Mafia 58-

[noodles62]

(snip)
I retract my vote for Annie and vote to lynch Zaffy

You're already on Annie Noods... :screwy:

Heh I was going off Ice's most recent tally.

I stand corrected.

:silly: not that it really matters. Im gonna go shower................

 

[Dangerdoll]

Pappy, from your list up there, it is showing that neither you or Dawg have each other as possible suspects. Care to explain to me why you don't seem to find any suspicion in Dawg?

Dawg, same goes for you. Care to explain what clears Paps for you?

 

[IceH2O]

Night fall in 45 mins +/-

PMs as required


Vote tally

Dawg-3- DD Rich Ogre

Rich-3- TRS Jbradt Zsand

DD-3- Jpap Dawg Zaffy

Jpap-1- Kash

MC-1- Annie

Zaffy-1- Noods

no vote from MC

 

[dirtydawg10]

Pappy, from your list up there, it is showing that neither you or Dawg have each other as possible suspects. Care to explain to me why you don't seem to find any suspicion in Dawg?

Dawg, same goes for you. Care to explain what clears Paps for you?

Where did I say JPap was cleared for me? I just have suspects who rank higher than JPap on my list is all.

 

[mostlycichlids]

Hit and run posts??? Scumbags. Anyone voting for me because of hit and run posts is scummy as hell. Especially you Noods.

MC why did you build a case for me, then vote for Woody??
"some would say I was building a case for woody then voted for you?"

Woodward, what can I really say to you? You're a rotten scumbag, but only in RL, I doubt now you're really a scumbag in game. I hope your UD is tremendously embarrassing.

I retract my vote for numbnuts..*cough*..Woodward, and vote to lynch MC.

Smooth

Noods, I find it interesting that ZS has posted less than the moderator at this point, yet you don't mention him at all. You chose your reason for voting me for being quiet??? Strange indeed.

I vote to lynch MC- MC made a post about Woody that he ended with a vote for me. Thats a scummy move, and he has not addressed it although I asked twice why he was voting for me.

My watchlist:

MC -scumbag extrodinare
Rich- a feeling
ZS- a normally active and helpful player, Z literally has less posts than the mod on Day 2. Laying low Z??? Maybe you'll post if you start seeing your name in bold more often.
Noods- Noods is evil every game I think

Though Kashta's theories about me are "tinfoil" as Zaffy would say, I will admit openly I have her leaning innocent at this point.

So you are still trying to build a case against me for voting you and not woody, I am not going to vote someone that is going to UD....I thought about changing my vote but when he decided to UD I kept my vote where it was. Nothing more to say really at this point....I don't feel you are mafia but you posts always make me curious...I voted you because I had no other suspects....I could of easily voted anyone else as well but I chose not to change with it being 50/50 why not.

Ok, so the only people who didn't vote Wood at some point (and are still around) were Zsand, MC, DD, Rich, and Ogre.

Zs- wasn't really around. Would like to hear his thoughts.

MC- Annie makes a good point about him building a small case for Wood but then saying that he doesn't like the train.

DD- made ONE comment on wood acting strange.

Ogre- first pointed out Wood placing the third vote, but sort of downplayed the train vote as it went on. Less subtle about it though.

Rich- I have to say that I agree with what jb said. He has a few one-liners but never insinuates that Wood is one way or the other.

I do understand that Wood being a non-communicator means that connecting him to a team is nearly impossible, especially at this point. What interests me more is the fact that certain people were wishy-washy about Wood. It was pretty obvious to some people that he was more likely mafia than the rest of the vote getters yesterday. It intrigues me that others avoided it almost entirely. Too afraid of making a splash perhaps?

Based on this my new suspect list is:

DD
Rich
MC
Annie- because of day 1 still.

Why would I vote for a player UDing? And I really don't see where I built a "case" for woody....I quoted a few shady posts.....thats it.

Kash, do you see it more scummy to switch votes off a player who is clearly planning to UD (which is done quite often) or to hide a vote on a player who is planning to UD anyway so you have nothing to lose?

I wasn't personally concerned about Wood coming back to place a vote because if he did it would be his death sentence. We wouldn't have even had to play the 2nd day because he would have received all the votes. Not to mention that Ice would have killed him off anyway.

As far as your other comments about a supposed "mafia team"...is it typical for mafia to follow each other openly in posts and have a similar voting record in order to hide their allegiances or is it easier for mafia to hide by being all over the map? If you believe the first part is a better strategy then you should vote for Noods and Rich right now because Wood said they were backing him up

I see your logic here dawg.

I vote to lynch Dawg for no reason at all.

I had a vertigo attack about 5 yeaterday and hae no read anything past that point. Dawg was least likely to have a lot of votes on him and I'm not going to get on a train without reading at this point.

I probably will not finish by nightfall. I have to lay down for a while and drug up a bit. Be back later.

WOW?

I know I haven't said much but have been pre-occupied this week.

I vote to lynch jpappy

 

[jpappy789]

Pappy, from your list up there, it is showing that neither you or Dawg have each other as possible suspects. Care to explain to me why you don't seem to find any suspicion in Dawg?

Dawg, same goes for you. Care to explain what clears Paps for you?

DD what makes you think I don't have Dawg as a possible suspect?

I don't have Noodles, Zsand, Jb, Kash, TRS, Zaffy, or Ogre on that list either. Some I haven't even mentioned. So using your logic I cleared them too...Wrong.

If you really want to know my stance...I don't have a feeling either way on Dawg, and I certainly haven't seen anything that sticks out to me as scummy. But the fact that my top suspect (you) have targeted him, lowers him on my radar. But I have never cleared him or made any indication of that.

 

[Kashta]

There are only 3 on the mafia team. So who is it...Me, Dawg, and Zaffy? Me, Dawg, and Annie?

You seem have me and Dawg pretty much locked into the positions. So either I distanced from and then saved Annie or the three on DD (who also tried to save Wood) are all mafia...which is it? Or did we magically pick up on another non-communicating teammate on Day 1?

Again, you're being deceptive, Pappy. There aren't 3 on a mafia team, there are (were) 7 on the mafia team.... it's just that 3 can talk directly while the other 4 couldn't.

As far as which ones are communicating and which aren't... that's hardly the point once they start to deduce who else is on their side. One of the non-communicators gets to investigate and one of those investigation results would've been received last night. The disconnected teammates watch others closely to determine who their named suspects are... who is being protected, defended, or ignored.... and who the final votes land on. This isn't that obscure... there are many BASIC ways for the scum to figure out who their teammates are and simply follow the lead they observe in the thread. Nothing magical about that.

 

[dirtydawg10]

because then we could finish what we should have done last nightfall.

Yet you are not voting for Annie tonight or last night for that matter. :huh:

 

[jpappy789]

MC: you quoted one post of mine where I have you on my suspect list, then end it with a vote. Is it purely an OMGUS or is there an actual reason.

Btw, your little case (really just a justification for voting Wood) was well before he announced his UD.

 

[jpappy789]

Again, you're being deceptive, Pappy. There aren't 3 on a mafia team, there are (were) 7 on the mafia team.... it's just that 3 can talk directly while the other 4 couldn't.

As far as which ones are communicating and which aren't... that's hardly the point once they start to deduce who else is on their side. One of the non-communicators gets to investigate and one of those investigation results would've been received last night. The disconnected teammates watch others closely to determine who their named suspects are... who is being protected, defended, or ignored.... and who the final votes land on. This isn't that obscure... there are many BASIC ways for the scum to figure out who their teammates are and simply follow the lead they observe in the thread. Nothing magical about that.

Yes, but your whole theory connecting the four of us (Me, Dawg, Zaffy, Annie) is based off of behind the scenes protecting and vote retractions/placement. Kind of hard to do when only 3/4 of those people can communicate, don't you think?

For me to do any distancing from Annie that early, I would have to be on a team with him. That leaves Zaffy out and thus your whole thing about the vote following falls through.

If Zaffy, Dawg, and I are teammates then I would not try to save Annie by voting Gun w/o knowing that he is non-communicating. I could see people trying to save Wood if he actually was going to play the night out due to his scumminess being so obvious, but Annie? He barely said anything.

As you can see, your weak case is weaker.