Mafia 58-

[IceH2O]

Those are the 2 journalists. If 1 dies, Ice isn't going to tell us all the headlines are being written by the remaining one.

I don't see how not to disregard the headline completely as this is, though. It's bad enough when the town doesn't know which team the headline writer is on, but when we already know it's a 50-50 chance which one gets their headline printed each time... and no two headlines in a row might even come from the same player... that's just messy as hell.

A headline that tells us Player XYZ is evil, for example... what good is that going to do us at all? I don't see any value in that as a possible hint for us.

Both headlines will be printed nightly IF sent in. You just won't know which one belongs to which team.

 

[noodles62]

Those are the 2 journalists. If 1 dies, Ice isn't going to tell us all the headlines are being written by the remaining one.

I don't see how not to disregard the headline completely as this is, though. It's bad enough when the town doesn't know which team the headline writer is on, but when we already know it's a 50-50 chance which one gets their headline printed each time... and no two headlines in a row might even come from the same player... that's just messy as hell.

A headline that tells us Player XYZ is evil, for example... what good is that going to do us at all? I don't see any value in that as a possible hint for us.

do we know it is a 50/50 chance who's headline gets posted?
I am curious to see with both of them alive right now, if we will get to different headlines? Puts a confusing twist into the game.....if i skimmed this , then shoot me now. :

 

[noodles62]

just read the rules agaan and it does not state that only one headline will get posted, just that we will not know who/which side it is from....

pasted from the rules....

One non communicating innocent and 1 non communicating mafia will get investigations.
They will also be able to publish a newspaper headline. You will not know which side the headlines are from.

 

[noodles62]

never mind - Ice replied in the interim....

 

[Kashta]

Both headlines will be printed nightly IF sent in. You just won't know which one belongs to which team.

That's even better. So Ice, if we kill off one of your journalists.. there'll only be one headline printed each day after that?

Are you going to supply a fake second headline in that case to cover up the fact the one was killed? Otherwise, what's the point behind NOT telling us the dead non-communicator was also a journalist when you reveal their role?

 

[IceH2O]

That's even better. So Ice, if we kill off one of your journalists.. there'll only be one headline printed each day after that?

Are you going to supply a fake second headline in that case to cover up the fact the one was killed? Otherwise, what's the point behind NOT telling us the dead non-communicator was also a journalist when you reveal their role?

Nope won't be rolling another headline...

The point is you won't know if the mafia or innocent journalist died so you won't know who the headline is from.

Also they can just not send one in to confuse you even more.

 

[IceH2O]

IT IS NIGHT

 

[IceH2O]

The town with a 50% chance at nabbing a mafia are all over the place with early votes.Only 3 players did not have a vote placed on them.

After Woods revelation the tide turned to another. The player of which no one trusts because of their willingness to hide their identity.

They drag the Gunslinger to Bala and hoist the rope high.

Gunslinger is dead

As Gun swings in the air something falls from his pocket.

A bottle of whiskey. Gun was the Hobo

 

[IceH2O]

Woods retraction and non revote puzzles the town. They go to look for him and find him dead.

Cause of death is testicular elephantiasis. This was only figured out days later during autopsy. With the naked eye his testicles were no bigger then chickpeas. **** they must have been tiny beforehand lol.

Wood was a non communicating mafia.

 

[dirtydawg10]

:rofl: