Mafia #60: A Clash at Christmas- The Play

Last post before I go. Noods, it's clear we need to get rid of DD and Ice, but right now it's a tie between DD and TRS. If it comes to a toss up, and TRS goes, we learn nothing and the grinch gets another chance to take out an elf. I don't see anyone else looking to change their vote to Ice. How 'bout it? If you move to DD, we can at least get rid of one of them tonight. Even if she isn't the grinch and you're right about ice... we have him dead to rights next nightfall.

It seems pretty clear though out most of the posting that these two are definitely on the same team. I really believe that DD is manning the whip, and Ice pulling the sleigh. But we need to get rid of one of them, and the "random number generator" is in no way a guarantee of that.

Just something to think about.
 
Now that you two bring up such good points I would be willing to switch my vote but should I make it a tie between DD and Ice, or vote for DD?
 
I've given my opinion several times Razz... but I really feel that DD is the grinch and Ice just the sled-dog. If we get rid of the grinch, he gets no hit and no more innocents have to die. Then we have Ice dead to rights tomorrow night. Plus, it would be really fun to see him squirm. :D:thumbsup::FIREdevil:
 
Now that I think about it my last post will probably get me yelled at by some people so, I retract my vote on TRS and vote to lynch Ice.
 
Sorry JB I typed and posted mine before I could see your post but either way we know both are evil and we cannot quite tell which is the grinch so a coin toss might actually help us here. I'll keep my post as is.
 
As long as we get rid of one of them...:thumbsup:. I'm just worried that with the numbers being so close, if the grinch gets to hit another innocent, we're close to losing. And if Jack "nips" an innocent, it's pretty much lost. I hate leaving things like this up to chance. My guts have been pretty good in the past, and for two nights straight it's told me DD (who, incidentally is no where to be found), so I have to stick with it.

You have to vote your conscience, but if you're really on the fence, I would encourage you to switch.
 
Nice posts JB. You went into a lot of trouble to frame a person who was never on your lists. I did suspect DD but never really had enough on her IMO,especially after TRS and Noods came out the way they did against players on Jms train when they were on Richs train. Just because Jm died and Rich didn't doesn't make Rich any less evil or innocent. The roles could be reversed. Since Jm was the one in the lead most of the day I would think that Rich would be a perfect place for the evil elfs to hide and not worry about him being lynched, that is till Fire came in with a last minute vote to tie it.

You are right about 1 thing. My vote on Noods is a waste and since my other main suspect is sitting with 2 votes I'll make it 3.

I retract my vote on Noodles and vote to lynch TRS
 
Very interesting - a 3 way tie - again. I think I will wait a bit and see what else transpires before I make any further decisions. I really like my vote on Ice and based on his latest vote switch I think we have him squirming!!

Another thing - based on who goes tonight, I hope Frosty uses his snowball on the other! With the innocent team not getting any hits he is our only chance on taking out a bad power role! Come to think of it - snowballs and Ice kinda go together! ;)
 
Just to play devil's advocate. It could easily be that Jb and his cronies are trying to protect TRS, taKe out an innocent either Ice or DD and with a hit make this whole thing very tight for the town. If it does not work out tomorrow they say oops. If TRS come up Grinch then this is going to be really interesting.
 
rich311k said:
Just to play devil's advocate. It could easily be that Jb and his cronies are trying to protect TRS, taKe out an innocent either Ice or DD and with a hit make this whole thing very tight for the town. If it does not work out tomorrow they say oops. If TRS come up Grinch then this is going to be really interesting.
Click to expand...

Well, I guess we will see come night fall. I am not willing to take that chance.
I do not know for a fact that JB is innocent but his thinking is on the same page as mine and I know what side I am on.... You place/keep your vote where you see fit but IMO Ice is scum - "plain and simple"
:headbang2:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom