinks I'm scum should vote for me. I am voting for who I think is scum.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Ogre, what are your thoughts on Annie?? He was actually the first person to vote for you. You came out yesterday wondering why there was a train on him. (Both Jpap and Phoniex voted for him).

Actually JPap voted for Ogre

 

[dirtydawg10]

well, i might as well jump on the train and vote ogre, this vote is prob. a tempory vote tho. ill see what else i can dig up from going back in the thread.


I vote to lynch Ogre.

So any luck digging anything up?

just some thinking out of the box here...

what if jpap was a double agent? since there are no set roles here, for all we know he could have been the leader of the KGB AND the town, with neither knowing who he was.

I doubt JPap would try to lynch Ogre for being KGB if he himself was a KGB double agent as you suggest.


We have about 9hrs until nightfall and still have several people who haven't voted. Granted due to the rules, voting is not required every night...but not voting will look very suspicious IMO. Do the non voters have any suspect lists? or do you plan to place a vote and help the town figure this thing out?

 

[dirtydawg10]

^should say...

I doubt JPap would try to lynch Ogre for being 'SUSPECTED' KGB if he himself was a KGB double agent as you suggest.

 

[rich311k]

I have read this several times and the only logical thing to do is vote for Ogre. There must be others suspects but no one is standing out. Since we have a run away lynch no one is going to be talking. We do not get much in the way of info that way but it is what it is. There is a pretty solid case on Ogre as well and we need to find out what he is.

I vote to lynch Ogre.