Mafia 58-
- Thread starter IceH2O
- Start date
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
What??? I have no read on zaffy you pretty much mentioned you would vote for him basically off of kash's top suspects pretty much directly after kash posted?
Jpappy.. you, Annie, Zaffy, and Rich are my choices now. I've been accusing you pretty strong of being evil (partly) because it appears you saved Annie Night #1. You contend that this isn't true... that your suspicion towards Annie is NOT distancing yourself from a scummate, but that you truly have (or had) him as a real suspect.. not a fake one.
I'd be happy to hold off on voting you for another day (for now pending more evidence against you) on the off-chance that you have been telling the truth. But what are your thoughts now on voting Annie who you've claimed was a real suspect instead of your teammate?
I'd be happy to hold off on voting you for another day (for now pending more evidence against you) on the off-chance that you have been telling the truth. But what are your thoughts now on voting Annie who you've claimed was a real suspect instead of your teammate?
what are you talking about? I was the lone vote on Zaffy this past nightfall. My reasons were clear IMO and had nothing to do with any posts from Kashta...I will refrain from saying anything further.
I agree except it's not distancing or saving.
Voting Gun may or may not have been the best decision, based on Annie's role. But at the very least I stuck to voting for someone who I had mentioned for being scummy when I switched off of Wood even if it meant putting my foot on the line for getting someone lynched.
Annie is getting lost on my list however. I have DD, TRS, MC, Rich, and Annie all still on my radar but have no idea where to rank them. Needless to say, I will not be voting anytime soon pending any revelations.
In case I didn't answer your question directly enough: I don't know where to put Annie. I keep seeing more scumminess from other players and it's harder to justify a suspect from day 1 (in my mind) after two nights of play.
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
Noods, papp post 374 one hour after night tonight.
Originally Posted by Kashta
Headlines from Nights 1 and 2
Looks like the red ones are from the mafia side.. the blue ones from the town side.
Mafia journalist is writing about the underworld. The town journalist uses sports analogies.
I think the mafia guy really blew this one trying to pin a communicating mafia role on me when Dawg was up for the coin toss at all. You took a big risk there.. so sorry, you lose... lmao.
Not only does that show the other writer has to be the good guy, but it also validates the townie's investigation results. I just can't read that as trying to tell us Rich was revealed innocent. So we'll have to conclude that Rich is mafia. That's a hard one for me, since I was leaning Rich for the town side and because Dawg named him a suspect. But if Rich was non-communicating, Dawg couldn't have known... or was it distancing?
My suspects... Jpappy, Zaffy, Annie, Rich. Not sure which one to vote for. I may have picked up on something enough to draw Dawg on my butt and the mafia reporter.. but the odds of me guessing all the right names in the exact right relationship are much too.
Then noodles writes:
"have not thought this through but knee jerk reaction is Zaffy.....i'm game...."
Originally Posted by Kashta
Headlines from Nights 1 and 2
Looks like the red ones are from the mafia side.. the blue ones from the town side.
Mafia journalist is writing about the underworld. The town journalist uses sports analogies.
I think the mafia guy really blew this one trying to pin a communicating mafia role on me when Dawg was up for the coin toss at all. You took a big risk there.. so sorry, you lose... lmao.
Not only does that show the other writer has to be the good guy, but it also validates the townie's investigation results. I just can't read that as trying to tell us Rich was revealed innocent. So we'll have to conclude that Rich is mafia. That's a hard one for me, since I was leaning Rich for the town side and because Dawg named him a suspect. But if Rich was non-communicating, Dawg couldn't have known... or was it distancing?
My suspects... Jpappy, Zaffy, Annie, Rich. Not sure which one to vote for. I may have picked up on something enough to draw Dawg on my butt and the mafia reporter.. but the odds of me guessing all the right names in the exact right relationship are much too.
Then noodles writes:
"have not thought this through but knee jerk reaction is Zaffy.....i'm game...."
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
