looking at the Aqua C EV skimmer for my 48g

debaric

debaric

AC Members
Feb 2, 2006
695
0
0
48
N.J.
www.myspace.com
getting a 48g rimless in the future (w/ 20g sump) and im wondering if the lowest Aqua C EV would be too much for that amount of water.


Also would a 20g long be easy to mod into a sump (simple sump w/fuge) for the following skimmers- aqua c ev, aqua c urchin pro, or ASM g1?

Do this seem reasonable or am I a stupid idiot?
 
debaric said:
getting a 48g rimless in the future (w/ 20g sump) and im wondering if the lowest Aqua C EV would be too much for that amount of water.


Also would a 20g long be easy to mod into a sump (simple sump w/fuge) for the following skimmers- aqua c ev, aqua c urchin pro, or ASM g1?

Do this seem reasonable or am I a stupid idiot?
Click to expand...

Bit harsh on yourself, aren't you?

I've used the AquaC line in the past and they were reasonable performers, but not necessarily worth the cost. The price/performance ratio wasn't quite what I was looking for. If you are looking for in-sump skimmers similar in class, but more efficient/efficacious, then try the Reef Octopus line. I think you'll find the performance vs. price a bit more attractive. If you want more performance, but with a substantial increase in price, you can always look at the Deltec line. Some have said that CPR's new series of skimmers are also supposed to be better and cost a bit less. Tunze is another good option, albeit a bit expensive, also.

Oh, I've moved this to the equipment forum, since I think it will get better (and more appropriate) exposure here.
 
^^^I've seen their larger models in action and I was impressed, especially with their cone skimmers. I haven't seen one of the H series, though.
 
I would stay away from buying a new AquaC Urchin or Remora / Remora Pro, as they just don't perform well enough for the cost. I like the Remora and Remora Pro I have, but I wouldn't buy either one new (I got both of mine used).

The AquaC EV-180 skimmer I have though, now that's a different story. I'm not saying that it's the best skimmer for the money (there's just so many choices), but it vastly outperforms the Remora / Remora Pro skimmers on my tanks. I would definitely consider buying another one if I needed it, but again, there are many other choices that probably work as well or somewhat better for the money. I think the EV-120 might be big for a 48g tank, unless you plan on stocking heavily or are striving for very low organic levels for a strictly SPS tank.

A 20g long won't be hard to turn into a sump at all. Any of the skimmers you listed (and many others) would be easy to fit into that size sump without a problem. When making your sump, it is generally a good idea to maximize the area for the return pump, as that is where the water level drops due to evaporation. Of course, it ends up being a balancing act, since having a large refugium area also has its benefits.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom