Mafia 59 - MAFIA WARS - The Play

[johnlarson66]

It was 4 - 3, but someone got frogs vote - so thier vote counted as two -

The Town is undecided today but as night approached they narrowed down the field to two. However there was a certain somebody who failed to vote and doubled the vote of one of his enemies.

So the vote went to someone who was voting frog - making it 4 - 4

The candidates are dragged before Bala kicking and screaming but there is no use in fighting it. Using a random number generator the victim is selected.

So it was tied up.

 

[jpappy789]

That's what I said JL.

Mafia helped so that's good...

So since it was 4-3 in Luv's favor, and frog didn't vote, one of the people on frog had their vote doubled.

I'm not sure if I'm reading the rules correctly so maybe Dawg can clarify: since frog was innocent, does that mean the vote had to go to a mafia, or can it still go to an innocent?

That would help give us some leads if it had to go to a mafia member.

 

[johnlarson66]

Here is the rule, plus it was discussed -

a. You must vote each day, but you cannot vote for No One. The first night you fail to vote you will turn your vote over to a randomly chosen member of a rival mafia family or an innocent and it will double their vote that night (I will PM the person who's vote was doubled so they know). If you fail to vote a second night you will die an untimely death.

I was not the player with the double vote. This also does not mean that a mafia or an innocent got the extra vote. One of us that was voting for Frog got it.

 

[jpappy789]

JL, please read Dawg's post where he explicitly states that a mafia member got frog's vote.

 

[johnlarson66]

The vote went to a member of a rival team. Since there are 4 teams and only 1 team is innocent...you do the math. I can see how the wording may have been misleading.

OIC - since frog was innocent, then the vote went to a mafia (non-innocent).

I retract my vote on Luv and vote to lynch rich311k.

 

[rich311k]

Not bad getting a mob leader on the first night. We lost a townie but not one who seemed likely to help much.

 

[johnlarson66]

JL, please read Dawg's post where he explicitly states that a mafia member got frog's vote.

Silly me, I was going from the rules -

The first night you fail to vote you will turn your vote over to a randomly chosen member of a rival mafia family or an innocent and it will double their vote that night (I will PM the person who's vote was doubled so they know).

 

[rich311k]

OIC - since frog was innocent, then the vote went to a mafia (non-innocent).

I retract my vote on Luv and vote to lynch rich311k.

Just curious why me and not TRS. For that matter only one clearing you is you.

 

[jpappy789]

Rich -1- JL66(11)Noodles(84)
Ice -1- JPap(16)
Kash -2- Annie(37)Zaffy(101)
JPap -2- Ice(46)DD(85)
Frog -1- TRS(58)
Zaffy -1- Luv(76)
Luv -4- ZSand(81)Kash(91)JL(97)RB(105)
RB -1- Rich(83)

No votes from: Frog

Nightfall in 1-1/2hrs. PM's as required.

Part of me really wants to vote for frog...

Notice the vote count above. Frog has one vote early on from TRS and out of the blue JL says he wants to vote for them.

I think frog has been given a chance to fix their vote and to read the rules. I don't like the idea of them not getting it. Even some of the biggest noobatards have been able to vote. I have tried to help and they even posted afterwords.

Even if they figure it out, I am over it. Why wait until tomorrow? I am breaking one of my own day one rules and am going to vote for a noob. I can only hope that they do not take it personal and that they read the rules and follow along. Maybe they will play again.

I retract my vote on Luvbuqz and vote to lynch Froglover007.

Here's the switch. Notice there's nothing incriminating (ie. no mention of mafia behavior or the sorts) just rehashing the fact that frog didn't know how to play the game.

Here you go noods -



I am glad Frog went, I hate that they were innocent and there is really no innocents to spare. Atleast Ice was mafia. Frog was just not getting it.

I still am not against voting for Luv. Maybe Ice moved to frog to save Luv.

I vote to lynch Luv.

Now a contradiction...glad frog went but at the same time hates they are innocent?

Add in the fact that he tried to say I skimmed (when he was the one who did) and also he was on frog (we know a mafia player voted there).

I vote to lynch JL

 

[johnlarson66]

JL I think you are skimming too, Ice moved to Luv.

Yep, I added 1 and 1 and got 3. Can't blame skimming as much as thinking too much.

Odd that Ice would move at nightfall to vote Luv and attempt to save frog.