mafia 63- Who is Who

[RazzleFish]

JL, I do agree with Jpap. It would help a lot to know for sure 'who is who'. Pardon the pun! Even if none of the invests show who is mafia, we can still cross names off of our lists.

 

[johnlarson66]

JL, I do agree with Jpap. It would help a lot to know for sure 'who is who'. Pardon the pun! Even if none of the invests show who is mafia, we can still cross names off of our lists.

Razz, why not show us your list?

There are 5 mafia left - care to name any suspects?

 

[johnlarson66]

The town has lost two innocents to UDs. The innocents lead could switch real quick with another innocent UD.

Follow who you want to follow, put out some information. Ask questions.

This is not the officer john game. I have one kill and I will use it on a confirmed mafia. I can't do crap until the next day. If it looks like the mayor might be in trouble, I will step in and save them.

The town still has to lynch mafia players.

 

[Kashta]

Well that was great! Too bad Annie wasn't a more important player but hey, mafia is mafia is mafia! I don't like how Ag is playing this game........ Or should I say how Ag is not playing this game? I feel temped to vote that way but why? It wouldn't do much for the town unless others did the same. I could see myself voting for RB but the whole rules thing was odd and It didn't point him in either direction. I could see him being mafia but I could also see him as innocent. I vote to lynch Ag. This vote may change but until I hear from them, this is where it will stay.

Razzle, I find it interesting that you singled out Agass like that and voted him because he hasn't done anything in this game. I've just gone back to look at the posts you've made.... and they just don't say anything. It's been like that with you the whole time.

Your posts also have an odd pattern about them, as well. When you have posted, which wasn't very often, it wasn't because you had something to tell us. It's more like you were just reporting in to document some reason... some excuse.. for not saying anything at all.

Hey! Just got home and I see as always there isn't much going on.

Wow 233 posts before night 1! There should be a limit of how much you guys can post while I'm away! I skimmed through and no doubt I missed a lot so my vote is going to be an OMGUS. I vote to lynch RB......... for now.

Jpap, that vote will most likely change but you know how it is on day 1. Not much to go on and gut feelings are worthless so eventually I was going to have to pick someone.

Jbradt even questioned you about this already

Anything real to share in the way of thoughts or insight, Razz?

And here was your reply.

No, just day one stuff. I wish day one was over already so we could get something to go on but as of now I have nothing. Sorry!

Then that same pattern continues.. goes on.

Well there isn't much info out there so it looks like my vote is going to stay where it is. Now how to kill some time until nightfall? Oh I know! Look at fish I can't get!

Then came nightfall on Day 1.

Just moments before Rich got lynched, you told him "bye" and said that you would talk to him later. I remember that now and it's a very weird thing for someone to do. Pappy noticed it too.

Bye Rich! TTYL

Hmmmm...

Razzle.. I'm having a hard time trying to think of another explanation for that post... a farewell to someone about to be killed.

Were you in contact with Rich already at that point behind the scenes as communicating teammates?

Is Rich the one you picked to investigate first on Day 1 after Ice told you what your role assignment was?

If that wasn't the case, Razz, and you weren't communicating directly with Rich.... then how were you still going to be able to talk to him later.... AFTER he got killed off in the game?

Continuing on with other posts you made in this game...

In the post below, the first part addresses Fishfriend and the notes he was posting. But in the rest of that post, it's the first time in this game where you actually make a suggestion about what we might do.

Nope, their worthless! JK I am sure we all read them but there just isn't much to say about them. I encourage you to continue sharing them but don't expect people to coment that much on them. You have said what you think is going to happen but because of the format of this game there isn't much to talk about with your notes. There is no way of linking anyone yet.

This is just a thought and I would like some input but what do you guys think about making it a tie between Annie and JL? I am thinking not but I just wanted to hear your thoughts. I don't think FF is mafia. I know that when I was mafia and knew I was getting lynched I shut up. I would expect a noob to do the same but I may be off. My top 3 are as follows in no particular order:

JL- Claming to be the cop.
Annie- Also claiming to be the cop.
FF- I know I said I don't think he's mafia but with what everyone else has said I feel I should put him up here. Also I don't have anything for the other players so........

Let me get this straight, Razzle. You're supposed to be working on the town side... or at least pretending to be so you can fool us if you're actually on the mafia team. Then two different players in the game had just stepped out of their anonymous roles to announce that they were both the townie policeman.

They couldn't both be telling the truth, of course, because the town only has one policeman. And your best suggestion at the time was for us to make it a tie.

You wanted the real cop on the innocent team to have a 50-50 chance of being killed. And... knowing all the time that half the voters were town and half the voters were mafia... you thought it might be a good idea to leave the fate of the town side's power role... to chance??

Then, you went on after making that statement to list both JL and Annie as your two top suspects in the game.

Also in the same post (highlighted with blue text), You told us that you don't believe FF is on the mafia side. THEN you listed FF as your third best mafia suspect. And you decided that you're willing to vote for somebody and help to lynch somebody that YOU BELIEVE IS INNOCENT if that's what everyone else wants you to do.

Razzle, I'd really like you to explain what your REAL thoughts and intentions were at the time you made that post.

After this, you started talking to FF again in your posts. Then you decided to vote him for the lynch.

You know you can go do something else and check back in later. You don't have to wait and reply after every post.

Wait why would you want to seem unpredictable? Wouldn't you want people to know your innocent? I may have to rethink my previous post.

I can! I vote to lynch FF. I gave him the benefit of the doubt, but he threw that out the window.

Well I don't know what to think. This is a very quiet game and with the posts that were made we haven't got anything good. FF, I am not even going to say anything about your notes but the whole banter against Kash was weird. I think you WAY over thought that. My vote is not going to change and I hope you just vote to lynch yourself. I have a feeling that you are a noob that got stuck with a mafia role that he doesn't know how to play. I think you are trying very hard to make your first game go well but it takes time to become a good enough player to be mafia and still make it to the end. Also, since I can tell that you are going to die, would you care to share with us what you were planning to post after death?

Something about the way that post is written really sounds like you've made some kind of a personal connection with FF. Maybe that's because you identified with the position you came to believe he must be in... as someone else who was also "stuck" with a mafia role that you "didn't quite know how to play."

Most of the posts you made (before today) came from our first day of play, Razzle. After that, you got really quiet.... You didn't post as much or as often the next day after the game started to pick and there was a lot more going on.

In the posts today, you say you'd like to know what the mayor has managed to find out. Yes.... I'm sure that's true. As clearly as it seems from your own posts that you're on the opposing team, you must really wonder how much our mayor has found out about you.

 

[IceH2O]

Night Fall in 20 hrs

Pms as required


Day 3

JB-3- Mad(635) Kash(644) Wiz(650)

RB-2- LB(642) Jpap(697) Zaffy(705)

Ag-1- Razz (698)

no votes: Ag JB Lab JL RB

 

[johnlarson66]

I think it is odd that JB has not posted. I also wish the players that are still playing would give a list out. I am not sure if I trust everyone on JB, so we will see who moves.

JB and Agas on my top two.

I vote to lynch JB.

I also hope Lab_Rat follows me on this vote...

 

[johnlarson66]

Is there anyone that wants to be investigated by the mayor? The good news is if you are innocent, you can join the communicating innocents, the bad news is that if you are mafia, you will get shot.

But slowly...

There is no shame in conceding. All the Don has to do is send Ice a pm.

 

[johnlarson66]

g/o

I will not be around at nightfall or very much tomorrow. There is the Carolina Games Summit in Goldsboro, NC on Saturday and ELITE ZONE has a few teams playing, plus I have a booth for advertising. I will leave early in the morning and come late at night. I might hop in a PC somewhere, but most likely will be too busy.

g/o

 

[Lab_Rat]

I think it is odd that JB has not posted. I also wish the players that are still playing would give a list out. I am not sure if I trust everyone on JB, so we will see who moves.

JB and Agas on my top two.

I vote to lynch JB.

I also hope Lab_Rat follows me on this vote...

Did the mayor investigate JB and find him to be mafia? If so I will vote for him. Or at least please give me a reason, other than that he hasn't posted (because that can be said for many). I don't do well following blindly...it's not my nature.

 

[Agassizii]

Sorry for my lack of posting. I've been busy with school and work the past couple of days and probably should have dropped out of this game awhile back. No point in me doing that this late in the game though. :huh:

I have skimmed through the thread and my top suspects are:

Lab_Rat - for being the person to lead the attack on lynching Annie. I'm thinking that she thought Annie was the Policeman, and thought JL was a mafia goon. I think that she was planning on sacrificing JL after the Policeman was lynched to lead blame away from her. I do not think she is the Don because it would be too risky for the Don to lead an attack like that.

Jbradt - I think Jbradt is in communication with the Don as well as Lab_Rat. I think that is why he followed Lab_Rat's theory. I think there is a chance he could be the Don, but not sure.

Razz - From what I read in Kash's most recent post...he has not been putting many thoughts out there. I think there is a good chance that he is the Don. He said "Bye Rich! TTYL!" right before Rich was lynched. I think Razz chose Rich as his first investigation and that he slipped up by saying that. Now, he has come out and voted for me, and probably remembers from previous games, that I am an easy person to pick on.

I know that I followed Lab_Rat's theory. I wasn't able to skim through the whole thread at that point. It seemed like a solid theory, so I went with it.

With that being said; I vote to lynch Jbradt. I would be willing to vote for Razz, but see no point in doing that now since he has no votes. If people switch over to him, then I will.

I know that my habits this game may lead you to think I'm mafia, but I'm not.