Mafia 62- The Play

[IceH2O]

One more question Razz...

Why didn't your vote move if you think Lab is innocent?

 

[IceH2O]

My bad you didn't say innocent per say. You just implied it so you could come back tomorrow and say you had the feeling she was.

 

[RazzleFish]

Helps me immensely.

I also garner from this that Z, Rich and I are your top suspects?

JB isn't colored,whats that mean?




He voted like an hour before you posted.




I want to thank you both.I was on the fence this morning about keeping my vote on Lab. I think she is being sincere but I didn't want to be rash and just jump. I've had her and Noods as suspects thinking one of the 2 is mafia. Then Noods post about the train coming her way really swayed me to think she was saying this as a preventive measure to make other innocents not want to move to her. Then the posts above sealed the deal for me.

I retract my vote on Lab and vote to lynch Noodles



My suspect list is now:

Noods
Razz
Dawg/Jpap ( but more because Razz has them listed as innocent)

Of Dawg/Jpap I'd only suspect 1 of the 2 is actually mafia. IMO it would be Jpap over Dawg. I feel that they are hoping that Dawgs posts against me will sway me to look his way when Razz shows mafia.

JB should be red. My bad I must have missed his name when I went back and changed the colors.

I don't think she is completly innocent but the way it sounds I could see her being innocent. I didn't change my vote because she is still my strongest suspect so I don't want to change to someone I don't feel as strongly about. But then again, Ice, you seem to react rather odd to my post when I put you on the mafia team. Why is it that you look to my most trusted players over my least trusted players? Is it because you are mafia and you are trying to make it seem like I am? Why am I on your list? I posted my thoughts and now I'm evil? I may have to vote you tonight but I'll wait for your responce before I change my vote.

 

[ZSandmann]

I vote to lynch Zsandmann

Pulling your posts is hard, you haven't said anything of substance yet. I just get an overall sense that you're not probing for scum at all. You're throwing other peoples arguments out there and making it look like you're helping the town, but you're really not.

It's easy to hide in a landslide, but you gotta give a reason. You were the 3rd vote, which is a strong vote on day 1 I might add.

It's a reason, but it's a go with the flow status quo reason.

Yes, Ag was leading most of the night, partly due to your vote (#3) on him.

Naw, you're scum. You'll just have to hit me tonight so I don't link you with her. It's a tough life.

Thanks for the hit n run vote Zaff. The part I've bolded is really starting to wear my patience down. This exact sentence was uttered about me last game and I think the game before as well. I post when I can and unlike some people I don't requote every post in the game to make my cases because it is redundant and a pain in the butt to read through. As for number of posts the two of us are almost on parity.

Now regarding Noods, yes her behavior is grossly off this round. I believe some of this is due to RL but I also feel like she isn't digging in and going after folks like she normally does. So that concerns me. As I said before if you see something on her, you need to tell the Town, keeping stuff to yourself makes you look like an outsider trying to play their own game.

Haha, no you didn't scare me off. I just realized that I'm very, very, very bad at this game so I've been laying low because I realized that I don't know what to say to not make me seem suspicious, as being lynched (which is probably what would happen if I tried to post) would be bad for the town.

Sandy takes Michs Noob Card (TM) and rips it in half. Everybody gets one.

I have spent the time since the past nightfall defending myself. That is a very true observation as I have been repeatedly raked over the coals. The heat is all on me and I have tried to explain why I posted what i posted previously.

Go back and read before the first nightfall. I was doing my best to kick bushes and find scum. The unfortunate result of me sharing my thoughts and suspicions with the town was twofold; not only did I come across as scummy to many of you, but it also seems I inadvertantly muddied the waters. Not wanting to increase confusion for my fellow townies I am now not throwing my every suspicion out there.

That being said, I'm not going to do what the mafia hopes...I'm not going to roll, I will continue to defend myself. Hence all of the recent defensive posts. Unfortunately, due to irl obligations, I will miss the couple hours prior to nightfall tonight. Do not mistake that for me giving up. If anyone wants to know anything from me, please ask now. I should have time to post again around 3pm est but that is likely about it.

Being on the defensive is no good way to prove you're Innocent. Better to point out who you believe is Mafia. So far you've done nothing to clear yourself in my mind.

JB should be red. My bad I must have missed his name when I went back and changed the colors.

I don't think she is completly innocent but the way it sounds I could see her being innocent. I didn't change my vote because she is still my strongest suspect so I don't want to change to someone I don't feel as strongly about. But then again, Ice, you seem to react rather odd to my post when I put you on the mafia team. Why is it that you look to my most trusted players over my least trusted players? Is it because you are mafia and you are trying to make it seem like I am? Why am I on your list? I posted my thoughts and now I'm evil? I may have to vote you tonight but I'll wait for your responce before I change my vote.

Razzle I can't tell what your game is this round. Between you and Noods I'm not liking my vote on Lab very much anymore. The non-commital comments, but not shifting votes... You do more to clear Lab than Lab has done in a day and a half...

 

[Zaffy]

Thanks for the hit n run vote Zaff. The part I've bolded is really starting to wear my patience down. This exact sentence was uttered about me last game and I think the game before as well. I post when I can and unlike some people I don't requote every post in the game to make my cases because it is redundant and a pain in the butt to read through. As for number of posts the two of us are almost on parity.

Now regarding Noods, yes her behavior is grossly off this round. I believe some of this is due to RL but I also feel like she isn't digging in and going after folks like she normally does. So that concerns me. As I said before if you see something on her, you need to tell the Town, keeping stuff to yourself makes you look like an outsider trying to play their own game.


Sandy takes Michs Noob Card (TM) and rips it in half. Everybody gets one.

Being on the defensive is no good way to prove you're Innocent. Better to point out who you believe is Mafia. So far you've done nothing to clear yourself in my mind.

Razzle I can't tell what your game is this round. Between you and Noods I'm not liking my vote on Lab very much anymore. The non-commital comments, but not shifting votes... You do more to clear Lab than Lab has done in a day and a half...

It's not hit and run, I think you're scum.

It's the content of posts that's important imo not the quantity. The content if is for the town to decide. I'm certainly guilty of being a low poster at times. g/o my remark is nothing personal I swear it, I'd have a beer with you. g/o

 

[Lab_Rat]

Being on the defensive is no good way to prove you're Innocent. Better to point out who you believe is Mafia. So far you've done nothing to clear yourself in my mind.

I don't like being on the defensive either.

Noods is the one I most suspect as mafia.

Michwol has been elevated on my scum list due to his awkward timing and posts. My theory is he was told in the scum den to change his vote to Ice. He, being a noob, did not realize his mistimed his vote switch greviously. His posting during nightfall seems like an honest noob mistake; the vote switch itself, when combined with the timing, feels very coached and scummy. From what I can tell, this may be the first slipup the mafia team has had. Like I said, this is just a theory. I am still more comfortable with my vote on Noods as she strikes me as the most scummy so far.

 

[ZSandmann]

It's not hit and run, I think you're scum.

It's the content of posts that's important imo not the quantity. The content if is for the town to decide. I'm certainly guilty of being a low poster at times. g/o my remark is nothing personal I swear it, I'd have a beer with you. g/o

I'm not taking it personally, its just that that statement keeps coming up. (I don't remember who said it last time) and it irritates me because, Day 1 excluded, I don't post much unless I feel I'm adding something. There is plenty of fluff in the thread already.

 

[ZSandmann]

I don't like being on the defensive either.

Noods is the one I most suspect as mafia.

Michwol has been elevated on my scum list due to his awkward timing and posts. My theory is he was told in the scum den to change his vote to Ice. He, being a noob, did not realize his mistimed his vote switch greviously. His posting during nightfall seems like an honest noob mistake; the vote switch itself, when combined with the timing, feels very coached and scummy. From what I can tell, this may be the first slipup the mafia team has had. Like I said, this is just a theory. I am still more comfortable with my vote on Noods as she strikes me as the most scummy so far.

Yeah Mich is playing a weird Noob game... Looking at how the votes are stacked I have to wonder where the Mafia are at. I suspect there are 4-5 based on starting numbers. DD and Rich haven't voted. Even if DD and rich were BOTH Mafia there still have to be 2-3 Mafia on Lab right now... Something doesn't add up. This should make Tonight more interesting, I will be interested to see where the others votes fall.

I retract my vote for Lab and vote to lynch Noods.

 

[noodles62]

I like fluffy things! Can we get an abstract question now, please? opcorn:

 

[noodles62]

Yeah Mich is playing a weird Noob game... Looking at how the votes are stacked I have to wonder where the Mafia are at. I suspect there are 4-5 based on starting numbers. DD and Rich haven't voted. Even if DD and rich were BOTH Mafia there still have to be 2-3 Mafia on Lab right now... Something doesn't add up. This should make Tonight more interesting, I will be interested to see where the others votes fall.

I retract my vote for Lab and vote to lynch Noods.

*gasp* et tu brutus? :thud: