Mafia 62- The Play

[johnlarson66]

Votes

Jpap 1 Lab

Lab 6 Jl Pap Noods Ice Z Noods Razz

Ice 1 Dawg

I don't think I have ever seen Ice as a player do a vote count. Trying to be helpful?

 

[dirtydawg10]

What I asked for was after the det was lynched so therefore not possible whatsoever. I never asked the doc to do anything. You get what I'm saying now?

The doc coming out is a whole other ballgame than the det. The doc can't protect themselves from the hit so it would be useless to come out because they would be dead anyway. Let's hope the doc isn't that naive.

So Ice would you have come out if you were the det in the same situation? I believe you would. I would. It's the only way to protect the most powerful innocent role we have. Now their gone.

 

[johnlarson66]

1 - Jpap - Labrat(231)
6 - Labrat - JL(243), Jpap(252), Noodles(257), Ice(310), Zsand(322), Noodles(327), Razz(330)
1 - Ice - Dawg(320)

No votes from: Zaffy, DD, Mich, Rich, JB

I think this is accurate.

I think at least one person voting Lab_Rat is mafia.

I also think at least one person tha has not voted is mafia.

So that just leaves Lab_Rat and Dawg not in those two groups. I would think that there is a good chance at least one of them is mafia.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I think at least one person voting Lab_Rat is mafia.

I also think at least one person tha has not voted is mafia.

So that just leaves Lab_Rat and Dawg not in those two groups. I would think that there is a good chance at least one of them is mafia.

There's a good chance you're mafia too JL

 

[johnlarson66]

There's a good chance you're mafia too JL

I would be in the group voting for Lab_Rat. So yes there is a chance. Maybe you missed that part of my post.

What is even worse, even if Lab comes up mafia, there could still be a chance that I am mafia. Me voting for mafia won't even clear me. I am hoping this saves me from being hit. I don't mind being a suspect. I could also beg the doc to protect me, but that would be tackey.

 

[ZSandmann]

Z I wasn't saying you were, it was more a general question to you 3 to see what answers would come forth.


I don't think Ag really had a chance to come out even if he wanted. It was pretty close until the last 45 minutes of the night.Then the rest piled on to put it out of reach.

Well that's a better point and one that could stand some looking into, there were definitely some late votes and vote changes on Day 1 but my recollection was that Agass was leading more.

I've seen enough from Pappythat I'll give him the benefit of the doubt for now. I'm gonna keep him on my short list though.

I don't want to vote Lab because I hate landslides, and everyone I suspect aside from Lab herself, and DD are voting on her; Jpap, noodles, Ice.

I don't like Ice's whole deal with begging for protection, if he's scum and the Dr. buys it, it's a guarantee that their hits will go off without a hitch. He's poking at everyone just a bit, which I like though.

Noodles, I suspect for a reason that I'm keeping to myself for right now, I'll see what happens there.

Concealing anything you have gleaned from the thread does nothing to help the Town Zaffy. I certainly feel Noods is a good suspect for Mafia, and anything anybody has on her would be of great interest to myself and others I am sure.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I would be in the group voting for Lab_Rat. So yes there is a chance. Maybe you missed that part of my post.

Nope didn't miss that but i figured I'd point out that you said everyone has a good chance of being mafia. I was wondering what you were getting at other than boosting post count.

What is even worse, even if Lab comes up mafia, there could still be a chance that I am mafia. Me voting for mafia won't even clear me. I am hoping this saves me from being hit.

Very true

I don't mind being a suspect. I could also beg the doc to protect me, but that would be tackey.

:rofl: I agree!

 

[IceH2O]

I don't think I have ever seen Ice as a player do a vote count. Trying to be helpful?

Being a skimmer I don't doubt you've missed my vote tallies in previous games.

So Ice would you have come out if you were the det in the same situation? I believe you would. I would. It's the only way to protect the most powerful innocent role we have. Now their gone.

As Detective probably yes, but I also think I'd have more pull then Ag would.But its still a moot point. Ag wasn't leading in votes until 45 minutes till night.

Would you have come out if you were in a 3 person lynch that was close enough it could have gone to one of the other 2 and not you?

I could also beg the doc to protect me, but that would be tackey.

Might be tacky but the mafia doesn't know if its happening or not so I'll use it to my advantage as long as possible.

 

[IceH2O]

Hey Mich. I checked and see you've been posting on site since 8 PM. Why nothing here?

 

[Zaffy]

I vote to lynch Zsandmann

Pulling your posts is hard, you haven't said anything of substance yet. I just get an overall sense that you're not probing for scum at all. You're throwing other peoples arguments out there and making it look like you're helping the town, but you're really not.

I retract my vote for Rich and vote to lynch Agass

It's easy to hide in a landslide, but you gotta give a reason. You were the 3rd vote, which is a strong vote on day 1 I might add.

I'm game, no order:

Mich: yes, a newbie, but asking an Innocent to die seems contradictory to common sense. Based on the way the last game went down no one gets a pass from me.

Noodles: Yeah she doesn't seem to have her head in the game, generally skimmy. I don't really get how the book would influence her play either.

JL: Nothing solid at all but he flew into the game like he had something to prove, definitely making waves with Lab and others.

Ice: Kash was on Ice pretty hard towards the end of Day 1. To Hit her draws attention but then we get into WIFOM of if he'd risk it and I could see Ice doing it.

I may have been persuaded to not lynch Agas if they had RCed, I can not say. The fact is they did not and were lynched, what could be a worse outcome than that one? I haven't seen anyone indicating the Dr should come out, that's just plain stupid. Agas was a very powerful player and they should have fought back harder, if they RCed, "maybe" enough people would have shifted and then the Dr could protect them from the Mafia. I'm not sure what's hard to understand about that.

Sorry Lab but it's Day 2, I don't trust anyone and I don't trust anyone that says they trust someone. The last game was different but we weren't naming people we trusted until very late in that game.

I vote to lynch Lab

It's a reason, but it's a go with the flow status quo reason.

Well that's a better point and one that could stand some looking into, there were definitely some late votes and vote changes on Day 1 but my recollection was that Agass was leading more.

Concealing anything you have gleaned from the thread does nothing to help the Town Zaffy. I certainly feel Noods is a good suspect for Mafia, and anything anybody has on her would be of great interest to myself and others I am sure.

Yes, Ag was leading most of the night, partly due to your vote (#3) on him.

Naw, you're scum. You'll just have to hit me tonight so I don't link you with her. It's a tough life.