Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[Madcrawdad]

Tomorrows topic will be Lab vs Ice.

If FF turns up mafia I was protecting a team mate, if he turns up innocent then I was mafia protecting an innocent. Lab has already said as much.

Why wouldn't it be? You apparently found FF's actions scummy, but then chased off after Lab because she might be bussing a scum buddy. Wouldn't it make more sense to vote the one you found scummy, and not the one who might be tossing him under the bus?

I disagree, why protect FF if you think he is a team mate and out yourself when you could just pile on and hide among the masses? He is only 1 player, after he is gone the odds that you'd pick another mafia player are much lower since everyone is on him.

So, how would the scum team go about choosing same-aligned investigation targets to build their team if everyone is trying to blend?

 

[Lab_Rat]

How would they do this? Only 3 know who is what, there are 4 players that each team can accidentally hit or lynch of their own.

If what you said is true there would be 7 on you and 7 on FF and the SB would be the deciding vote.

You might want to read through some of these type games. You'll see it never plays out the scenario you just posted. Each team takes out their own.

That's actually what I expect to happen by the time nightfall hits. It's why Kash's vote on me did not surprise me one bit.

 

[Dagamoth]

How would they do this? Only 3 know who is what, there are 4 players that each team can accidentally hit or lynch of their own.

If what you said is true there would be 7 on you and 7 on FF and the SB would be the deciding vote.

You might want to read through some of these type games. You'll see it never plays out the scenario you just posted. Each team takes out their own.

While each might take out some of their own it would be on accident. With this format if you get the feeling someone might be on your side isn't worth trying to save them instead of just saying "well we were probably going to kill some of our own anyway"? Pretty much no matter what the format you want to keep your own people alive unless they have been completely outed like Noods last game.

 

[johnlarson66]

Not saying I should shoulder all the blame, I'm saying that is what I think will happen though.

At this point, my suspects are those who have defended FF. Due to the 50/50 format of this game it's essential for both teams to retain as many of their own as possible. That means if they think FF may be scum then he's worth saving.

Can we have a list of names?

 

[IceH2O]

Like how high up is noods on everyones mafia list? (top 3 here)

Noods doesn't make my top 3 at this time. I already posted my suspect list but even that could change depending on what FF turns.

I understand she said she didn't have time to post much but at the same time it does concern me that when she finds time to post she hasn't really said anything.

 

[Kashta]

Guess I'm as caught up as I'm going to get.

I see no reason to switch anything tonight. Lab Rat is still being argumentative with anyone who posts anything in disagreement with her initial actions or anything else she posts. When someone goes on the attack like this (especially in this format) and then gets either defensive or argumentative about it afterward.... that reads as a scummy position to take.

Labby, if you're mafia... at least you're being consistently evil/conspiratorial in your point of view. If you're innocent, then shame on you for letting the innocent team down by taking this approach.

I expect to keep LR as a top suspect now whether FF turns out to be innocent, evil, or the serial bomber... based on her anti-town behavior. I feel it's because of her that prevents us from getting a more objective read on which role FF was given.

 

[Dagamoth]

Where have I said, "it is just a revenge vote"?

Dag, your initial vote on FF was a revenge vote, then later after the FF train had starting rolling you jumped on board. What else have you done?

So you are my top suspect and have a lone worthless vote on you from me, what is the issue. What have else have you done? Any thoughts on my other suspects, noods and JB? Thoughts on Lab?

What if FF is truely just inept and not mafia at all, then what? Besides being in a battle of wits with a much smarter person and being on the defense, what has FF done that has been so scummy? I don't like how he can't keep his own facts striaght, but again I have that more and more leaning to ineptness.

Sorry I forgot to address the last part in my previous post. Are you saying that LR started a battle of wits when she said that FF posting a whole bunch of non sense would only serve to confuse the innocents and be beneficial to the mafia to which FF replied after this obvious challenge i wish the mafia would investigate me?

 

[Lab_Rat]

Can we have a list of names?

I've made it pretty clear who I consider scummy. I'll give you my top 3 again, minus FF.

JB
Ice
Kash

 

[Fishfriend1]

*sigh* maybe tomorrow there will be a different topic of discussion?

Yep, ill be dead.

Why is that? If FF shows innocent, but was acting scummy, then why should you get blamed?

Besides his reactions to you, what has he done? Besides people that have "defended" FF, who are your suspects. Your suspect list seems to be more OMGUSy than anything FF has done.

Plz dont blame lab if i die, i really think that she is innocent and confused.

My list includes
noods, for note ringing any bells.

JL, for the same reason

Jp/jb (get them confused) for defending me to much, even if im innocent.

I hope that makes sense in at least one way...

 

[jpappy789]

FF, my vote's been on you for a while now.