Mafia 65: Masons and Mafia (Game Thread)
- Thread starter Madcrawdad
- Start date
Lots of prodding going on. Its hard to take a true read when a third of the players are barely hanging in there. I was expecting a bit more from Tex than what he posted as well.
As far as the FF-JL thing goes I just think they have two very different styles of play, I could see either one of them being mafia, it doesn't seem like a distancing spat though so I doubt they both are. Of the two FF comes off slightly more scummy, although I haven't played with FF as much as JL so that could once again just be my read on the FF style.
Dawg I see very little to point to as scum yet. I'm going to reread and see where the sudden shift is in popular opinion is based.
As far as the FF-JL thing goes I just think they have two very different styles of play, I could see either one of them being mafia, it doesn't seem like a distancing spat though so I doubt they both are. Of the two FF comes off slightly more scummy, although I haven't played with FF as much as JL so that could once again just be my read on the FF style.
Dawg I see very little to point to as scum yet. I'm going to reread and see where the sudden shift is in popular opinion is based.
I understand what you're getting at Ice...it makes little sense to vote with someone who you suspect to be mafia with the person you are voting for...but at the same time you have to wonder if FF would actually think that all through.
I do wish FF would put more thought and analysis into voting rather than just vote on every whim...same goes for just posting in general.
Seems to me that FF's vote is an OMGUS. Which fits in with the way he has played the previous 2 games.
What really is bugging me right now, is Dawg's insistence that JL and FF were (are) communicating. I think that's a really weak thing to be pushing right now given that a mason could just as easily slip up, especially someone who plays like FF.
Dawg, could you also please read my post (#145) on how FF came to the conclusion that he did. I personally think it's pretty obvious that FF just has a weird way of rewording what people have said. I cannot, however, explain the other odd things FF has said...ie, why he assumed I was innocent.
Dag's vote on FF seems really convenient given the fact that FF has been pushed around a lot this game. His only reasoning is based on FF's gamestyle despite the fact he acknowledges that FF is playing like normal. I do have to say that it would be a perfect plan for the mafia, or even the masons, to keep FF out in the open and actually away from the noose because he's played so spastic in every game. The problem is, there's no way of knowing that so I find using that reasoning to be weak and convenient given the circumstances.
Razz is about the only one who has yet to get into the game. Kash posted some theory at least. Tex voted, granted, the timing seemed off to me. Annie apparently is busy...what's there to be so silent about, Razz?
Dawg, could you also please read my post (#145) on how FF came to the conclusion that he did. I personally think it's pretty obvious that FF just has a weird way of rewording what people have said. I cannot, however, explain the other odd things FF has said...ie, why he assumed I was innocent.
Dag's vote on FF seems really convenient given the fact that FF has been pushed around a lot this game. His only reasoning is based on FF's gamestyle despite the fact he acknowledges that FF is playing like normal. I do have to say that it would be a perfect plan for the mafia, or even the masons, to keep FF out in the open and actually away from the noose because he's played so spastic in every game. The problem is, there's no way of knowing that so I find using that reasoning to be weak and convenient given the circumstances.
Razz is about the only one who has yet to get into the game. Kash posted some theory at least. Tex voted, granted, the timing seemed off to me. Annie apparently is busy...what's there to be so silent about, Razz?
To continue with your questions, DD has posted but given no original thoughts. All she has done is repeat what others have already posted.
Do you not have any thoughts that might benefit the town DD?
I am sure that we would like to get your opinion as to what has transpired to this point.
I know I ALWAYS hate voting with someone I suspect, in this format though I am not sure it can be avoided. To many opportunities to either vote on a teammate with no repercussions or to not vote at all for that matter. I have a feeling Day 1 at least we are not going to be coming to a nice super-majority.
I can see your point about FF. Also about Dawg.
I agree Razz and Kash both need to step up and give us some thoughts. Hiding, especially in this games format is very suspicious to me.
What are your thoughts about how defensive JL became when linked to FF?
What about how Tex also listed Dawg and JL then voted with JL on Dawg?
Tex I'd like an explanation about that from you as well.
I agree with Wiz, DD has nothing but fluff posts. I know its hard to be committed especially on Day 1 but you have to have some kind of thought. Or do you just plan on voting with the masses?
I'm not ready to pull my vote off FF. His answers really don't put me at ease that he is in fact innocent.His answers almost seem like he has no answer to the question and is beating around the bush.
I agree Razz and Kash both need to step up and give us some thoughts. Hiding, especially in this games format is very suspicious to me.
What are your thoughts about how defensive JL became when linked to FF?
What about how Tex also listed Dawg and JL then voted with JL on Dawg?
Tex I'd like an explanation about that from you as well.
I agree with Wiz, DD has nothing but fluff posts. I know its hard to be committed especially on Day 1 but you have to have some kind of thought. Or do you just plan on voting with the masses?
I'm not ready to pull my vote off FF. His answers really don't put me at ease that he is in fact innocent.His answers almost seem like he has no answer to the question and is beating around the bush.
Hey guys sorry I haven't been on. I have been busy all day and I just got a few minutes to get on so I have to wait until I get home to catch up and get my thoughts out there.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
the problem I am having is with FF. I see the whiole JL/FF/Dawg thing and I guess I am just as frazzled as everyone else with it but the one that really tugs at me is FF. Yes, this is his style, for the past games I have played with him, he has made my head spin with his posting frenzies.... but the thing is, how can we really be sure that he is just being consistent with his style because that's just how he is... I mean, don't you think that if he was quiet this game, he would be even a bigger suspect? With that said, I think Dawg might have gone head first in trying to get folks to think about FF... but I am stuck with this because of my back and forth thoughts on FF. Was that the intention? I don't know...
how interesting, wiz.... I am wondering the same thing about you... where are your "original thoughts"? What are you offering that might "benefit the town"? What is your "opinion that has transpired up to this point"?
