Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[Fishfriend1]

I dont want to lose ice either, in fact if it came down to a tie between me and someone that was believed innocent i would try to get myself lynched to save that person.

 

[the wizard]

Is it too late for a "game on" woo hoo?

Sorry I haven't been here yet but I spent all night setting up a 12 gal. nano reef. (my first sw attempt) I am excited about that.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

My intention with the whole distraction thing was that you kept at it with only me... and I was not sure what you were doing but a scum ploy could in fact be trying to distract me from the game.

alternatively i "kept at it with you" because you kept responding...usually how a conversation works

well, right now my top scumbag is LR, mostly for twisting words of others. Of course by top scumbag i mean that she is most liklely scum to me, but still not high on the list, lots can change b4 the night ends and others may come that seem scummier.

quotes??? I havent seen anyone else come up with this idea so if youre going to present something as damning as twisting words then you better have proof.

 

[the wizard]

OK now to the game, I didn't have a lot of time for read but skimmed through to try to catch up to speed and will read more thouroughly after work today.

I appears as though Mael was having fun with DD.

JL started playing instead of joking, unusual for him. I kind of thought He was our resident court jesture.

FF is being FF.


Ice makes a good point about the benifit of a vet over a newbie for invest purposes but don't think that it is worth intentionally lynching one for that reason though.

capt cavie, first time I have played with you. You were asked a question twice before answering.

You thought it scummy the way JL agitated FF, but voted FF.

Now I do realize FF does look scummy with his posts, but he always does regardless of alignment.

Like he said, he can't shut up.

It would be wise FF for you to hit the preview post button and reread it a couple of times before submitting the post.

I need to vote because my schedule is wierd, sometimes can make nightfall and sometimes can't.

I vote to lynch Captaincaveman.

Until I read more thouroughly, it just seems odd you would consider JL scummy for stirring up FF and then vote FF.

I am not too worried about FF looking scummy yet as he always does and makes himself pretty lynchable anyway.

Will be back later and read more carefully. My next post will be
1)shorter and 2) hopefully more helpful.

 

[Zaffy]

umm..What are the numbers next to the names?

The ones on the right are the post number where the vote happened, the one on the left is the total against that player.

Vote count thus far.
(4) FF - JL(19) JRR(87) CCM(145) Annie(155)
(2) CCM - Madcrawdad(109) the Wiz(164)
(1) Maelsrom - DD(140)

No votes from: Lab_rat, Ice, Noodles, kash, rich, FF, Lady G, Bio, ILM, Dawg, Maelstrom.

 

[Lady G]

Nothing really to new to post about, just been thinking...(I know dangerous). Anyhow, IMO the ones gunning most for FF need watched most at this point. From what I can tell (haven't ever played with FF before) it is norm for him to be all over the place not really seeing that as "scum" tell at this point. I think John is being John and having fun with FF. Ice...I see the point about a vet, but what bothers me is the way ppl seem to be just accepting him as innocent or something and the way he appears to be presenting himself that way as if we should just believe him to be and go with the flow. Not saying I think he is scum, at this point I have no opinion of him either way. CCM, well as pointed out several times now the way he talked about John then voted FF.

G/O
Congrats, they are fun to have...ya gotta get yourself a red flash light and magnifying glass, at night turn the lights off and check out the rock...so cool the things you will see!!!G/O

Is it too late for a "game on" woo hoo?

Sorry I haven't been here yet but I spent all night setting up a 12 gal. nano reef. (my first sw attempt) I am excited about that.

 

[johnlarson66]

My vote on FF was a joke vote, but his response was no joke.

Of course the town wants to lynch scum over an innocent. Now it has been brought up about which is better, lynching an innocent vet of an innocent noob. My biggest concern would be if the player would still be playing. Could we trust if the person that is now dead would still follow along and particapate. To me it is not vet vs noob at all.

So if an innocent were to get lynched I would hope it would be one that stayed into the game. I think FF and Ice both would keep up with the game.

Ice, do you think FF would screw up the investigations? How? Is there a "wrong" investigation?

 

[johnlarson66]

Nothing really to new to post about, just been thinking...(I know dangerous). Anyhow, IMO the ones gunning most for FF need watched most at this point. From what I can tell (haven't ever played with FF before) it is norm for him to be all over the place not really seeing that as "scum" tell at this point. I think John is being John and having fun with FF. Ice...I see the point about a vet, but what bothers me is the way ppl seem to be just accepting him as innocent or something and the way he appears to be presenting himself that way as if we should just believe him to be and go with the flow. Not saying I think he is scum, at this point I have no opinion of him either way. CCM, well as pointed out several times now the way he talked about John then voted FF.

G/O
Congrats, they are fun to have...ya gotta get yourself a red flash light and magnifying glass, at night turn the lights off and check out the rock...so cool the things you will see!!!G/O

IMO, those that have been posting and are saying certain players "need watched", but themselves have not voted or really have stated anything concrete are very high on my suspect list.

If you have a suspect, then vote for them or atleast tell us who your suspects are.

Going to break out the "T" word now that FF has 4 votes?

 

[Fishfriend1]

You're saying you want to be lynched?

Some twisting, or translating badly.

So let me see if I'm getting what you're saying...it's better to accidentally lynch an innocent vet than an innocent FF/noob because that way the vet can make better decisions about who to investigate, right?

I can kinda see that but it seems more important to me to keep vets in the game where they can make much more of a difference in hunting scum than they would by picking investigations from the other side.

Ice never said that, he said that he would prefer to loss someone who could make a good decisions(not me). Of course i could be wrong.

Worked well for him as scum or as townie? Last game, before it was called, I thought it was odd he was stuck on the great colon debate. Turns out, he was scum. This game I'm thinking it's quite odd that he said he'd rather an innocent vet get lynched than an innocent FF/noob. It makes me want to vote for him...

Ok, same as b4.

That's true, that did work out well. What do you think of his theory that better a vet be lynched than FF/a noob in this format?

Still about the vet v/s noob thing.

Lol, I want to lynch scum too.

Does Ice saying it may be better to vote for an innocent vet vs. innocent FF/noob seem scummy? This question is for everyone as it strikes me as a bit of a scummy thing to say.

More about vet/noob.

Then vote me, its who I said to vote for over FF anyway. I fail to see how its scummy to be asked to be lynched though, maybe you're the vet we should have do our investigations?

This makes me think Ice is more townie then scumy. Scum would try to keep themselves from being voted over being ready to sacrifice themself.

 

[J double R]

This makes me think Ice is more townie then scumy. Scum would try to keep themselves from being voted over being ready to sacrifice themself.

and try to talk people out of voting for you is PRECISELY what you did first.