Mafia 61: The Gunslinger - Game Thread
- Thread starter Madcrawdad
- Start date
Interesting read today.
I have problems with some of the stratagies but I'm going to save my comment.
I'm going to ask another question instead.
If you had to name 4 mafia players right now who would they be?
I have problems with some of the stratagies but I'm going to save my comment.
I'm going to ask another question instead.
If you had to name 4 mafia players right now who would they be?
My first guess at 4 mafia:
Annie
Zaffy
Kash
Z/JPap
ok so I picked 5. But since I put them both on the same line it counts as 1 right. If I was forced to pick between Z and JPap right now I'd flip a coin.
Annie
Zaffy
Kash
Z/JPap
ok so I picked 5. But since I put them both on the same line it counts as 1 right. If I was forced to pick between Z and JPap right now I'd flip a coin.
Well I am not at all confortable with any of this yet but here is my run down for you Ice. To be honest I went back to the beginning and pulled the player list as I couldn't remember everyone that is in.
I'm excluding myself naturally and I'm excluding you Ice. This leaves:
Agassizii
Annie
Dawg
JB
JPappy
Kash
Lab
Razzle
TRS
Zaffy
I've seen nothing but helpfulness from Kash, Pappy, and Dawg so far. I may not agree with their logic in some instances but I see this round as a logic puzzle and they are all trying their own approaches. JB is also in this group but going on my own thoughts that a high poster is likely Mafia and that a high poster makes him a good Sherriff I pick him from the fray. Plus to be honest he had me so off kilter last game I am a bit on tilt.
For two middle-of-the-roadies, I'd go with Agass and Lab because its what all the cool kids are doing. Honestly I have nothing but feelings on these two. And for a forth I'd go with Razz. They haven't posted and it seems like it would be a good way to keep at least one Mafium off the radar for a while. After all why would you put your life on the line shooting someone that hasn't said a word.
My list:
JB
AGass
Lab
Razz
I'm excluding myself naturally and I'm excluding you Ice. This leaves:
Agassizii
Annie
Dawg
JB
JPappy
Kash
Lab
Razzle
TRS
Zaffy
I've seen nothing but helpfulness from Kash, Pappy, and Dawg so far. I may not agree with their logic in some instances but I see this round as a logic puzzle and they are all trying their own approaches. JB is also in this group but going on my own thoughts that a high poster is likely Mafia and that a high poster makes him a good Sherriff I pick him from the fray. Plus to be honest he had me so off kilter last game I am a bit on tilt.
For two middle-of-the-roadies, I'd go with Agass and Lab because its what all the cool kids are doing. Honestly I have nothing but feelings on these two. And for a forth I'd go with Razz. They haven't posted and it seems like it would be a good way to keep at least one Mafium off the radar for a while. After all why would you put your life on the line shooting someone that hasn't said a word.
My list:
JB
AGass
Lab
Razz
You confused me with Rich? I have as many posts as anyone in this thread, I'm confused and hurt. 
My list would be:
Annie- not sure if mafia, but has me concerned. I think he's a great hit choice, personally.
Lab- that post about wanting to be gunslinger was off. Could be one to choose Ice.
Razz- a no show so far but is viewing
Zaffy/JB- either one fits the mold I laid out of who may have chosen Ice. Neither has done anything notoriously scummy but it strikes me odd that JB and I have been on the same page for the most part. I might just be paranoid but I'm interested in what he has to say next after posting "more later."
Annie- not sure if mafia, but has me concerned. I think he's a great hit choice, personally.
Lab- that post about wanting to be gunslinger was off. Could be one to choose Ice.
Razz- a no show so far but is viewing
Zaffy/JB- either one fits the mold I laid out of who may have chosen Ice. Neither has done anything notoriously scummy but it strikes me odd that JB and I have been on the same page for the most part. I might just be paranoid but I'm interested in what he has to say next after posting "more later."
You confused me with Rich? I have as many posts as anyone in this thread, I'm confused and hurt.
No I HAD you on the list but substituted Rich because you have games were you will post a lot more and then some were you dont. Rich is much more middle of the road, but I forgot to check if he was in the game. My fault.
Sorry, I actually forgot the game started today and I was reading. Honastly, I have no idea who should be picked. I haven't found anyone that sticks out yet. All I can say for sure, is a shot to me would eliminate Ice and then handing off the gun to me and like I said, I have no clue who to even point the gun twards, let alone shoot.
