Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

IceH2O said:
JL why would you switch from an innocent to a team mate when you had an even chance the innocent was going to die? I could see you switching to Lab if she was innocent because she is much more of a thorn in your side then FF would be but you didn't which makes me think even more she and you are in fact team mates.
Click to expand...

Because lynching a mafia and being the vote that did it makes one almost 100% innoncent. We used to talk about it in earlier games, but I have done it and it has worked out, it has also failed.

I am sure if I was the kill vote on a mafia player and then we find that the person I "saved" was innocent, you would have me innocent more often than not.

The mafia want players like FF around. They are a total distraction.
 
Lady G said:
I'm thinking the evil team forgot to send their PM in, and she knew it so was confused as to how it happened.

Ya know what Lab really slipped IMO...soooooo, I vote to lynch Lab.

Bio, you are very defencive and the fact you had NOTHING to say except a "how did that happen" about Kash makes you look even more scummy to me.

John, I just don't know...you have acted very scummy also IMO, but I'm still back and forth with you.

JRR, there were so many things that happened and your post was just a vote, no reason, no comments, just a vote....not looking good in my book either.

Mollies, where the heck are ya...you lack of posts and contents are very concerning also.
Click to expand...

LG, how have I acted very scummy?
 
Revised suspect list:

Lab- very defensive and i could easily see what she said being a slip. the OMGUSy attitude doesnt help either.

ice- if it isnt labrat I bet he is scum. however I have no problem leaning him to the innocent side if Lab is scum since I still think they are on opposite sides.

Jrr- was way too focused on ff yesterday and then threw an early hunch vote on LG without any further explanation.

ILM- way too quiet and has yet to contribute to the game while still posting elsewhere on the site.

bio- I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt because i didnt understand what wiz and LG were getting at but throwing out post counts as a defense is worrisome since as mentioned its not about number but content.

annie- she seems to come and go quickly flying under the radar. she jumped off FF to vote for lab first and votes her again today also stating that she is looking at JL because of wiz who thinks Lab and JL are teammates. makes me wonder if she was trying to distance from lab earlier and is now just trying to go with the flow. I also noticed that 3 of her 4 posts have votes in them. very curious. why so reluctant to just add to the discussion?

Not really in any particular order but I think lab is the best chance at nailing scum.

I vote to lynch Lab

subject to change.
 
Lady G said:
I'm thinking the evil team forgot to send their PM in, and she knew it so was confused as to how it happened.

Ya know what Lab really slipped IMO...soooooo, I vote to lynch Lab.

Bio, you are very defencive and the fact you had NOTHING to say except a "how did that happen" about Kash makes you look even more scummy to me.

John, I just don't know...you have acted very scummy also IMO, but I'm still back and forth with you.

JRR, there were so many things that happened and your post was just a vote, no reason, no comments, just a vote....not looking good in my book either.

Mollies, where the heck are ya...you lack of posts and contents are very concerning also.
Click to expand...

LG, you point out that Lab really slipped as your reason for voting. When Lab made her post yesterday, you commented on it right before nightfall. You said:
Lady G said:
WOW, are you actually saying you know Ice to be innocent?
Click to expand...

Why didn't you change your vote to Lab at that time?
 
IceH2O said:
Sorry, wrong game its evil not mafia





Impressed now?
Click to expand...

ppppfffffttttmmuuwaaahahahahhaha! I am sorry but that is priceless! :rofl:

Lab_Rat said:
I'm not getting OMGUSy. My vote is on Ice, I think he is scum. Maybe you misunderstood what I wrote, the way you have taken it is not what I meant at all. I was simply pointing out that I thought it was scummy for Noods to go from a lynching vote (tie vote) to a non-committal vote right before nightfall. I kinda thought she might jump off of me last minute when I turned out to be the one up for the lynch since she wouldn't want to face the heat when I showed innocent. Maybe her computer overheated and she couldn't.
Click to expand...

nice try but no cigar. If you care to reread nightfall I was on/in the game all the way through. I said goodnight shortly afterwards....Personally I think it would have been scummier for me to leave my vote on a player tied for the lynch that I not longer held suspicious. JMO

IceH2O said:
Really? most of us expected night to fall at 7 PM. Her vote didn't move till almost 7:30 when we all realized night was going to be at 8. She could have moved it when she posted at 6:30 if the plan was to move it all along.
Click to expand...

Bingo! :thumbsup:

Although I love where my vote is (on Labby) I do not like the train that is being formed; even though it is on who I want to see lynched; it makes it too easy for scum to hide. which brings me to this:

Madcrawdad said:
LG, you point out that Lab really slipped as your reason for voting. When Lab made her post yesterday, you commented on it right before nightfall. You said:

Why didn't you change your vote to Lab at that time?
Click to expand...

Excellent point Mad.....I would love to hear the reasoning behind not moving your vote last night LG.

Right now I would have to say my top suspects are Labby, Bio and possibly JRR, for the way he has throwing votes out with no real reasons or justification. hhhhhmmmm, perhaps his vote on LG is just distancing?
I also am curious if ILM plans on playing or not. Some input would really be nice!

Also, in regards to the hit on Kashta, IMO it would have been too obvious for JL to hit Kashta due to how she was grilling him pretty hard. I could definately see Lab putting a hit on Kashta tho.........
 
I Love Mollies said:
Game still going been gone for awhile (1 day)
Click to expand...

picard-facepalm.jpg


Hey, it's not a lolcat!
 
hmmm.... ok... just catching up.... I will say that things don't look good for you labby, I am not really sure what happened with you last night with that post but was willing to give the benefit of the doubt, waiting for your explanation but the explanation you gave isn't really sitting well with me... Jrr, still haven't seen anything worth anything from you except for your vote on LG...

but that brings me to a point on LG...

G, you asked Labby if she really said she knew Ice was innocent as if this was something you considered to be an absolute evil thing, yet you didn't change up your vote for her. I am curious as to why you got so excited about it, yet didn't switch your vote to her.... I dunno, just doesn't seem very "G" to me.

ILM... no you did not just pop in and ask if the game was still on. The point of the game is for you to interact with your own thoughts and theories of who you might perceive to be evil.

one thing I have been thinking about is the whole hit on Kash. Some people are saying that they would consider that JL is evil and possibly the lead evil but then they reconsider that thought because they don't think JL would be so careless... really? What about JL depending on that majority thought and picking Kash because of it... just somethng to be consider. If there's anything I've learned from these games, it's that people are squeaky and you cannot say "so and so wouldn't have done that"...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom