[AC] maelstrom;2338866 said:
That this day was wasted trying to find sense in what i say, and i will now try to talk less think more (will prob fail).
Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread
- Thread starter Zaffy
- Start date
That this day was wasted trying to find sense in what i say, and i will now try to talk less think more (will prob fail).
Why do you continue to beat yourself up like this? It's pathetic, and certainly isn't going to get any votes retracted for sympathy. The majority of your recent posts have had some sort of self-insulting comment in them, and frankly, I (and I am willing to bet I can speak for the rest of the townspeople) don't care.
g/o
Thank you, we are pretty excited about it and can't wait for it to cycle so we can add critters. g/o
I vote to lynch FF. He has been over the top this game. I do think he is scummy, and we need to find out.
Ok, this is interesting, yesterday Ice made his statement about vet vs newb.
No one called him on it other than to say that it might be true but, we weren't willing to risk it.
Today, we have three jumping on him for it. LR, Kashta, and bio.
Let me ask the three of you this, do you really think scum would volunteer to be lynched?
Think about it, it is day one and we never have much to go on in day one.
We historically end up lynching townies for that reason.
These three votes have caused me to think maybe we have a female scum team this time around.
The scum have an advantage as they know already who is innocent. Now suppose, (and I don't intend for this to be a defense of anyone I am just trying to put it out there for thought because I don't know either.) that FF is innocent as he claims.
The scum are willing to let him be lynched as it is another innocent gone. Ice makes his statement, and after a day of discussion in the scum den they decide that they can use that statement to lynch a more formidable foe than what is already on the chopping block and not look scummy doing it.
I may have made a target of myself with this theory but so be it. I want to get it out there and give them a chance to respond. Meanwhile I will think on it and if I see reason to I will move my vote.
No one called him on it other than to say that it might be true but, we weren't willing to risk it.
Today, we have three jumping on him for it. LR, Kashta, and bio.
Let me ask the three of you this, do you really think scum would volunteer to be lynched?
Think about it, it is day one and we never have much to go on in day one.
We historically end up lynching townies for that reason.
These three votes have caused me to think maybe we have a female scum team this time around.
The scum have an advantage as they know already who is innocent. Now suppose, (and I don't intend for this to be a defense of anyone I am just trying to put it out there for thought because I don't know either.) that FF is innocent as he claims.
The scum are willing to let him be lynched as it is another innocent gone. Ice makes his statement, and after a day of discussion in the scum den they decide that they can use that statement to lynch a more formidable foe than what is already on the chopping block and not look scummy doing it.
I may have made a target of myself with this theory but so be it. I want to get it out there and give them a chance to respond. Meanwhile I will think on it and if I see reason to I will move my vote.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
OMG, Mad you are to good to your wife. You make a woman jealous!
ok, as I am catching up with the days events, I see what Ice says and I see FF trying to worm his way to saying the same thing because there are folks believing it... of which I still don't really get because the way I see it, if you are a townie, why would you possibly want to be lynched when the evil team doesn't need to kill all townies, only as much to put one over the level of the game... meaning, if there are 4 or 5 or whatever scums, they just need to kill us off or have us lynched until there is 1 less than them and we aren't even sure of the number of them further than speculation. However, does that make me think that Ice is scum, well, I don't know... because why would scum do such a thing on day 1?? That's my thought on that...
the reason I quoted the above post is because outside of what FF is trying to say (which I still am not all 100% sure about), I find something odd in this post. The first part, you spell psychic as "phycik". Next, you spell it as . Not only is it correct, but it is bold... why? So then I read on and I see that you can't spell "psychic" correctly when typing off the cuff, nir can you go back and correct it when you see that it's wrong... but you can use a word like "expendable", and spell and use it correctly? Did you have a spelling test today?
you are now thinking that these two may be mafia but only if others think they are? I am not getting what you are getting at or trying to accomplish here, FF... no one is here to hold your hand during the game... remember, the point is trying come up with things that might be proof of the scums... not to train you on the game.. so what makes you think LR and Mael are scummy?
A bit of a reach there, Wizard... IMO. But I'll respond.
I was fairly busy with the thread yesterday and haven't been through this as much today... I do what I can with the time I get for this. I did read through what was going on and had been thinking about Ice's suggestion since last night.
I looked over the thread again, wrote up my post (voting Ice), and as I normally do, I refreshed the page to see what else had posted before submitting my post. That's when I saw Lab's post where she also voted Ice for pretty much the same reason I was going to. I added an introductory sentence to my previewed post then.... in agreement with Lab Rat's conclusion.... and posted it. I didn't feel it was necessary to change anything just because it seems Lab and I view Ice's position the same way. I saw later that Bio came along and followed to place a 3rd vote against Ice.
Your theory that the 3 of us are in cahoots because the votes happened to come along at the same time is incorrect. Given the timing, however, and placement of our posts, I say it's still a fair question. I'd like to hear responses as well from both Lab Rat and Bio.
I'll also ask you (Wizard) to consider this: If the three of us were communicating scummates plotting away... (1) do you really think it'd take either Lab Rat or myself a whole evening and most of today for us to deliberate about Ice before voting him?, (2) if we were planning this as scummates, why on earth would we foolishly post the same thing at the same time?, and (3) are you overlooking the point that other seemingly rational (?) players have voiced similar suspicions about Ice for what he posted?
As I stated, I can see why the timing might raise this question... but think it's a bit much to accuse 3 different players of being mafia teammates over that alone. If you have other reasons for suspicion, please point them out.
That said, I wonder a bit about Biohazard jumping in with her vote the way she did and when she did because it possibly sounded to her like a safe place to be at that point in the thread. I'm a little suspicious about Bio already because prior to her vote, she'd made 4 totally useless posts plus only 1 more where she actually made a point.
A good point to make when this was posted, but her participation is still too low for us to tell much about Bio in this game.
Lab (so far) seems to be trying to help the town as far as I can tell (so far). In her case, I take that with a grain of salt.
