Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[the wizard]

So you are not willing to answer the same questions you ask me?

You tell me to do my own homework, but yet you beg for a vote count?

Really, tell us what day one scumminess you saw.

Ok I will for your benefit post a few thoughts here.

I will not go into what I saw with you as it has been stated.

My list also consists of JRR

He votes with no explaination, heaccused FF of posting mindless dribble and I have not seen anything from him to rate higher than that.

Actually some of FF's last posts were more solid than any of Jrr's.

He has yet to answer any of the questions put to him by numerous players.

ILM is playing exactly like last time when he was scum and told to not post much.

and you know where my vote fell last night.

I left LR out of this post because you asked besides you and the LR/Noods thing.

 

[the wizard]

If he disregarded answering valid questions, then yes...

With that said, using post 460 as example, the tone of the questioning was condescending, some questions seemed rhetorical, and a few others may have not been readily answerable. It seemed like more of an opportunity for Kash to call JL scum, as opposed to actually gathering any information to help her make a decision.

But even in spite of that, I do remember JL answering to that post.

Can you point out just the most important question of Kashta's that went unanswered (in your opinion)?

I was in process of going through Kashta's posts to answer that question for JL but didn't get a chance to go back to find once the question answer session started.

It is a valid question and so I will find the important unanswered ones but it will take time as there are a lot of posts and I want to stay current with the game too.

 

[johnlarson66]

I vote to lynch AnniesNoOk.

Four posts. Four posts?

The switch off of FF on to a lone vote for Lab?

I don't expect for players to have bunches of posts, but it is halfway through day two and annie has 4 posts.

 

[johnlarson66]

Mad, don't muddle the guy.

 

[johnlarson66]

I was in process of going through Kashta's posts to answer that question for JL but didn't get a chance to go back to find once the question answer session started.

It is a valid question and so I will find the important unanswered ones but it will take time as there are a lot of posts and I want to stay current with the game too.

It is hard to keep up with the fast paced action of the last hour...

 

[johnlarson66]

I also agree with ILM as a suspect, I think he has 5 whole posts.

I also do not like JRR's hit and run posts, as Ice has pointed out. I am just not real quick at jumping on board with Ice on anything at this time.

 

[the wizard]

Kashta's Questions for John -

I'm back now and wondering... Hey JL, where'd you go?

I am working - busy Wednesday at Elite Zone

You could have gone over my posts to pull something from them and respond. But nothing at all, John?

I thought you were done talking to me today.

(Guess John requires spoon feeding today so I've summed up the questions I have all in one list.)

I think I asked about this 8 hours ago (when I was not busy)

How about these points then, John?



1. What's your opinion about that statement from FF as possibly being truthful. (Clicking the link will show you the text I quoted there... oh wait, you already know that. Um.. don't you? Don't you?!?!)

FF could be innocent. If an innocent were to get lynched today, I would rather it be FF than anyone else.

2. Are you so set in your stance against FF and your vote on him still that you aren't willing to consider you may be wrong? What if you are wrong, John? What will you say to us then if FF gets lynched tonight and turns up innocent townie?

My vote stays on FF. If FF gets lynched and turns up an innocent townie, I will say he did this to himself and he needs to think before he posts. He was a liability to the town.

3. Knowing FF's game play as well as you do, wouldn't you expect FF to stumble around awkwardly in his posts trying to defend himself against your initial vote and repeated questions? Unless he's being coached how to handle it by communicating teammate(s), of course. Did it really surprise you when FF reacted poorly in response to your posts as he did?

Yes, I thought his "Bad for both of us" comment was out of left field.

4. While I'm at this.... what DOES it take to get you to back off someone and leave them alone? <-- Heh. For future reference, just in case...

paypal sent to johnlarson66@aol.com

5. Feel free to comment on that remark, John, if you want to. Or not....?

did not come up on the quote

6. Same thing, as I mentioned you there too.

did not come up on the quote

7. Of the folks voting FF, John... who do you feel is most scummy, least scummy?

if FF is innocent then the third voter will have my attention.


8. Dang... you couldn't even answer a direct question?

what question

9. Do you actually have a case against Ice that's NOT dependent upon FF being evil?

Yes.

10. You've pushed them both at us to vote them all this time. Care to comment whether that's been deliberate or just a goof on your part?

I have not pushed anyone

11. Not a bad question for you to answer. What ARE your thoughts about the votes on FF today and the players behind those votes?

no real thoughts until we find out what FF and Ice are.

12. Seems you've pushed Ice as a suspect more than anyone else has in the game.... without actually voting the person you name. This tactic concerned you enough that you've called someone else out for doing it. Does that same premise NOT apply to you? If so.. why not?

what?

13. I'd like to know what you think about each of these people who voted Ice. Scummy? Not scummy?

I answered that one before.

14. After accomplishing what you hoped for and set out to make happen, aren't you proud? What has this vote split between FF vs Ice demonstrated for us, in your opinion? And was that what you expected we would learn from this?

If FF is the prime evil then his teamates voted for Ice.

I did find this post where JL responds to some of Kashta's questions.

the thing that strikes me here is his answer to question #12.

If he didn't understand the question and needed it clarified shouldn't he have asked for clarification instead of just saying what in the middle of a long post where it could get lost and missed?

 

[johnlarson66]

I did find this post where JL responds to some of Kashta's questions.

the thing that strikes me here is his answer to question #12.

If he didn't understand the question and needed it clarified shouldn't he have asked for clarification instead of just saying what in the middle of a long post where it could get lost and missed?

That long list was an hour before nightfall. There was no time to ask for clarification. I was not trying to hide anything in this long post, I was responding to 14 questions.

I had stated that I was okay with either Ice of FF and felt that FF was the prime evil and that Ice was protecting him. It was not your typical look left and vote right type of situation. I felt that FF and Ice were connected, mostly by Ice's actions.

Is this the dark secret that you wanted to know?

Really Wiz, you have been barking lots, but nothing you have has any bite to it.

 

[johnlarson66]

Sorry to muddle you with facts Wiz.

So what do you think of annie?

Is he a suspect of yours?

 

[the wizard]

That long list was an hour before nightfall. There was no time to ask for clarification. I was not trying to hide anything in this long post, I was responding to 14 questions.

I had stated that I was okay with either Ice of FF and felt that FF was the prime evil and that Ice was protecting him. It was not your typical look left and vote right type of situation. I felt that FF and Ice were connected, mostly by Ice's actions.

Is this the dark secret that you wanted to know?

Really Wiz, you have been barking lots, but nothing you have has any bite to it.

IF that was your real thought at the time then why didn't you say so when you responded to the post instead of typing "what" as an answer?

There are no real dark secrets I am looking for from you (unless you would care to name your team mates) just pointing out that you don't seem to answer the questions that are put to you.