Mafia 58-

jpappy789 said:
DD...in cased you missed it.

15 players, minus the hobo.
7 mafia (3 communicating, 4 non communicating)
7 innocent (3 communicating, 4 non communicating)
Click to expand...

ok - since I am bored and you brought up the Hobo...what significance does he have, other than a live body? He is not on either side and has no powers.......I have read over the rules multiple times and cannot figure it out.....just curious and thinking out loud.....usually gets me into trouble but hubby is ticking me off right now so I have to talk to someone! LOL
 
noodles62 said:
ok - since I am bored and you brought up the Hobo...what significance does he have, other than a live body? He is not on either side and has no powers.......I have read over the rules multiple times and cannot figure it out.....just curious and thinking out loud.....usually gets me into trouble but hubby is ticking me off right now so I have to talk to someone! LOL
Click to expand...

On this, what I figured was Ice intended to have 4 communicating on each side... but we were short one player. So there are 3 communicators instead... and the hobo role is the odd man out..... or that other player who would have been on one of the communicating teams had one more person signed up to play.

That's the only reason I can see why someone is playing in a neutral position. To keep the 50-50 split even.
 
Sorry guys football games had my attention


PMs as required Night fall in 40 minutes


Vote tally

Woody-3- Jbradt TRS Kash

MC -1- Annie

Gun-4- Ogre Noods Zaffy Jpap

Jpap-1- DD

Annie-3- Z MC Rich

Kash-1 Gun

Z-1- Dawg

No vote Wood
 
Kashta said:
On this, what I figured was Ice intended to have 4 communicating on each side... but we were short one player. So there are 3 communicators instead... and the hobo role is the odd man out..... or that other player who would have been on one of the communicating teams had one more person signed up to play.

That's the only reason I can see why someone is playing in a neutral position. To keep the 50-50 split even.
Click to expand...


Makes sense....
 
Need to ammend a role.

The players on the non communicating teams with headline/invest capabilities upon death will not have that part of their role revealed. You will only know that they were either non communicating innocent/mafia.
 
IceH2O said:
Sorry guys football games had my attention


PMs as required Night fall in 40 minutes


Vote tally

Woody-3- Jbradt TRS Kash

MC -1- Annie

Gun-4- Ogre Noods Zaffy Jpap

Jpap-1- DD

Annie-3- Z MC Rich

Kash-1 Gun

Z-1- Dawg

No vote Wood
Click to expand...

So Gun has 4 right now while Woody and Annie have 3. And Wood hasn't shown up to vote yet, if he's going to.

Gun playing under an alias is cool to hide their identity. But for them hang back and not participate in the game or try to help the town in any way seems particularly scummy... alias or not. I don't really care who the player is or their reason for playing under a fake name... but it's reasonable to assume this is a veteran and I agree the player must be hiding something more than their identity. So if Gun gets lynched after all, I don't mind that as tonight's outcome. But.. there's no need for me to get omgussy about their voting me for no reason... so I'm not planning to vote Gun at this point.

I'll hold my vote where it is to keep Wood close to the lynch. If Woody does hit the thread with a last-minute vote to avoid UDing.. I hope someone not voting him now is considering a switch to help us boot him out of the game. And that they're able to vote Wood too in time. Wood wasn't just anti-town today, he's anti-game.
 
IceH2O said:
Need to ammend a role.

The players on the non communicating teams with headline/invest capabilities upon death will not have that part of their role revealed. You will only know that they were either non communicating innocent/mafia.
Click to expand...

Those are the 2 journalists. If 1 dies, Ice isn't going to tell us all the headlines are being written by the remaining one.

I don't see how not to disregard the headline completely as this is, though. It's bad enough when the town doesn't know which team the headline writer is on, but when we already know it's a 50-50 chance which one gets their headline printed each time... and no two headlines in a row might even come from the same player... that's just messy as hell.

A headline that tells us Player XYZ is evil, for example... what good is that going to do us at all? I don't see any value in that as a possible hint for us.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom