Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[[AC] maelstrom]

i'm debating whether to move or not. I think Jrr is scum but I feel better about bio and at the same time I dont want to vote with them too. Im not sure I see what is up with ccm but again if Im the one who needs to switch to make it a three way tie (if thats what the plan is) then I will. I feel stronger about annie and/or rich filling in that last spot.

 

[captaincaveman9]

My responses will be in red.....

"It was all Day 1 posts, it wasn't a list. Reading the context of the posts leads me to the 4 I listed. I doubt all 4 are evil. 5 evils and an extra hit seems over the top. At least 3 of the 4 are evil IMO.

Rich- complete 180 in regards to vote. I'd like to know what changed your mind to do a complete flip? Can you point me to a post that convinced you I was evil and Lab was innocent?

JRR- nothing he has done has been pro town. Doesn't give reasons for votes. As much that has gone down no opinions?

Bio- pretty much no real opinions either, votes in places that doesn't help the town and also has no real input on anything happening.

CCM- Have problems with his list and never did get any real reasoning from him for it. "

I gave a brief overview of some of the key players on my list. If i need to rehash every post I've made regarding JL then I can find them. But, frankly as this is a game and have some time to play, I don't have hours on end to copy every post i question, or copy all my old post because some one is to lazy to reread some of my old posts.

johnlarson66 I was looking at the vote tallies, here CCM moves off of FF and puts a lone vote on me -



He saves FF, but states that he does not think FF is innocent.

CCM, do you think I am the prime evil, is that why you would choose one person over the other if you thought both of us were evil?

John I chose you over FF simply because people pointed out his play and spastic way he is, and you seemed more of a logical choice for being scum. I wont pretend to think you are prime evil, just at the least on the scummy side. FF seemed scummy to me by the way he posted and pointed to other players right away to try to get attention to someone else. it wasn't until he was resigned to his fate of being lynched, were his posts taking my suspicions away.

Is he really playing the confused card for Bio?

I'm not playing the "Bio is a confused noob" card for anyone. I was just making an observation based on her posts. If you don't see her posts the same way then I'm sorry for you....


My lack of response to peoples questions on Friday and Saturday were simply due to working late and preparing for the bad weather that hit my area today. Sorry but my safety was a bigger concern than a game.....

 

[captaincaveman9]

Many of the people on my list were people of low post count up until that time and suspicions from earlier posts. I still think JL's earliest posts looked like he was trying to work up FF and guide people to him........

 

[dirtydawg10]

JRR voted LG and then switched to Lab late...LG was hit during the night.

did jrr try to get a train going too soon and jumped off when he realized they were going to hit her? I'm thinking so.

I do agree that Richs flip flopping doesnt look good, especially when you consider the stance he took last night on lab when she flipped scum.

My list has stayed the same:

Bio
Jrr
Annie

with special consideration for Rich who I could sub in for annie.

Any merit to putting up Jrr and Bio tonight rather than just railroad bio?

Here you suggest putting up a 2 horse race.

I'm pretty sure of bio but i was just thinking about what other info we could gain since it doesnt look like others are going to be close to the chopping block today...I dont have ccm as a top suspect per se but I dont have him leaning innocent either. If others have a strong enough opinion of him being scummy and you need my vote there count me in.

Again you would like to vote for someone other than Bio it seems as you keep suggesting it.

Either way I don't think we'd learn much unless the evils make a suicide move or innocents are trusting of an evil player that gets them to lynch an innocent 3rd player.

Might just be safer to take this 1 player at a time. We can all come to an agreement on at least a few players. The less players post at this time the more suspect they will look. So if they are innocent and on everyones lists they better come up with good case why they are innocent and why they think someone else is evil.

Ice suggests taking one player out at a time.

makes sense.

And I agree with the bottom part...now that you all mention cap he hasnt said anything in quite a long time.

waiting to hear your thoughts ccm.

And you say you agree with that.

check my suspect list and you'll see. I posted it earlier and nothing has really changed.

You say your suspect list hasn't changed...which has Bio clearly at the top as scum.

i'm debating whether to move or not. I think Jrr is scum but I feel better about bio and at the same time I dont want to vote with them too. Im not sure I see what is up with ccm but again if Im the one who needs to switch to make it a three way tie (if thats what the plan is) then I will. I feel stronger about annie and/or rich filling in that last spot.

After you agree with Ice that focusing on one person tonight is a good idea...you talk about moving again. You say Bio is still your best feeling for scum but for some reason you keep suggesting moving your vote off of them. It seems the Town consensus is to get rid of Bio tonight. Judging from the votes and several peoples comments I think that is safe to say. But you keep talking about switching and I'm wondering if you have an ulterior motive.

Then you talk about Annie...who is on your list and has been. So what do you think about Annie voting for Lab (a known evil) both nights? Please explain your thoughts on Annie.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I'm very surprised no one besides Mael has commented on this previous post. I'm not really interested in what Mael thinks although Mael did confirm Lab was right in calling him a he.

I ran across this in my rereading and thought it merited a post...

So now Mael is on this team?

IDK, is he?

Take a look at the 2 posts above. In the first post JL is asking Lab if Mael is an evil. Lab rat responds "IDK, is he?"...how exactly does Lab know that Mael is a he?? Mael seems to be a player who hasn't played in a while and is an unknown (alias) player. Mael can you confirm whether you are in fact a he? Or perhaps you don't want to??

Lab has slipped up quite a few times this round and I'm wondering if I found another one.

For now...I vote to lynch Bio

 

[dirtydawg10]

Is it just me or is anyone else wondering where JL has disappeared to???

 

[noodles62]

Is it just me or is anyone else wondering where JL has disappeared to???

not just you. I have been curious about that myself.

as i said last night i have a feeling that i am being played or being too trusting of one i should not. I hope to figure that out today and quiet that nagging little voice in my head....


I have to fix breakfast for my poor hubby that has to work again on his "day off" but will be back in a while......

 

[AnniesNotOK]

Here you suggest putting up a 2 horse race.



Again you would like to vote for someone other than Bio it seems as you keep suggesting it.



Ice suggests taking one player out at a time.



And you say you agree with that.



You say your suspect list hasn't changed...which has Bio clearly at the top as scum.



After you agree with Ice that focusing on one person tonight is a good idea...you talk about moving again. You say Bio is still your best feeling for scum but for some reason you keep suggesting moving your vote off of them. It seems the Town consensus is to get rid of Bio tonight. Judging from the votes and several peoples comments I think that is safe to say. But you keep talking about switching and I'm wondering if you have an ulterior motive.

Then you talk about Annie...who is on your list and has been. So what do you think about Annie voting for Lab (a known evil) both nights? Please explain your thoughts on Annie.

I'm curious as to what her thoughts are on me as well Dawg. She may call it distancing, as JL implied it was, but it doesn't explain why I am on a list with two people I named as suspects in what few posts I have made.

This morning I'm going to spend some time turning over stones. I'm ashamed to admit I have skimmed most of this game. Its difficult to post original thoughts when you're often late to the party, but I'll do my best to dig in and find a scumbag today.

 

[IceH2O]

Many of the people on my list were people of low post count up until that time and suspicions from earlier posts. I still think JL's earliest posts looked like he was trying to work up FF and guide people to him........

I knew your reasons for JL it was the other players on your list which I wondered about. Do you have a new list after seeing what has transpired the past few days?
Glad to see the tornadoes bypassed you.

Here you suggest putting up a 2 horse race.



Again you would like to vote for someone other than Bio it seems as you keep suggesting it.



Ice suggests taking one player out at a time.



And you say you agree with that.



You say your suspect list hasn't changed...which has Bio clearly at the top as scum.



After you agree with Ice that focusing on one person tonight is a good idea...you talk about moving again. You say Bio is still your best feeling for scum but for some reason you keep suggesting moving your vote off of them. It seems the Town consensus is to get rid of Bio tonight. Judging from the votes and several peoples comments I think that is safe to say. But you keep talking about switching and I'm wondering if you have an ulterior motive.

Then you talk about Annie...who is on your list and has been. So what do you think about Annie voting for Lab (a known evil) both nights? Please explain your thoughts on Annie.

Yeah this is starting to rub me the wrong way. I must admit that Noods is starting to worry me a bit also with her feel like she is being played or being too trusting of someone.


I'm thinking whoever got the EVP message should tell us what it said. We can determine if its true or not or if its an innocent player or not saying so.
It bothers me that it was just pushed to the side. Its funny that Mael and Noods are the 2 players that did speak up and say that person shouldn't come out or that we couldn't prove it was an innocent that got it.
I think its worth the risk.

 

[IceH2O]

I'm very surprised no one besides Mael has commented on this previous post. I'm not really interested in what Mael thinks although Mael did confirm Lab was right in calling him a he.

I always assume he too unless its obvious in the posting its female.