Mafia 62- The Play

WOOHOO! Great night.... except that we lost an innocent but Dawg, face it, you were a little off in your stepping.....

as far as the listing is going, I am cool with Zaff, Razz, and Mich also and am willing on going for a split vote.
 
Sorry I mistyped that it should be not knowing your role. My bad!
 
O' come on Ice and Jpap, starting a train already!?!? As of now Zaffy is my top suspect but Jpap, now knowing your role make you second in my mind.

I'd like some clarification on this. I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt that it was a typo, but this raises HUGE red flags to me.
 
O' come on Ice and Jpap, starting a train already!?!? As of now Zaffy is my top suspect but Jpap, now knowing your role make you second in my mind.

What is Jpaps role?
 
But how would he know that the doc was actually going to protect him this nightfall so the timing would work out? Can the doc protect the same person night after night?

Yes as far as I am aware in this setup the Doc can protect the same person over and over. But please don't put a tinfoil hate on, I was just talking out of my bum.
 
Razz...

so far you've had one mafia player as innocent, one as "IDK" and two innocents as mafia. Not to mention you just saved your neck only to lynch another innocent...

The more of Labs posts I read the more she looks less scummy. That may just be a good player tricking me but I almost want to switch my vote........ Now who looks more scummy?
Labrat

I think are innocent, I think are mafia, I can't tell yet

Dawg - I don't see anything scummy about Dawg. They seem to be helping the town.
DD - Hasn't been around much so I cannot lean her either way as of now.
Ice - Seems very different. It may just him being tired of being killed early or it may be a way for him to keep the town from lynching a mafia player.
JB - I can't tell for sure but there is just something about him that makes me think he is a mafia player. Mostly a gut feeling
JL - Seems pro-town but with what everyone else is saying I can't decide if I should take him completly off my list of suspects.
Jpap - Very pro-town, and very helpful so far.
Labrat - The more I read what she has said the less I think she is mafia. Again, she may be pulling the wool over my eyes so I am leaning mafia but not quite. (She would be my 4th pick for mafia.)
Mich - Hasn't voted, hasn't put anything out there for us to go on and I son't know why. It worries me that he may be trying to stay off the radar with his lack of posting.
Noodles - I don't understand why people think she is mafia. Unless I missed something I don't see the case against her.
Razz - I know my role.
Rich - Again is a low poster and is only putting things out there that can't be built on.
Zaffy - Good player but I don't know their playing habits so I can't go either way.
Zsand - A good player but he just isn't sitting right with me. I can't put my finger on it but they just seem like they are playing a game from the mafia side.

HTH
 
Sorry I mistyped that it should be not knowing your role. My bad!

Still, I don't know anyones roll. So by that logic I should have you and everyone else 2nd on my list. It's not just the one word I have issue with.
 
You know what would be worthy of the "Lab Rat Snowglobe" award? If Ice were Mafia and convinced the Doc to protect him, then had JL put a Hit on him... boy I need to lay off the caffeine. lol

I thought of that too...:nilly:

That would have been a terribly risky proposition given that there's a huge chance that the doc wouldn't have been protecting Ice on the night they hit him.

It's an interesting thought, but I don't think it's likely.
 
AquariaCentral.com