Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

I'm willing to believe you think I'm innocent and I'm willing to believe the post was just a tired ill written post. Not sure yet that I think you're not scum.

I think you're wrong about Noods but I could be wrong about Noods.I haven't really seen anything scummy. I don't see why she would move from 1 innocent to another as you are claiming. At the time if she had stayed on me it would have been a 3 way tie between me FF and Bio. Her moving put it between Bio and FF until your post moved me and Mad to you which put Bio out of the running and you in.
So why would she move out of a 3 way tie to make a 2 way tie?

I'm going to wait to see a more thorough list since this is preliminary at best as you said.

Because she didn't want her vote on anyone up for the day 1 lynch. What's our record for lynching innocent vs. lynching scum on day 1? At the time of her move I was not a lynch contender, thus it was a safe vote. I guess she could have moved onto one of her scum buddies, but she didn't.

I read Lab's post and thought the exact same thing.



Lab how would you think I was innocent or a PR? There only seems to be one way you might know I'm innocent. That just seems like a strange comment to make. I vote to lynch Lab

I agree I haven't been posting as much in this game as I usually would. I'm just not into it this time as much as I usually am and I'm not sure why. I may just need to take a break from this for a bit after this game. I'm not going to give up though and I have nothing to hide. if you have questions, Lab just ask away and I'm more then willing to answer. As far as any other suspects...I'm still seeing Annie as a good candidate. I was ready to come in here and vote Annie. Then I read Lab's post and it just stood out to me that she knows what I am for a reason.

Dawg, I said I think you are scum or a PR...leaning scum way more than PR. That is why I'm not worried. If I know what you are, that means you're confirming your scum. That's what I claimed you were...
 
Because she didn't want her vote on anyone up for the day 1 lynch. What's our record for lynching innocent vs. lynching scum on day 1? At the time of her move I was not a lynch contender, thus it was a safe vote. I guess she could have moved onto one of her scum buddies, but she didn't.



Dawg, I said I think you are scum or a PR...leaning scum way more than PR. That is why I'm not worried. If I know what you are, that means you're confirming your scum. That's what I claimed you were...

Huh??? You said you would have hit me last night?? Nice try though.
 
Dang it Lab. There you go again... What do you mean, that if you were scum you would have hit Dawg? Why? And what makes you think that if you were scum, that Dawg would be innocent? And why if you say that you would hit him are you also listing him as a suspect?

[AC] maelstrom;2341297 said:
good point mad...first thing that popped into my head when lab said that. why would you hit him as scum if you think he is suspicious? wouldnt you have to think he is innocent in order to hit him?

This may be a bit of a stretch but if lab is feeling the heat it wouldnt be too far out there for her to throw a teammates name out there for distancing. conversely she could be trying to take him down with her but makes me wonder why him then? why not someone more in the spotlight like say JL? I dropped dawg off my list when more scummy things popped up but its something to consider.

I read Lab's post and thought the exact same thing.



Lab how would you think I was innocent or a PR? There only seems to be one way you might know I'm innocent. That just seems like a strange comment to make. I vote to lynch Lab

I agree I haven't been posting as much in this game as I usually would. I'm just not into it this time as much as I usually am and I'm not sure why. I may just need to take a break from this for a bit after this game. I'm not going to give up though and I have nothing to hide. if you have questions, Lab just ask away and I'm more then willing to answer. As far as any other suspects...I'm still seeing Annie as a good candidate. I was ready to come in here and vote Annie. Then I read Lab's post and it just stood out to me that she knows what I am for a reason.


I'm going to disagree with this train of thought. I don't think it means as much as you guys think.
If I had asked everyone who they would have hit last night how would you respond?
If I was mafia I would have hit someone like ILM to help FF with investigations. Does that mean I know ILM is innocent and I'm automatically scum? No, just means I'm smarter then the current mafia players.

Still not convinced Lab is innocent but I don't think the statement means as much as its being made out to be.
 
I thought it was quoted enough times that I didn't need to post it again. Well here it is in case you missed it Lab...

Geez people, I do have a life you know. Again, I just got home from work after another 12 hour shift. I do this 5 days a week, some days are slower than others, on those days I can post. We've been super busy this week.

You want the full out explanation about where my mind was yesterday? Here goes...after 3 hours of sleep, I went to work at 4am since my team is capped out with 20 patients. 4 of those are very very sick, think likely to not make it out of the hospital. I have a lot of drug monitoring and recommendations due to changing renal fxn, etc. Sometime around noon my mom texted me that my grandpa had fallen and was in the ED and that they were going to admit him. From the way it sounded, there was a decent chance he wouldn't make it out of the hospital, fortunately today he's doing better. I didn't get home until after 6pm since I have to meet with students every afternoon.

So after a 14 hour day with 3 hours sleep my brain wasn't working well. When I saw Noods vote jump right before nightfall (and I didn't have any problem with the time, idk why everyone else was so confused), I thought maybe she knew something I didn't. And maybe she does. Maybe I'm wrong about Ice, he sure seemed scummy with his theory about a vet needing to be the one to pick the investigations. His idea worked out without Ice getting voted out seeing as Kashta was the scum hit.



Why could you see me putting a hit on Kashta? She seemed to be leaning me innocent, no way I would take out someone who leaned me innocent if I were scum. That would just be stupid.

From what was going on during day 1, if I were scum I likely would have hit Dawg.



Actually Ice, now that I'm not completely brain dead, I'm not liking my vote on you. I'm really thinking Noods is scummy and (omg, I can't believe I'm saying this) you may be innocent. I was kinda thinking distancing but I don't think that's what happened. I think Noods KNEW you were innocent and didn't want to be caught voting for an innocent. It was the impression I got last night but since my synapses were not fully firing I didn't make any moves (and I'm stubborn, I thought you were scummy). Looking back, she knew I'm innocent too, but there was no way she could move her vote off of me without looking incredibly scummy so she just sucked it up and had a vote that counted. She herself said she was around the entire nightfall, did you have a mini-heart attack there Noods, thinking you might get caught voting for an innocent? Good thing the coin flip turned out in your favor...

With that, I retract my vote on Ice and I vote to lynch Noods.

This is a very preliminary list as I haven't had time to thoroughly read, but these are my impressions atm.

Noods- right now is my #1 suspect for reasons above

Dawg- hasn't posted much and he's usually much more active. Makes me wonder why he's laying low and what he has to hide

ILM- Not contributing one bit to the town. His lack of playing doesn't necessarily make him scum, but it sure as hell doesn't help flush out scum

CCM- Some inconsistencies and odd posts. May just be due to being new to the game.


I do have to say the double standards about who is busy irl is amazing. Apparently it's ok if Noods, Rich, Dawg, or Annie claims to be busy, but if Bio or I say we've been busy irl a huge deal is made out of it. I don't get it... :screwy:

Why are you speculating about innocents? How would you know I'm innocent and therefore a good hit for the scum?
 
I left my notes/vote spreadsheet at work, but I am not sure what to make of Annie. His lack of posting seems to have become a norm for him so not sure which way to lean him....

ILM blows my mind! Apparently has no real interest in playing or has been to told to baffle us all by staying quiet....

I am really surprised to not see some real pushes for players since there should be investigation results from last nightfall. not sure what to think about that...

this post make no sense...

consider the facts

1) the chance of picking an innocent are greater than a scum (or for the scum invest a PR)

2) why would a PR especially push for a lynch unless there was a lot of evidence out there for them being scum? at that point it wouldnt be hard for the town to notice it either. they would likely catch flack for pushing w/o any backing.

LG: I believe the mod said at one point that the psychic chose last night and from no
 
Because she didn't want her vote on anyone up for the day 1 lynch. What's our record for lynching innocent vs. lynching scum on day 1? At the time of her move I was not a lynch contender, thus it was a safe vote. ..

That makes absolutely no sense. If I was scum it would have been perfect to hide among the votes on the three way tie regardless if they flipped innocent or not. I was not in the hot seat so there was no need to worry about moving to a "safe vote". It was day one and there were plenty of other players that were on the 3 way tie. Sorry, I am just not seeing your logic here................
 
Because she didn't want her vote on anyone up for the day 1 lynch. What's our record for lynching innocent vs. lynching scum on day 1? At the time of her move I was not a lynch contender, thus it was a safe vote. I guess she could have moved onto one of her scum buddies, but she didn't.



Dawg, I said I think you are scum or a PR...leaning scum way more than PR. That is why I'm not worried. If I know what you are, that means you're confirming your scum. That's what I claimed you were...
See, my problem here is...you say you THINK he is scum OR PR, yes you add you lean him way more scum, but if you think there is a chance he is a PR why, why, why mention it if you are not evil?
 
I'm going to disagree with this train of thought. I don't think it means as much as you guys think.
If I had asked everyone who they would have hit last night how would you respond?
If I was mafia I would have hit someone like ILM to help FF with investigations. Does that mean I know ILM is innocent and I'm automatically scum? No, just means I'm smarter then the current mafia players.

Still not convinced Lab is innocent but I don't think the statement means as much as its being made out to be.

If you asked me who I would have hit last night I would have said Annie because I thought he was scum. If you wanted me to out who I thought was innocent in order to help the scum figure it out...I wouldn't have speculated or answered. It's not pro town IMO.
 
AquariaCentral.com