mafia 63- Who is Who

[Lab_Rat]

So I went through all 700+ posts and pulled EVERYTHING Ag has posted in this game. I will do the same for Wizard next. Kash has already pulled everything for Razz.

Yay!

Thanks :

OK, Just finished my school work for the day and have to go do my paper routes now. Not sure if I will be back before nightfall, but just in case I will throw out a vote...

I vote to lynch Zaffy

I will probably change it if I return in time...

I should have time to go through the thread later this evening. Been busy since I have a unit test coming on Thursday and need to finish all the Unit assignments. :nilly:

From what I have read, this is the best theory out there right now. I hope your correct on this, Labby...

I vote to lynch Annie

Sorry for my lack of posting. I've been busy with school and work the past couple of days and probably should have dropped out of this game awhile back. No point in me doing that this late in the game though. :huh:

I have skimmed through the thread and my top suspects are:

Lab_Rat - for being the person to lead the attack on lynching Annie. I'm thinking that she thought Annie was the Policeman, and thought JL was a mafia goon. I think that she was planning on sacrificing JL after the Policeman was lynched to lead blame away from her. I do not think she is the Don because it would be too risky for the Don to lead an attack like that.

Jbradt - I think Jbradt is in communication with the Don as well as Lab_Rat. I think that is why he followed Lab_Rat's theory. I think there is a chance he could be the Don, but not sure.

Razz - From what I read in Kash's most recent post...he has not been putting many thoughts out there. I think there is a good chance that he is the Don. He said "Bye Rich! TTYL!" right before Rich was lynched. I think Razz chose Rich as his first investigation and that he slipped up by saying that. Now, he has come out and voted for me, and probably remembers from previous games, that I am an easy person to pick on.

I know that I followed Lab_Rat's theory. I wasn't able to skim through the whole thread at that point. It seemed like a solid theory, so I went with it.

With that being said; I vote to lynch Jbradt. I would be willing to vote for Razz, but see no point in doing that now since he has no votes. If people switch over to him, then I will.

I know that my habits this game may lead you to think I'm mafia, but I'm not.

What habits Ag? I see no habits. I see a big bunch of nothing from you. At least as an innocent you tried to defend yourself...at first. But this...nothing the whole game. And the timing of those posts...2 right after the game started, 2 right before nightfalls to simply not UD, 1 during nightfall to help RB find the fish he wanted, and 1 when you're being called out. I can't imagine Ice would make you don, but if he did you are really flying under the radar...in fact it's like you're a ghost. Did you investigate Rich? Did he tell you to not post so what happened last game didn't happen to you again?

Many of us are busy IRL. I'm lucky because I have a phone that I can post from, but I'd bet my fish my schedule is much busier than yours (do you have to get up at 5am to round on patients, do you get home from a full day of work after 7pm some nights?) Of course, not being able to sleep helps free up some game time too. I see you had time to find a new, creepy avatar too.

You voting for JB is pretty lolzy, seeing as JL's main case against him (from what I can tell) is that he voted like I did and he had a bit of time where he didn't post. You've posted nothing. You voted for my theory too. I have a feeling you're just jumping on the train to hide your scummyness. Or were you waiting for JL to tell me who to vote for so you would not raise suspicions with the policeman?

I want to vote for you. I really hope JL comes back online and realizes you'd be a better lynch option than JB.

 

[jbradt]

Well JL, he's posted now. I do know his work claim is legit with what he does so if his lack of posting in a certain time frame (when he may have been at work) is why he's scummy then I don't like that. If he's scummy because he followed my theory I don't like that either (like I said, I thought it was sound). :wall:

But, you are the policeman. I said I would follow your vote. I will. But not happily. I hope you get back online before nightfall to confirm that he was investigated and is indeed mafia. You can at least humor me with that much.

I vote to lynch JB. I hope you're right on this JL.

Let me also adress the bolded part... not the vote. HE CAN'T. As I've stated before, the mayor has obviously not investigated me. And even if he had, JL wouldn't be able to say I"m mafia. IT'S NOT TRUE. But feel free to keep wasting your time and votes...

 

[jbradt]

OOO! Look! I found the menu from the local diner!

 

[Lab_Rat]

This will be a bit longer than Ag's but really there's not much more content.

Wiz starts off pretty well on Day 1 for a noob.

here we go

thanks spidey

im off to work and will post when i get home in about 12-13 hours

wow! come home and find a lot of posts to read. Didn't see a whole lot of anything but as was mentioned no one knows who their teammates are.I have seen a lot of good discussion back and forth however about strategies.

There were a few things that stuck out however.

First of all, as mentioned, trs comes on and says very interesting then states that he didn't read the thread?says he has to catch up? didn't post again. Also didn't answer the queries as to what was "interesting"

FF jumping in with a lynch vote right off the bat. Then changing it so often. Why is he behaving like he has so early in the game? Does he eat too much sugar or drink too much caffeine? Then type like you would expect someone in that condition to talk? Or is he simply trying to draw attention to himself on purpose? The behavior is odd no matter what the reason.

As was mentioned earlier and multiple times there just isn't much to go on to place a vote.

Again as mentioned earlier it is a 50/50 chance of hitting mafia.

I need to vote tonight as I will be at work still when nightfall happens.

It is tempting to vote for ff but something doesn't smell right about his behavior

trs hasn't done anything but say interesting. hasn't answered the inquiries just disappeared
I need to consider this for a minute.

This seems like he's looking for scum. Good job noobie!

zsand and razzlefish have both been pretty absent as well. being new i don't know if that is their style or not

Umm, Zs isn't playing this one...

Fish, you have made a lot of posts already but haven't posted anything helpful. All you have done is make yourself stand out from the crowd and draw a lot of suspicion.

I realize that you are new but from reading the thread you should be able to pick up on the purpose and strategy from the experienced players.

HMMMM.....

Yes, and this was the time I was kicking at FF a bit and catching a bunch of flack for it. Double standards there Kash?

ooops. It was a long monday. my mistake.
ok i need to vote as nightfall comes before my next opportunity to log in here.
I was just hoping to see something to steer my thoughts one way or the other.

ff has made quite a few posts but hasn't posted anything to help the town. Then again ff is playing his newb card already (you can leave it at the door when you log off thank you...)

on the other hand trs isn't a newb. made one post , then left. obviously all that did was stir up suspicion. I am sure that he would know that would be the result so why would he do that?

what ever the reason it doesn't help the town at all. it got the experienced players looking at him.

ok here goes i am worrying this thing like a dog does a bone and not getting anywhere


I vote to lynch TRS

Still doing well for his first game, seems pro town. But from here on out I get very concerned with the sudden lack of participation. It's like someone told him to shut up. Let others make cases and take the heat. To lay low.

...
I vote to lynch ff

As did a bunch of other scum...

we got two all right! I knew that the jl annie thing was best left to the mayor. who didn't agree? Oh yeah
I vote to lynch jbradt

Haven't added a thing since the last nightfall. You never explain why JB is your vote. Is it because it's what all the cool kids are doing?

Less going on today. Made it a lot easier to get caught up to speed. Looks like JL is enjoying his "puppy" :dog: :rofl:

I can't wait to see what happens next.

Why don't you try to help the town find scum instead of sitting on the sidelines? Scum sits on the sidelines, waiting for a townie to do something they can twist and manipulate for the mafias favor.

I don't know what to think of you Wiz. You seem quite intelligent, your day 1 play was very promising and seemed protown, but your play since Rich was lynched simply stinks.

 

[jbradt]

Here you go Labby...

I have to say, it's nice to see you kicking some bushes again, but I think the transformation may be past the point of no return... at least until your vote changes...

 

[Lab_Rat]

Why isn't there a Zombie smiley?

WTF, Labby? Now you're a brain eating, undead puppy? I thought you had some integrity to stand up to this bs, but I guess if the leash fits...

We've got a non-confrontational Jpap, a cop who would rather kick innocents than work with us, and a Labby who's no longer looking for scum. This isn't ACville, it's the ****ing twilight zone... :screwy::nutkick::1zhelp:

:yuck: It is absolutely killing me to trust JL blindly but he has been proven innocent, which is more than can be said for you. I have to believe he is acting in the town's best interest. Therefore, since I want to act in the town's best interest I will vote how he votes...no matter how much that makes me :crazy: :yuck: :headshake2: He has access to the mayor and information that I don't have access to. So logic trumps my feelings toward the situation... and brains are gross, I don't want Cruetzfeldt-Jakob disease, so I'll pass on the brains, tyvm...

Jpap's sudden shift from ankle-biting chihuahua to fluffy little poodle has confused me too. Maybe JL has him on a leash too...

And I'm still looking for scum, even though I am not voting with my gut. That comment is a bit offensive JB. Do you really think I've stopped trying? Or was that just an OMGUS sort of comment?

This game has been weird...twilight zone is a good description. :hypnotized: The lack of participation, I just don't know what to make of it.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Here you go Labby...

I have to say, it's nice to see you kicking some bushes again, but I think the transformation may be past the point of no return... at least until your vote changes...

mg:mg:mg: Now when I wake up with nightmares, are you gonna be the one to check under the bed and in the closet for monsters???

 

[jbradt]

:yuck: It is absolutely killing me to trust JL blindly but he has been proven innocent, which is more than can be said for you. I have to believe he is acting in the town's best interest. Therefore, since I want to act in the town's best interest I will vote how he votes...no matter how much that makes me :crazy: :yuck: :headshake2: He has access to the mayor and information that I don't have access to. So logic trumps my feelings toward the situation... and brains are gross, I don't want Cruetzfeldt-Jakob disease, so I'll pass on the brains, tyvm...

Jpap's sudden shift from ankle-biting chihuahua to fluffy little poodle has confused me too. Maybe JL has him on a leash too...

And I'm still looking for scum, even though I am not voting with my gut. That comment is a bit offensive JB. Do you really think I've stopped trying? Or was that just an OMGUS sort of comment?

This game has been weird...twilight zone is a good description. :hypnotized: The lack of participation, I just don't know what to make of it.

OMGUS? Hardly. It just seems to me like the mood of the town has gone from trying to find scum to trying to placate JL. I figured you'd have some balls after coming out with your version of the tinfoil hat conspiracy, but aparently you've tucked your tail between your legs only to whimper off into a corner. Offensive? Don't get me started.

I understand that JL's confirmed innocent. I also understand that he doesn't have any more to go on than the rest of us. If he did, his vote would not be on me. Offensive? How about an authority figure who demands trust/respect/obedience without giving anything back to the people he's demanding these things from.

I get it, JL; you're confirmed innocent. But I still feel as though you're not playing square with us. And innocent or not, that's a scummy thing to do.

 

[jbradt]

mg:mg:mg: Now when I wake up with nightmares, are you gonna be the one to check under the bed and in the closet for monsters???

Yes, once this game's over I can go back to liking you. :laugh::rofl::raspberry:

 

[Lab_Rat]

I understand that JL's confirmed innocent. I also understand that he doesn't have any more to go on than the rest of us. If he did, his vote would not be on me. Offensive? How about an authority figure who demands trust/respect/obedience without giving anything back to the people he's demanding these things from.

He is in communication with the mayor...did ya miss that part? :headshake2: Like I said, he has access to the results of the investigations from that. Obviously he is holding those results for himself, but I have to assume he has good reason for doing so. Now whether the mayor investigated you and found you to be mafia, I don't know. That is what I really want to know from JL, but he's not around. I think it's pretty clear I'm not happy about the situation, voting without being given real evidence...

And :silly: