Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[Fishfriend1]

why did my post look so good? because it took about an hour to type, revise, and type again ( i accidentally lost the original and needed to re-type the whole **** thing, and go back to find all the stuff there).

 

[the wizard]

why did my post look so good? because it took about an hour to type, revise, and type again ( i accidentally lost the original and needed to re-type the whole **** thing, and go back to find all the stuff there).

There is your epiphany. Do this on every post and you won't post as much but your play will improve greatly. :thm:

 

[IceH2O]

Well maybe you should try that more often.

Quick question for Bio.

I see you moved your vote off me onto ILM. What has ILM done to look more scummy then me to you? What was your reason for voting me again? Do you now think I'm innocent and that id why you moved?

 

[the wizard]

A lot has happened today and I am getting ready to go back through the days events to put a post together, does anybody have an accurate vote count?

 

[BioHazard]

Well maybe you should try that more often.

Quick question for Bio.

I see you moved your vote off me onto ILM. What has ILM done to look more scummy then me to you? What was your reason for voting me again? Do you now think I'm innocent and that id why you moved?

I voted on you based on this...

Then vote me, its who I said to vote for over FF anyway. I fail to see how its scummy to be asked to be lynched though, maybe you're the vet we should have do our investigations?

I felt that, at the time (that is, many many posts ago), you were the scummiest looking person. What do I think of you now? I'm not sure, but I am leaning towards non-scum. I still don't know if you were playing at some reverse psychology to claim innocence, or just stating an opinion.

As for ILM, they are not posting, and the posts they have made have been useless. As mentioned earlier, not all my posts have been relevant either, but most of them have. ILM decided to vote off FF, and still has not explained their reasoning (unless I missed it). And that seems to be the only thing he has done so far.
If he is scum, he is probably being coached to stay quiet.
If he is innocent, he is hardly contributing, and will not be missed.

 

[Madcrawdad]

I really have no reason to believe he is except that he always posts this way. Look thru the thread and prove me wrong on my next thought. A lot of players just want to vote him off because he is a distraction,not because he is scummy but could be. FF is an easy target and with any player like that I like to watch the reaction of others against him. JL I'm not sure of, he always votes the 1st role player. But from that point on everyone grabbed and ran with a twisting of a statement of him saying we'll both be sorry if I'm lynched. How exactly does that equate to him insinuating him and JL are on a team and if that is the thought we votes on JL? Isn't he more a threat as scum then FF? If you're sure this statement was scummy the votes should be on his so called team mate and not FF. If you're not sure that FF is evil then you shouldn't be voting him IMO.

I agree that he always posts this way, which unfortunately turns most scum-tells into null-tells for him. That doesn't make him innocent, though. Big difference between not finding someone scummy, and actually calling them innocent. We're not just arguing semantics here.

Additionally, I don't think that any of FF's statements were 'twisted'. Unfortunately, scum flows from his mouth like a river (regardless of alignment), and it just can't be ignored because it's FF posting. Probably better to pressure him early in the game, as opposed to an endgame situation where, best case scenario, he's a major distraction as town, and worst case, he's actually scum.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

As for scum wanting to keep you around, that might be true but I'd actually wouldn't mind keeping you around even if you were scum because you're more likely to slip and give away team mates when pressured.

Correct me if I am wrong but i thought ff meant that as an innocent the mafia would want him around because he causes confusion and draws attention...i cant imagine the mafia would like that very much if he were on there team unless they somehow could keep him under control.

some ppl mentioned earlier about ff being an "easy" lynch and while that may be true because of what he has said im not so sure the mafia would want to railroad him unless they are already wanting to cut him loose from their ties. Judging by his eratic playstyle I woudlnt doubt that but it seems a little early for that too...but hes a good cover for them IMO if he is innocent.

keep in mind this is my 1st time playing with him so Im not really mindful of FF's mafia history. I did skim one of the more recent ones (67 maybe?) where he seemed to be a hot topic of convo d1 then too.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I have a theory on JL/FF/Bio connection. Never would have put it together if he hadn't made the post above.

Has anyone noticed that FF never voted JL for voting him? Is FF better at the game that he doesn't name voters for him as suspects anymore? When he implied it would be bad if JL votes him off was he actually slipping? Then he refuses to vote Bio saying he doesn't see anything scummy but all of a sudden I am. JL won't move off FF as its a distancing vote and who cares if they lose FF from the team. If FF or Bio shows evil JL will be my next vote.

I'm not trying to push anyone to FF, he does that well enough on his own. Its just something that popped into my head and I wanted out there.

I still have no problem with being the 1st innocent voted out.

I refuse to vote Bio just because you came up with a theory. It would be good if i was scum, but im not so i cant believe in it. I dont really think Bio is Evil, just a little higher up on the Scum Scale then others, but still less then you. For someone who doesn't care about dying you really seem to want to live. Was that whole "Ill die for the town" bit just trying to seem innocent? And you seem to think that the scum would never go on first, which is exactly what scum would want us to believe if they had decided to start some stuff, or be first ones on.

 

[Fishfriend1]

As for ILM, they are not posting, and the posts they have made have been useless. As mentioned earlier, not all my posts have been relevant either, but most of them have. ILM decided to vote off FF, and still has not explained their reasoning (unless I missed it). And that seems to be the only thing he has done so far.
If he is scum, he is probably being coached to stay quiet.
If he is innocent, he is hardly contributing, and will not be missed.

If i recall that has been the excuse for voting me several time.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

somethings been bugging me...

Some twisting, or translating badly.



Ice never said that, he said that he would prefer to loss someone who could make a good decisions(not me). Of course i could be wrong.



Ok, same as b4.



Still about the vet v/s noob thing.



More about vet/noob.



This makes me think Ice is more townie then scumy. Scum would try to keep themselves from being voted over being ready to sacrifice themself.

ff states that he thinks ice is more innocent because of the noob vs. vet sacrifice thing.

Oh daer, im not gonna make it as a spirite!




It needs a "To Lynch" between vote and FF.


All this talk of mind games and wording is giving me a headache. I think ill vote later, and i am starting to see a team in here.

Ice, Wiz, and DD.
OR
LR, Mael, and other.

They seem to be "understanding" and "connecting" more so then the rest.

now Ice is on one of his lists because he is "understanding" and "connecting" better than others...not sure what that means either.

not anymore, look down.




I vote to lynch Ice. I will let the coin flip, he seems more evil to me then any other player.

suddenly ice is the scummiest to him.

Here is why i voted ice ( i make no promises about looking scummy or not, this is just my semi-refined thought proses on the pot) :

Ice is scum because... um... Well, he seemed to protect me without any prior knowledge of my position, and scum would want me in the game in order to sow accidental confusion over everything. 2, he seemed to think that it was better to lose a vet then a newb, mostly because the newb wouldnt be as good at invests as a vet. he has been posting more and more often. In the beginning of the game it was like one post of his for every 40 other posts, now its like 1 post for him in every 5-10 other posts. He claimed that when he is wrong he can be even more of a distraction them me, which means he must be lying scum. On a more seriuse not, if he is a major distraction when he is off, then how dig a distraction is he when he is scum? He pulled quotes and never used them. he used that strange saying "took FF with a grain of salt" WTH does that even mean? He brings up some facts and then posts his ideas, that makes us more likely to believe him (i dont know, it seems a little like that). he said my role playing posts have nothing to do with the game, they most definitely do, and tend to voice my opinions and thought better then normal posts, so read them ice. Also read post 398, i put up some reasons there.

PLZ don't make me quote anything, i dont think ill live long enough to do so...

Ice if i get lynched you will be the first person i look into.

READ MY REASONS, DON'T SKIM!

interesting aside: Mad stated in post 380 that he was glade to see that i was looking at him. Why?

now FF is using virtually the same reason why he thought ice was innocent as why he thinks hes scum. the rest of them dont even make sense as scum tells so Im going to ignore those.

ff, what made you change from thinking Ice was a townie willing to sacrifice himself to thinking that ice was scum "protecting" you?