Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[[AC] maelstrom]

I Love Mollies...care to add anything else??? you have not posted anything relevant to the game or whats been going on.

Game 2 for the newbie(Me if you didnt guess)WOO!! Although wont be posting often this week my dog had a seizure and the vet has yet to find why.

Well at least im not a noob anymore

Sorry to hear about your dog. And sorry if this may sound heartless, but how will your dog's condition negatively affect your posting? What is it about your dog's condition, that will be taking up your time?


Well i have to keep checking in on my dog plus i have some tests at school and i have to go and refill my dogs medicene weekly because i have to give it to him in large doses because he is a big dog even for his breed (Yellow Labrador, his name is Schroeder) and he weaighs about 110lbs. that is how it affects my posting the tests are just a bonus.Plus he has tremors and i have to wake up to comfort him Every Night.

 

[IceH2O]

Post 36 to be exact.

Also all innocents that are lynched will be good spirits.

Odd that FF posted this and that Ice agreed. I also think that it is odd that Ice does not think FF could handle investigated people if he was a good spirit.

For Ice's sake, he better hope that FF does not come up evil.

Why is that JL? I might get lynched? I'm already saying I'd rather be lynched over FF. My only regret would be that I was protecting an evil player in the process.

 

[IceH2O]

So which is it JL?

My vote is on FF.

Doesn't answer the question... If you don't think its a good plan to lynch me and let me do invests then why is it that you would like to see me lynched to see what my affiliation is? Isn't that the same as following the "plan"?

 

[IceH2O]

I was not sure what he thought before he role-played, however, the role playing could be to back you up, I don't know.

You forgot about Lady G and ILM. Neither has added any substance to the game. However, I doubt all 3 are mafia and using the same tactic...

I find it interesting though that Annie has posted just after your thought.

I have no idea how this even equates to answering the post you quoted, mind clearing it up for me?

 

[Lady G]

IMO, those that have been posting and are saying certain players "need watched", but themselves have not voted or really have stated anything concrete are very high on my suspect list.

If you have a suspect, then vote for them or atleast tell us who your suspects are.

Going to break out the "T" word now that FF has 4 votes?

Why would I vote if at the time no one was standing out to me John? I like being on your "list" so that is fine with me, means I must be on your minderv:.
Anyhow, after reading through everything Bio is my highest suspect right now. The whole voting knowing they would have time to come back, but then saying voting incase they may not be able to, while bringing up the last minute vote last game (which I believe they were evil that game) just isn't going over well with me so I vote to lynch Bio.

yep, that's why ive never been PR. The mods prob switched me out for a better candidate. I was just saying that no one ever bothers to think i could be a PR player.

I dont even remember where i was going with this so ima leave it now.

Why would someone mention thinking you were a PR? If one felt that way the last thing they would want to do is post that thought especially on D1.

Ok, this is interesting, yesterday Ice made his statement about vet vs newb.

No one called him on it other than to say that it might be true but, we weren't willing to risk it.

Today, we have three jumping on him for it. LR, Kashta, and bio.

Let me ask the three of you this, do you really think scum would volunteer to be lynched?

Think about it, it is day one and we never have much to go on in day one.

We historically end up lynching townies for that reason.

These three votes have caused me to think maybe we have a female scum team this time around.

The scum have an advantage as they know already who is innocent. Now suppose, (and I don't intend for this to be a defense of anyone I am just trying to put it out there for thought because I don't know either.) that FF is innocent as he claims.

The scum are willing to let him be lynched as it is another innocent gone. Ice makes his statement, and after a day of discussion in the scum den they decide that they can use that statement to lynch a more formidable foe than what is already on the chopping block and not look scummy doing it.

I may have made a target of myself with this theory but so be it. I want to get it out there and give them a chance to respond. Meanwhile I will think on it and if I see reason to I will move my vote.

I pretty much agree with this post.
The talk about voting a "innocent" noob/vet is pretty worrisome to me, I don't like the way it is looking. To me it seems most are willing to decide their vote on one innocent or the other instead of trying to figure out who may be scum. I just do not like it.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I pretty much agree with this post.
The talk about voting a "innocent" noob/vet is pretty worrisome to me, I don't like the way it is looking. To me it seems most are willing to decide their vote on one innocent or the other instead of trying to figure out who may be scum. I just do not like it.

I'm voting for Ice because from what I can tell, he's the scummiest so far. If someone comes up scummier looking I'll change my vote. The mind games he's playing do not have a pro-town feel to me.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

Why would I vote if at the time no one was standing out to me John? I like being on your "list" so that is fine with me, means I must be on your minderv:.
Anyhow, after reading through everything Bio is my highest suspect right now. The whole voting knowing they would have time to come back, but then saying voting incase they may not be able to, while bringing up the last minute vote last game (which I believe they were evil that game) just isn't going over well with me so I vote to lynch Bio.


Why would someone mention thinking you were a PR? If one felt that way the last thing they would want to do is post that thought especially on D1.

I pretty much agree with this post.
The talk about voting a "innocent" noob/vet is pretty worrisome to me, I don't like the way it is looking. To me it seems most are willing to decide their vote on one innocent or the other instead of trying to figure out who may be scum. I just do not like it.

I dont see anyone saying that their vote is going to an innocent...if there are ppl its hardly "most"

 

[Lady G]

I was not sure what he thought before he role-played, however, the role playing could be to back you up, I don't know.

You forgot about Lady G and ILM. Neither has added any substance to the game. However, I doubt all 3 are mafia and using the same tactic...

I find it interesting though that Annie has posted just after your thought.

Nope, I haven't been in the game much this round so far. It started after I went to work. I checked before I left..PM was sent but game hadn't started. I posted once I was able to get on before work this morning.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I have no idea how this even equates to answering the post you quoted, mind clearing it up for me?

the question you asked is in the post below

I really have no reason to believe he is except that he always posts this way. Look thru the thread and prove me wrong on my next thought. A lot of players just want to vote him off because he is a distraction,not because he is scummy but could be. FF is an easy target and with any player like that I like to watch the reaction of others against him. JL I'm not sure of, he always votes the 1st role player. But from that point on everyone grabbed and ran with a twisting of a statement of him saying we'll both be sorry if I'm lynched. How exactly does that equate to him insinuating him and JL are on a team and if that is the thought we votes on JL? Isn't he more a threat as scum then FF? If you're sure this statement was scummy the votes should be on his so called team mate and not FF. If you're not sure that FF is evil then you shouldn't be voting him IMO.




You don't think FF knows that Lab is better at this then he is?

when I was reading this, I was thinking to myself, I was not sure what he thought, meaning whether he thought Lab was a better player than. Then I read his role play post where he explains that he does in fact believe Lab to be a better player than him. Well, he doesn't say so much in the post, but instead goes on how he thinks you and Lab are good players, will post like you two have and hopes to learn from it.... well, that is if HE is Mr. Palmer.

This is the 2nd time you've mentioned me and FF on an evil team together. I've never been on FFs team,unless I blocked it from my memory.

I could have sworn it was mentioned (by someone else before) that you and him were on a team and you instructed him to keep quiet, no more posting... and that is what he did. This is not something from this game I remember byut one of the last couple of games. If I am wrong, by all means, correct me.

 

[BioHazard]

Why would I vote if at the time no one was standing out to me John? I like being on your "list" so that is fine with me, means I must be on your minderv:.
Anyhow, after reading through everything Bio is my highest suspect right now. The whole voting knowing they would have time to come back, but then saying voting incase they may not be able to, while bringing up the last minute vote last game (which I believe they were evil that game) just isn't going over well with me so I vote to lynch Bio.


Why would someone mention thinking you were a PR? If one felt that way the last thing they would want to do is post that thought especially on D1.

I pretty much agree with this post.
The talk about voting a "innocent" noob/vet is pretty worrisome to me, I don't like the way it is looking. To me it seems most are willing to decide their vote on one innocent or the other instead of trying to figure out who may be scum. I just do not like it.

I think you are reeeeeeealy pulling at strings to find anything I've said scummy. How is it scummy to learn from a past mistake (that is, waiting too long to vote), and make an early vote based on what I know at the time, knowing that I would be able to change it later? I never know how busy or unbusy I will be, so I am planning ahead.