Mafia 65: Masons and Mafia (Game Thread)

[Dangerdoll]

Well from what little Mafia ability I have I've scanned the posts. And I've seen two extremes.

JL- seems determined to defend himself from anything, constantly talking like hes an innocent that doesn't want to die so early,

DD- He seems to come and go. Posting very "deep" things and then dissapearing again like he wants to make his point but doesn't want to say something stupid that would reveal his role.
I vote to Lynch DirtyDawg

FF does seem to post inside out, I can see how this might be what he meant to say as well.

I think the JL-FF thing is really nothing. I don't think it says anything about either one of these guys. It's a miscommunication because one tends to put a lot of thought and meaning into his posts and the other just posts a whole lot.

What I think we can learn from it is how other people react to it. Dirtydawg has certainly reacted to it. I want to go back and read up on LR and some others first. but I'd be inclined to vote DD right now.

ummmm... can we call Dawg, "Dawg" during the game? Using DD for him is confusing I think.... it was established in one of the earlier games that we would go this way.... just some advice

 

[IceH2O]

I can see a case against Dawg, he did come out firing on FF. Maybe he figured he is an easy target and most would want him gone just for the fact he can be somewhat annoying with his posts.

But with that said I don't like some of the players on Dawg namely FF JL and TX.
Lets make it interesting and see what happens with another voter on FF.

I retract my vote on JL and vote to lynch FF

 

[IceH2O]

Well from what little Mafia ability I have I've scanned the posts. And I've seen two extremes.

JL- seems determined to defend himself from anything, constantly talking like hes an innocent that doesn't want to die so early,

DD- He seems to come and go. Posting very "deep" things and then dissapearing again like he wants to make his point but doesn't want to say something stupid that would reveal his role.
I vote to Lynch DirtyDawg

This is the post I don't like from Tex.

JL is a suspect but he votes on the same person as JL.

 

[Zaffy]

Ok, I want to clarify that i never actualy came out and said that JL was mafia, just that he said what mafia would do. Then dawg came in and screwed up by thinking i accused Jl of being mafia. It was that that set me off, not JL himself. I now have Dawg as top suspect and Jl as seconed, because they may be on a team. All in All I vote to lynch Dawg.

Why is Dawg your number 1, and JL your number 2? Why do you think they are on the same team?

 

[IceH2O]

Why is Dawg your number 1, and JL your number 2? Why do you think they are on the same team?

Tex did the same thing and then voted Dawg same as FF.

 

[Zaffy]

ummmm... can we call Dawg, "Dawg" during the game? Using DD for him is confusing I think.... it was established in one of the earlier games that we would go this way.... just some advice

Yeah, my bad. when I said DD, I meant DirtyDawg.

 

[Zaffy]

Tex did the same thing and then voted Dawg same as FF.

I'd like to see them both write 100 words or more explaining how they have come to this conclusion.

 

[IceH2O]

I'd like to see them both write 100 words or more explaining how they have come to this conclusion.

I'd like to see why also,especially since if they had voted JL he'd have had 3 votes Dawg would have 2 and FF would have 2 but they wouldn't have voted with their suspect. Doesn't make any sense at all.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Here is my post and my response to jpap using the train word.



Here jpap explains his comment and that he expects to see the votes spread out.



Here Ice chimes in -



Then some more input from Ice (both very good points) -



Then some insanity from FF -



Then here is the bone that dawg is chewing on -



Here is what FF is quoting me as saying "that the mafia wont try to stat a train on someone they know is innocent." Now can someone please put that in some sort of context? I have no clue what FF is even talking about and for the last 30 minutes have read his post and really want my 30 minutes back. I am way better off skimming them.

Why is this the lone crazy talk from FF that dawg is focused on. How about FF saying I am starting a train? How about FF saying that Zaffy is defending jpap? How about FF declaring jpap innocent? I am sure there is much more craziness from FF. I am going to stick to skimming his posts.

Dawg taking FF serious is what I have issue with and then somehow linking me to FF. If FF and I talked outside the thread and I said what he is quoting me as saying then we are talking about the mafia.

I vote to lynch Dirtydawg10.

The other thing I don't like about your thinking JL is that you jump all over JPap and vote for JPap for calling 8 votes on 1 person a train. Then FF calls your single vote on JPap a train and no comment from you. Makes no sense.

I also don't like how you talk about not taking FF serious. If he's playing the game and has a possibility of being mafia you have to take him seriously yet you suggest people should skim his posts. In fact there are several people who apparently think FF should not be looked at.

The last paragraph of your post JL is the only thing I'm worried about. I thought about that before but I didn't want to bring too much light to it. If FF screwed up he may have just outed the innocent communicators...that wouldn't be good. I'm guessing if FF and JL are not mafia we will know by the next day regardless of who votes to lynch them.

Ok, I want to clarify that i never actualy came out and said that JL was mafia, just that he said what mafia would do. Then dawg came in and screwed up by thinking i accused Jl of being mafia. It was that that set me off, not JL himself. I now have Dawg as top suspect and Jl as seconed, because they may be on a team. All in All I vote to lynch Dawg.

Who said you called JL mafia? I never said you accused JL of being mafia I said it appears you were talking to JL outside the thread. The communicating part led me to believe you were comm mafia because I would have hoped that comm innocents would be much more careful. If I'm wrong and you get lynched and turn up innocent I'm sure I'll be heavily scrutinized the next day. However right now it appears I may be the one to go.

Me and JL a team??? lol...JL you may want to reel him in just a bit. I understand you wouldn't be able to do that today anyway since there is no communication going on right now.

 

[the wizard]

I too have taken notice of that.

I am not sure what to make of this day yet. There has been a lot going on for day 1 yet something doesn't set right.

I can't put my finger on it yet.

I am watching Dawg, Jl, and FF for sure.

Hard to read Dawg because of the way he posts, but as was mentioned, he came out firing on FF pretty hard.

Jl was very defensive about being associated with FF. Seemed to shift gears, but, couldn't stay away from being defensive.

FF is FF. Posting all over the place as usual, but possibly posting some info he shouldn't have. From a pre game message board maybe? Or is it just the fact as jpap pointed out, that he posts inside out and it was from the game thread? I don't know yet.

At any rate I don't see the need to worry about FF at this time as he could be handy for the town. He does, after all, tend to get excited and type and post faster than he thinks. This could be beneficial to the town, especially the non communicating citizens.

Besides, the FF factor alone will eventually get him lynched. lol.

My main concern as it stands right now, are the more experienced players like Dawg and JL. I think JL slipped up with his defensiveness and is having a little bit of trouble trying to cover for it.

Dawgs initial go at FF was simple and understandable enough. It was after all just a question. I think, however, that he slipped up when it turned into a debate and he just couldn't let go.