Mafia 62- The Play

[jbradt]

Why is that concerning? My initial vote was a knee jerk vote after nightfall on my top suspect. I retracted as I wanted to do a little more research and thinking. I s'ppose I could have just left my vote there while I thought about but I didnt. Dont see how that indicates anything...:huh:

that's ok. I can hear the train a comin. It's coming round the bend.....

To be honest, Noods it's concerning largely because of the context. You voted for her on a "knee jerk reaction" after having made vague comments about not wanting to take the chance because she's a good player. Then you retract, saying you have to do more research. My memory is failing a little atm, but I don't remember you putting a lot of research out there before voting again. I think you realized you were third on Labby... that's why you retracted. I think that when that vote got scrutinized, it would have connected you to someone. So you took it back. Then when it was safe, you placed your vote back on just to be sure she would go tonight.

At one point you basically said you were voting for her because she's a good player. I believe you. And I believe you're scared she'll be good at finding you and your teammates.

You've pinged my meter Noods. And I hope the innocents voting for Labby will look at their reasoning for voting that way. As always, the innocent have to vote their conscience. Just make sure there's a reason for your vote.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I think at least one person voting Lab_Rat is mafia.

I also think at least one person tha has not voted is mafia.

So that just leaves Lab_Rat and Dawg not in those two groups. I would think that there is a good chance at least one of them is mafia.

There is a 0% chance that I am mafia (unless I totally misread my PM). Dawg I suspected anyway, so I can't comment about your percent there.

 

[jbradt]

Why is that concerning? My initial vote was a knee jerk vote after nightfall on my top suspect. I retracted as I wanted to do a little more research and thinking. I s'ppose I could have just left my vote there while I thought about but I didnt. Dont see how that indicates anything...:huh:

that's ok. I can hear the train a comin. It's coming round the bend.....

As I read this post again, it really started to bother me. It sounds like you're pretty excited about the train on Labby, Noods. It's day 2. You can't be THAT sure that she's scum. I can also see your vote retraction/restatement as a way to say "see, I wasn't totally sure" if Labby turns up innocent.

To come out with it for the record, based on her reactions to being tied to the tracks, i think she is indeed innocent. Don't worry, Jpap... I didn't say I trusted her. :thm:

 

[dirtydawg10]

Being a skimmer I don't doubt you've missed my vote tallies in previous games.



As Detective probably yes, but I also think I'd have more pull then Ag would.But its still a moot point. Ag wasn't leading in votes until 45 minutes till night.

Would you have come out if you were in a 3 person lynch that was close enough it could have gone to one of the other 2 and not you?



Might be tacky but the mafia doesn't know if its happening or not so I'll use it to my advantage as long as possible.

It would be a tough call of when to pull the trigger but since it was close coming out close to night it would have only taken a couple of votes to save me at that point. If I saw my choices as certainly die or possibly die I would have taken possibly die even if it was 20min till nightfall. As you know a lot can happen in this game in 20min. Especially since most players are around close to nightfall. I'll show you in another post when I would have come out if I was the det. I understand it's a moot point but you brought it up.

The whole doctor thing seems to be a big misunderstanding since in neither cases did I see anyone want the Dr to reveal their role. Not sure why it suddenly became an issue in the first place.

It became an issue because Ice and JL made it an issue.

 

[Lab_Rat]

What is even worse, even if Lab comes up mafia, there could still be a chance that I am mafia

Sounds like you doubt that I'll come up mafia...

 

[noodles62]

Thought i would take a look at Mich in case he does not UD tonite.

I vote to lynch JL

Becuase JLs the only one who hasn't posted and not already gotten a vote.

Following others by voting for someone who has not posted yet...

Wouldn't he had UDd by then?

Well yea, so why the vote on him then? (him = JL)

I retract my uneducated vote on JL and vote to lynch Ice

Ice seems the most suspicious to me, I haven't played before but it seems he's trying a new strategy? I don't see why anyone would try so hard to not be lynched if they're innocent. Too late, I didn't see that it was over. Sorry!, I was still typing.

Either is following what others have said or is being coached.

...wow, bad night

meh!

I don't see why you would be trying so hard to stay in the game if you're innocent anyways.

This sets off all kinds of alarms. I know he has been looked at by others and there is not a whole lot of posts to look at but if he does not UD tonite i will be very worried about this guy tomorrow............

 

[noodles62]

As I read this post again, it really started to bother me. It sounds like you're pretty excited about the train on Labby, Noods. It's day 2. You can't be THAT sure that she's scum. I can also see your vote retraction/restatement as a way to say "see, I wasn't totally sure" if Labby turns up innocent.

To come out with it for the record, based on her reactions to being tied to the tracks, i think she is indeed innocent. Don't worry, Jpap... I didn't say I trusted her. :thm:

JB, the train (Johnny Cash) reference was in regards to ME! Once Labby voted for me, I can see what is coming. Not a train yet, but I will be very surprised if it does not end up one.

 

[jbradt]

JB, the train (Johnny Cash) reference was in regards to ME! Once Labby voted for me, I can see what is coming. Not a train yet, but I will be very surprised if it does not end up one.

I guess I don't see the connection between the condemned pointing a finger at you and a train a comin'. (and I love Johny Cash btw :worthy. Seems like a pretty large jump. Also kind of seems like a guilty conscience.

 

[jbradt]

There is a 0% chance that I am mafia (unless I totally misread my PM). Dawg I suspected anyway, so I can't comment about your percent there.

Okay, so to be fair... at what level do you read?



:silly:

 

[dirtydawg10]

1:15 min till nightfall...Ag ahead by 1 vote. 3 people havent voted and 1 (Alex) had quit at this point...so 2 possible votes one of which was Ag so they knew where that one was going.

Dawg-0- Zaffy(#28)
Rich-0- ZS(#42)
Alex-0- Lab(#45)
Kash-1- Rich(#46)
Lab-3- JB(#47), JL(#139), Noods(#150), JL(#162), Dawg(#165)
Razz-0- Ag(#48)
Ice-1- Jpap(#53), Kash(#168)
Zaffy-0- Ice(#55)
JL-1- Mich(#57), Ag(#67)
Noods-0- Dawg(#66)
Ag-4- Ice(#70), Razz(#71), ZS(#147), Jpap(#157)
DD-0- Noods(#78)
Jpap-3- Zaffy(#109), Labby(#155), JB(#158)

NIGHTFALL IN ONE HOUR FIFTEEN MINUTES

45 min till night...Rich switches and essentially locks Ag as the lynch victim. 2 votes to come Ag was up by 2 votes and couldn't even tie it up at this point. Alex had quit.

No votes from DD, Ag, Alex

Dawg-0- Zaffy(#28)
Rich-0- ZS(#42)
Alex-0- Lab(#45)
Kash-0- Rich(#46)
Lab-3- JB(#47), JL(#139), Noods(#150), JL(#162), Dawg(#165)
Razz-0- Ag(#48)
Ice-1- Jpap(#53), Kash(#168)
Zaffy-0- Ice(#55)
JL-1- Mich(#57), Ag(#67)
Noods-0- Dawg(#66)
Ag-5- Ice(#70), Razz(#71), ZS(#147), Jpap(#157), Rich(#181)
DD-0- Noods(#78)
Jpap-3- Zaffy(#109), Labby(#155), JB(#158)

This post is probably where I would have come out. It's 35 min till nightfall and only DD's vote is missing. Even if DD placed her vote on one of the runners up the best I could hope for is a tie not good even with a tie. I would at least hope DD would tie it up on someone else with her vote and then someone would switch off of me to save me.

I vote to lynch Jpap

Being lynched by 1 vote still w/ 30min till nightfall...

Dawg-0- Zaffy(#28)
Rich-0- ZS(#42)
Alex-0- Lab(#45)
Kash-0- Rich(#46)
Lab-3- JB(#47), JL(#139), Noods(#150), JL(#162), Dawg(#165)
Razz-0- Ag(#48)
Ice-1- Jpap(#53), Kash(#168)
Zaffy-0- Ice(#55)
JL-1- Mich(#57), Ag(#67)
Noods-0- Dawg(#66)
Ag-5- Ice(#70), Razz(#71), ZS(#147), Jpap(#157), Rich(#181)
DD-0- Noods(#78)
Jpap-4- Zaffy(#109), Labby(#155), JB(#158), Ag(#189)

No vote from Alex or DD.

NIGHTFALL IN HALF AN HOUR. ONE HOUR IN NEWFOUNDLAND

Kash chimes in and switches to Ag w/ 23 min left till night and seals the deal. Definitely would have come out then.

I don't like making late vote changes and I'm still holding Ice as being really weird (aka suspicious). But there's plenty of time for all the rest of you to switch around however you will before night falls.

I was contemplating a vote on AG but seeing 5 votes there already on a guy who might UD on us wasn't looking very promising. He's since voted so the lynch votes on him actually count for something. Of the other two names on the leading list, I'm most suspicious of Lab Rat. Her first post an hour into the game was followed half an hour later suggesting people who weren't posting already must be scummy. And from there, she's been all finger pointy and overly inquisitive (IMO) for just a regular townie. Jpap is on that list too but I'm not getting a real scummy read on him yet. I don't count him as readable though for a few days in any game.

I retract my vote on Ice (for today at least) and vote to lynch Agass.

That shouldn't be taken, Ice, that I'm lowering my suspicion of you and your actions thus far. But mine is a lone vote and it's not getting us anywhere at this time.

With 19min left the final vote comes in and Ag has absolutely no chance. If I still hadn't come out at this point I would be jumping up and down screaming that I was the det.

sorry guys.... I have had a heck of a day.... I haven't read through the posts really well but I can see there is some concern over Lab, however, I am still not feeling good about Ag.... the most because of the reference to games off the board. Not much to go on but it's what I have to get my vote out.... I vote to lynch Ag