Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[Madcrawdad]

As for ILM, they are not posting, and the posts they have made have been useless. As mentioned earlier, not all my posts have been relevant either, but most of them have. ILM decided to vote off FF, and still has not explained their reasoning (unless I missed it). And that seems to be the only thing he has done so far.
If he is scum, he is probably being coached to stay quiet.
If he is innocent, he is hardly contributing, and will not be missed.

Odd thing is that ILM has 6-7 posts on the site this afternoon, but nothing here.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I looked at it from a different angle. I saw so many people commenting on that in a negative manner that i looked at how scum could use it, and suddently he was scummy because of it. I will post my notes in about an hour, they are not nessesarily meant to be scummy, but some of it may seem scummy. It is pretty big.

 

[the wizard]

I totally read it differently and was confused. That is why I thought it was a typo. To me it was sounding like he was saying he totally agreed that FF should send in investigations. His post B clarified it, maybe I have the understanding of a 4 year old. I will give him the benefit of the doubt and will assume I just read what he was saying wrong. Also, I need more sleep, makes reading easier when you get some...


What he said was odd imo. It's got me playing a huge game of WIFOM with what he said. Why do you not think it's a mind game he's playing? I don't see why more people aren't bothered by this or are willing to brush it off, so I keep bringing that up. I don't trust Ice one bit and cannot figure out his motivations if he's truly innocent.


I am sooooo glad you're able to know what Ice meant. Maybe you're the clairvoyant one. When I read them they said opposite things. The problem with the internet is that you don't hear enunciation, try reading that sentence with pauses in a different spot and you'll see what I was reading.


I'm so glad everyone is so much better at reading than I am. And I tried to move on but you all seem stuck on berating my reading skills. Hukked on fonicks werked fer me!

Also, you must not have played many games with me if you're surprised that when I see something odd I'll keep going at it for a while...


I call it like I see it. At least a couple other people in this town aren't ignoring Ice's odd request.

I haven't said he isn't playing a mind game, only that it didn't look that way to me.

You on the other hand seemed to be determined that it was the only answer.

Less wifom and a little more wisom might do the trick. :thumbsup:

 

[IceH2O]

I refuse to vote Bio just because you came up with a theory. It would be good if i was scum, but im not so i cant believe in it. I dont really think Bio is Evil, just a little higher up on the Scum Scale then others, but still less then you. For someone who doesn't care about dying you really seem to want to live. Was that whole "Ill die for the town" bit just trying to seem innocent? And you seem to think that the scum would never go on first, which is exactly what scum would want us to believe if they had decided to start some stuff, or be first ones on.

I never asked you to vote Bio, the question was asked earlier of you why you wouldn't so my theory has nothing to do with it.

Where have I asked to be saved? I'm not even moving my vote to Bio to help keep me alive. I'm just posting things I've noticed, why does that bother you?
While we're at it... What are your thoughts on JL?

 

[Fishfriend1]

I looked at it from a different angle. I saw so many people commenting on that in a negative manner that i looked at how scum could use it, and suddently he was scummy because of it. I will post my notes in about an hour, they are not nessesarily meant to be scummy, but some of it may seem scummy. It is pretty big.

This is too mael.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I never asked you to vote Bio, the question was asked earlier of you why you wouldn't so my theory has nothing to do with it.

Where have I asked to be saved? I'm not even moving my vote to Bio to help keep me alive. I'm just posting things I've noticed, why does that bother you?
While we're at it... What are your thoughts on JL?

Ugg, back to JL. I have him neutral, maybe a little on the scummy side, but i hold everyone a little on the scummy side until proven otherwise.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

This is too mael.

so you admit you just went with the flow then...huh

 

[the wizard]

these "you'll be sorry" posts always are worrisome...

I would like to retract my vote for Ice, and vote to lynch ILM. If you don't have time to play these games, don't sign up. Even the other low posters have at lease posted SOMETHING constructive.
I am sorry about your dog, but so far, in the two games you've played, you've always had an excuse to not post.

I am sorry but maybe I am just dense because I don't have a dictionary handy, explain to me how lolcats is beneficial to the town or the game for that matter.

 

[captaincaveman9]

OK I have a few quick thoughts (may have been logged on ac earlier, but I've been running around all day).

As I said early on, I still think JL is pretty scummy, and FF is not looking as scummy. To me rereading his early posts with FF it still looks to me like he is just working FF up to make him ramble and look bad. I'll admit it worked. I don't think FF is an innocent, but that is more a a general feeling from his posting than from any real quotes I can get from his posts.

I'm not sure what to think of ILM not posting. I get the impression he is going to vote at the last second to lynch someone. If that's what he does, that'll look very scummy to me. Like he would be told who to vote for (just a thought on the way things look so far, and my theory as to why he's not saying much).

I'm not sure what to make of ice yet, but i get a pretty strong desire to get soap when he posts. He seems to like to point fingers, and that can't be a good thing right?

These are just a few of my thoughts for now...

if I don't get a chance to do this later:

I recant my vote for FF and change it to JL

 

[the wizard]

I for one just misunderstood what he was saying and was confused which is why I asked. I understand what he meant to say now and I have no issue with it.



Even though I disagree with Lab's take on Ice being scum because he doesn't mind being lynched, I do agree that his post was confusing until he clarified it. I don't think Lab was trying to twist anything. I think she was reading it the same way I was. This post of yours seems scummy to me Annie. Mostly because I don't see how Lab twisted anything. I was the one who pointed out what I thought was a conflicting statement from Ice. I could be off but for now it is the best thing I have so far...

...I vote to lynch Annie

Yes there are others that have stated things about thinking Lab is twisting Ice's words but you decided to vote her for it...which seems opportunistic to me.

Dawg, While I can agree with you voting for someone you think to be scummy, I did the same, with night approaching are you comfortable with leaving yours as a lone vote?

Actually I would ask this of all the players with a lone vote out there. Are any of you willing, with night approaching and three players with multiple votes, to make it a race?

Or do you all feel more comfortable with your "safe" votes?