Mafia 59 - MAFIA WARS - The Play

jpappy789 said:
JL I'd like to know how you came to the conclusion that Rich was in fact the doubling vote, and that only one mafia was on frog.
Click to expand...

Jpap, here is what I think is a hint that it was rich -

dirtydawg10 said:
The Town has come to the realization that one who voted for Frog was in fact Mafia due to the doubled vote. The Townies spread their votes among the 3 who voted for Frog in hopes to root out the evil...but...did they make the correct choice??
Click to expand...

If we were all Frog's enemy, there would be no correct choice - all of us would be evil. By rich coming up evil to me says the town made the right choice.
 
And I am not saying that there was just one mafia on Frog, I am saying that not all three of us are mafia.
 
I also don't think a tie tonight is a good idea at all. A tie at this point only helps the mafia.
 
What do other players think about this going to a coin toss?
 
Just checking in real quick - I do not really like the 4 way tie right now either. with so few innocents left it makes me really nervous........
 
That seems to have become a staple statement in the nightly even descriptions, to add to the drama of the situation...but I do see what you mean. Maybe Rich was the one mafia we needed to find. I guess Dawg could have hinted at the fact that Rich ended up being the "right choice" but he never really said anything. Rich ended up mafia, but the double vote getter could still be alive for all we know. Just some more speculation I suppose...

All I know is that my top suspects are still the people I feel have acted the most scummy regardless of the situation. I don't see how an innocent would have voted for frog and I'm not going to get rid of the possibility because of what the mod may or may not have implied.

I'm not sure I understand the votes on Luv but I digress. I'm not entirely sure about anyone.
 
noodles62 said:
Just checking in real quick - I do not really like the 4 way tie right now either. with so few innocents left it makes me really nervous........
Click to expand...

Most likely there are three innocents - a vigilante, a doctor and a non-communicating innocent.

The vigilante has had the oppurtunity to place a hit and to investigate three players. If they have found the doctor they have someone to communicate with outside the thread. They should know that status of someone at this point.

There is most likely 5 mafia left - 3 NYC, 1 cuban, 1 russian. They either have 3 hits or 2 hits left. It is possible for one (or two) of the mafia teams to be without a hit.

If the town can lynch a mafia and the mafia take out each other - the tide can turn very quickly.
 
johnlarson66 said:
What do other players think about this going to a coin toss?
Click to expand...

I don't really like it either, especially a four way toss. The whole point of ties, in theory, is to see if mafia jump but with two teams down to only one and with as little activity as we've seen it's not really doing its intended job.

At the same time, I'm not sure how to break the tie myself. I certainly am not going to Luv at this point, but between Annie and TRS I don't know. I had TRS slightly ahead, but still not far enough to make the decision.

If both would have the time to answer post #350 maybe that would make it an easier decision.

I don't see a clear cut way for the town to win this. We really need to get lucky on the lynch and hits tonight.
 
johnlarson66 said:
Most likely there are three innocents - a vigilante, a doctor and a non-communicating innocent.

The vigilante has had the oppurtunity to place a hit and to investigate three players. If they have found the doctor they have someone to communicate with outside the thread. They should know that status of someone at this point.

There is most likely 5 mafia left - 3 NYC, 1 cuban, 1 russian. They either have 3 hits or 2 hits left. It is possible for one (or two) of the mafia teams to be without a hit.

If the town can lynch a mafia and the mafia take out each other - the tide can turn very quickly.
Click to expand...


I forgot about the doctor. That is good. I am surpirsed that no one has moved yet. I like my vote on TRS and I would like to keep it there.
 
What makes me think Luv is the original day one play where she named other players and then voted a different way. Also the post and go style has not sit well with me.

Another thing about Luv, Ice voted for her thinking he was breaking the tie with Frog. While other players could have done that also and saved frog - no one else did. It has been stated that Ice mostly did this as an act of killing an mafia instead of an innocent and that Ice had frog more innocent than Luv.

Speaking of the tie - no one else stepped in to stop it. There were players on the board.

Besides the three on Frog, I think Kash had Luv as a suspect.

Of the 4 of us in this tie - 2 have claimed they are innocent and one has been just hit and run.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom