Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

IceH2O said:
I never posted I moved him to innocent on Day 1. I think my actions implied I had him leaning more toward innocent though.
Click to expand...
Oh, I see...

So which actions? When you said this?

IceH2O said:
Still not saying FF is innocent mind you just hate to see a 1 horse race. Its possible Lab is also a non comm mafia doing her best to look innocent and if they both are mafia its a no lose situation.
Click to expand...

Sure looks like you're leaving all options open. Huh?

The fact you even have the guts to say the following on D2 is pretty humorous...
IceH2O said:
Since I'm one of the people who thought FF was innocent I'm going to answer this.

I thought it was pretty obvious,well as obvious as FF can be. He started posting things that didn't set right with me thus my vote.It didn't really strike me till later in the day when I went back to reread that I saw Lab had bolded just 1 part of a sentence and took it out of context. This is a scum tactic to draw the eye to the negativity of the post instead of to the entire context of the post. At that time I figured Lab was mafia and assumed FF was innocent. Did I know for sure? Not in the least but the more Lab went after him the more I thought it was a better chance that Lab was scummy and I wasn't going to vote with her.

To the last question I don't understand it. If I'm mafia and thought FF was a lost cause why would I vote Lab and not him. If a lost cause I'd just pile on and hide with the masses.
Click to expand...

Never happened, Ice.
 
rich311k said:
Happens just about every lynch. I dont think you have said anything really about who is your favorite. You are leaning JB and noods but are going to lynch LR.
Click to expand...


I've been on Lab since Day 1. As of todays posts Noods moved right up there with her. You and Annie are on my list but not as high. JB I'm not as sure of though I can see why you guys think he might be,so no I'm not convinced on JB enough to vote him especially with 3 of my suspects on him.

If certain players would move to Noods I'd also move and give Lab the benefit of the doubt for tonight. Then see where the lynch takes us for the following day. If no one wanted to move to Noods then I'm contempt with staying on Lab and either be happy when she shows mafia or take the heat if she shows innocent.
 
Lab's behavior yesterday when she pursued FF so aggressively leads me to believe that she isn't mafia. From all my experience mafia don't hunt down people on the first day like that it makes them easy targets later on. Although this game format is different and it is possible that LR has adjusted mafia strategy accordingly. I doubt that however as I was just as suspect about FF when he asked to be investigated. Since no one has been able to explain how FF getting investigated could benefit the innocents I really have a problem with the people who wanted to leave FF alive. Mainly Jb and Kash. This format is a numbers game and innocents need to get the numbers in their favor, yes we might have been able to learn more had someone other then FF been lynched but I think that trying to kill a mafia is more important. Now it sucks that FF turned out to be innocent but he was acting extremely scummy and I personally didn't think he would still be carrying around that noob card (it's got to fall apart some time right?). I think most people felt he slipped when he said he wanted the mafia to investigate him and that is why there was the defense of him. I am not saying that all the people who didn't vote for FF were mafia but I am guessing that there are definitely a few of them who are.

JL's vote last night also got me to wondering. His vote for me was essentially a vote for FF since it was a worthless vote yet it kept his name from the list on FF. Either he was thinking FF was SB or FF was mafia but he didn't want to be associated with the vote on him. Also saying that my vote FF was nothing but a revenge vote when i had clearly said about 4 times up till last nightfall that it started as a joke revenge vote but became serious vote when FF said he wanted mafia to investigate him. He even said
johnlarson66 said:
So Dag's vote on FF is no longer a random revenge vote...
Click to expand...

then when he votes for me (instead of voting for FF but essentially voting for FF)

johnlarson66 said:
Very early on FF mentioned it was spring break and he was going to do mass posting. Lab replied and then FF posted this -



Now he is trying to re-write his own history.



I also stated that I thought the FF's vote on Lab was not OMGUS, because Lab had not voted for FF yet and there were two others that had voted FF. Of course while I was posting that, FF said his vote on Lab was OMGUSy and retracted. Then he claims his vote was not OMGUSy based on statements I had made.

While I am unsure if FF is mafia or just inept, I am concerned about his revisionist look at his own statements.

I also think it was clearly defined in the game not to role claim, while I am unsure if non-communicating innocent is a "role", I think it serves no purpose.

I am unwilling to be one of the last two votes on FF, but I am willing to take my vote off of Lab.

I retract my vote on Lab_Rat and vote to lynch Dagamoth.

Dagamoth's vote is mostly for how FF played last game. Not a random vote, but a revenge vote. I expect more from them.

My other suspects are noods (confused card) and JB (keeping mafia alive is good for the town).
Click to expand...
 
Madcrawdad said:
Oh, I see...

So which actions? When you said this?



Sure looks like you're leaving all options open. Huh?

The fact you even have the guts to say the following on D2 is pretty humorous...


Never happened, Ice.
Click to expand...

Still pulling the same post from the middle of Day 1.

I'm fine with you suspecting me, its really not a big deal. You might try finding something else though as this one doesn't look like its working for you.


What are your thoughts on Noods?
 
well, i would rather see a coin toss.... I retract my lone vote on JL and vote to lynch JB
 
noodles62 said:
well, i would rather see a coin toss.... I retract my lone vote on JL and vote to lynch JB
Click to expand...

hit post too soon - I am equally cautious of both Labby and JB so I feel good about a toss up...........
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom