Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[the wizard]

Sorry to muddle you with facts Wiz.

So what do you think of annie?

Is he a suspect of yours?

You haven't "muddled" me at all JL.

I haven't seen anything or enough of Annie to see anything scummy.

Although as you mentioned, 4 posts at this point in the game is a bit ridiculous, we also know that he will claim RL as the reason.

LR posted in a couple of games back that when she was scum with him he told her to claim RL as an excuse to post low and he does it whether he is scum or townie.

I personally don't care for it as an excuse, and do my best to participate in the game regardless since I signed on to play.

 

[johnlarson66]

It was not the same tatic and I was rushing thru the questions.

"what" was the best answer I had at the time.

Do you think that my actions were as of described by Kash?

Do you think I was saying look at Ice and then voting FF? If anyone thought that both Ice and FF were scummy, but voted Ice, that would be scummy.

What are your thoughts on my vote on FF? Do you think I was just looking for an easy kill? If I was evil, would I even want mixed in the whole FF drama? Wouldn't it be best for the mafia to keep FF around a few more days?

If I am evil, why would I want FF gone? Why didn't I move off of him. People asked me to, it would not have looked scummy. I could have placed a lone vote for rich or some other low poster. Then if FF was lynched, I would have looked just fine.

Have you thought any of this out?

 

[johnlarson66]

You haven't "muddled" me at all JL.

I haven't seen anything or enough of Annie to see anything scummy.

Although as you mentioned, 4 posts at this point in the game is a bit ridiculous, we also know that he will claim RL as the reason.

LR posted in a couple of games back that when she was scum with him he told her to claim RL as an excuse to post low and he does it whether he is scum or townie.

I personally don't care for it as an excuse, and do my best to participate in the game regardless since I signed on to play.

But ILM, who was told not to post much last time they were mafia you have as a suspect.

You can't have it both ways. If you think ILM is evil, then you must have annie leaning evil also.

Your response to this is very suspect. Yes, annie is a known low poster. Granted. He also is known to make up reasons why he will not be around when he is scum. Granted. He has four posts. He was on FF and then placed a lone vote on Lab. I am not even sure why. He did post the slap-chop video.

You sure you don't want to re=evaluate your stance on annie?

 

[johnlarson66]

Not that I do not enjoy you trying to fill in the void that FF left (which you are doing quite well), I think I will be calling it a night.

This will give you time to catch up on the evenings events.

 

[the wizard]

Let me refresh your memory JL, in the post below you are replying to LG when she asked if you saw anything scummy about LR and who you thought to be scummy besides Ice.

Mostly people that have aligned themselves with Ice and asking questions like "who besides Ice to you think scummy?"

I think you also made some sort of comment about me finally being here or something. I think you know I post in spurts. Also, it is a little bit like the kettle calling the pot black.

It was not the same tatic and I was rushing thru the questions.

"what" was the best answer I had at the time.

Do you think that my actions were as of described by Kash?

Do you think I was saying look at Ice and then voting FF? If anyone thought that both Ice and FF were scummy, but voted Ice, that would be scummy.

What are your thoughts on my vote on FF? Do you think I was just looking for an easy kill? If I was evil, would I even want mixed in the whole FF drama? Wouldn't it be best for the mafia to keep FF around a few more days?

If I am evil, why would I want FF gone? Why didn't I move off of him. People asked me to, it would not have looked scummy. I could have placed a lone vote for rich or some other low poster. Then if FF was lynched, I would have looked just fine.

Have you thought any of this out?

What is not an answer it is a question.

My thoughts about your vote on FF are that it was scummy.

How about to give the scum team an edge by eliminating an innocent through lynch and their hit. (kind of like what happened)

But ILM, who was told not to post much last time they were mafia you have as a suspect.

You can't have it both ways. If you think ILM is evil, then you must have annie leaning evil also.

Your response to this is very suspect. Yes, annie is a known low poster. Granted. He also is known to make up reasons why he will not be around when he is scum. Granted. He has four posts. He was on FF and then placed a lone vote on Lab. I am not even sure why. He did post the slap-chop video.

You sure you don't want to re=evaluate your stance on annie?

Why do I need to reevaluate?

To say I suspect ILM means I have to suspect Annie doesn't make sense.

While I agree that not participating sucks and screws the town, what you are saying then is that all the low posters are suspect if you suspect one of them.

With that line of reasoning JL, you suspect ILM and Annie therefore you shouldn't suspect Ice because all the low posters are enough in number to round out the scum team.

 

[the wizard]

One more point for you JL.

You told Kashta that you did have a case against Ice.

You said that you thought Ice was protecting FF as he might be the prime evil.

You told LG in response to who besides Ice you find scummy anyone who sides with Ice or asks "who besides Ice do you find scummy?"

Here's the thin JL, as it reads in the thread, your whole case against Ice is based on FF being the prime evil.

FF was a townie.

Your response to LG was tonight. After last night's lynch revealed FF's alignment.

So your case against Ice is full of holes now don't you think?

besides, You suspect Ice and vote Annie? Even though you suspected Ice from D1.

Do you see the same contradiction I do?

 

[captaincaveman9]

WOW have a busy night and you miss a lot.

Here is a current list of living players:

AnniesNotOk
Biohazard
captaincaveman9
DangerDoll
dirtydawg10
I Love Mollies
IceH2O
J double R
Johnlarson66
Lab_rat
Lady G
Madcrawdad
[AC] Maelstrom
Noodles62
Rich311k
the wizard

Of that list I suspect JL, Ice, JRR, and ILM the most. I am very leery of Annie too.

I did flip flop my first vote to JL from FF, and I still stand by that. His original posts and then backing off is still suspicious to me.

The lack of posts and feedback as to why they are voting a certain way is disturbing for the remaining people on my list so far.

I removed Bio from my considerations, because a lot of times she seems more confused in her postings, or trying to lighten the mood.

just my quick random thoughts before I head off to work. I will be home in time to read the thread tonight and have time to change my vote if someone can convince me to change it. But as it stands I still feel my vote is on the correct person.....

 

[AnniesNotOK]

I vote to lynch AnniesNoOk.

Four posts. Four posts?

The switch off of FF on to a lone vote for Lab?

I don't expect for players to have bunches of posts, but it is halfway through day two and annie has 4 posts.

I know, its pretty ridiculous. I have been so busy I haven't really had time to keep up, I've skimmed most of the game at this point. I wish I hadn't signed up for this one, but I'm not going to quit or UD either.

You haven't "muddled" me at all JL.

I haven't seen anything or enough of Annie to see anything scummy.

Although as you mentioned, 4 posts at this point in the game is a bit ridiculous, we also know that he will claim RL as the reason.

LR posted in a couple of games back that when she was scum with him he told her to claim RL as an excuse to post low and he does it whether he is scum or townie.

I personally don't care for it as an excuse, and do my best to participate in the game regardless since I signed on to play.

Yeah, I certainly do feel bad, I should not have played, I was well aware my time would be limited. Turns out its even more limited than I expected.
Luckily, this town is full of great players, and I think we're gonna win this one anyway.

I will not be back on until Saturday morning, when I will review the thread and try to make sense of it all. Until then I'm comfortable with my vote on Lab.

 

[Lady G]

Mostly people that have aligned themselves with Ice and asking questions like "who besides Ice to you think scummy?"

I think you also made some sort of comment about me finally being here or something. I think you know I post in spurts. Also, it is a little bit like the kettle calling the pot black.

I don't see how asking for other thoughts on other ppl is a bad thing. I'm not "aligning" myself with Ice either. I just happen to think Lab is evil, I can't help he feels the same way.
Yes, I know how you post.

Sorry grammer king, I guess keeped it not a word - lets try kept. I kept my vote on FF. That is not muddled, my non-counting confused friend, it is typo while watching TV. Next you are going to say gooder is not a word.

:grinno:

You posted a question, your very own question, now you want to ask some of Kash's questions? Could we try to keep it under six. You have to agree 14 questions an hour before nightfall was BS. I think I did a pretty good job of answering them.

I am not like LG where I have you answering questions for me.

Hmmm, is he answering questions for me?
I do however agree with you on the Kash's burst of questioning, and from what I saw you pretty much answered.

 

[noodles62]

You are wrong, gooder comes right before goodest in my dictionary.

I prefer "more better" personally. :

there is certainly alot to try to digest from last night. This back and forth between Wiz and JL is mind boggling so I will have to read it over again. (ugh!)