Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[IceH2O]

Back from work!
Well, I see the dog piling has continued. I am innocent, I tell you!

I still don't see what I have done scummy...or how I am connected in any way to LabRat. I feel like one of the people really pushing my "scuminess" is scum themselves.

**Ice grabs pliers and opens Bios mouth****



So who is it????????????????????????

Why do you feel that way?????????????????



This is why we think you're scum. You don't name anyone you suspect and why you suspect them. You've protected someone that showed evil and are protecting others some think are evil.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I always assume he too unless its obvious in the posting its female.

Good point. I just wanted to hear it from someone other than Mael. I guess it stood out more to me because I don't like to assume and I will usually write they or them instead of he or she.

 

[noodles62]

I'm very surprised no one besides Mael has commented on this previous post. I'm not really interested in what Mael thinks although Mael did confirm Lab was right in calling him a he.

I'm curious as to what her thoughts are on me as well Dawg. She may call it distancing, as JL implied it was, but it doesn't explain why I am on a list with two people I named as suspects in what few posts I have made.

This morning I'm going to spend some time turning over stones. I'm ashamed to admit I have skimmed most of this game. Its difficult to post original thoughts when you're often late to the party, but I'll do my best to dig in and find a scumbag today.

ok, after dawg questions Mael on his (?) thoughts on Annie, Annie comes back and calls Mael a she? Strange...

I knew your reasons for JL it was the other players on your list which I wondered about. Do you have a new list after seeing what has transpired the past few days?
Glad to see the tornadoes bypassed you.



Yeah this is starting to rub me the wrong way. I must admit that Noods is starting to worry me a bit also with her feel like she is being played or being too trusting of someone.


I'm thinking whoever got the EVP message should tell us what it said. We can determine if its true or not or if its an innocent player or not saying so.
It bothers me that it was just pushed to the side. Its funny that Mael and Noods are the 2 players that did speak up and say that person shouldn't come out or that we couldn't prove it was an innocent that got it.
I think its worth the risk.

Sorry if me posting my suspicsions is bothersome but this just seems too easy and too quiet. i find it hard to believe that the entire scum team is playing quiet and not playing us at all.

of the players taht actually seem to be playing of late:

Ice - i still feel pretty confident about Ice; I find it hard to beleive that Labby would have gone after him that hard if they were team mates.

Dawg- feeling ok with him as well. not get a scum vibe but he is hard to read.

Mael - not sure- seems to be trying to help the town but a bit leery about the he/she issue. something is making me a bit leery. Maybe it is the alias - IDK.

JL - did seem to be working to help the town but has been MIA of late....RL issues? again IDK....

Other players really are not that active and as i said i just find it hard to believe that the entire scum team is playing quiet. But i guess it is a possibility....

 

[noodles62]

**Ice grabs pliers and opens Bios mouth****


So who is it????????????????????????

Why do you feel that way?????????????????


This is why we think you're scum. You don't name anyone you suspect and why you suspect them. You've protected someone that showed evil and are protecting others some think are evil.

:rofl: well, you did say it was like pulling teeth - pliers will certainly get the job done! :lipssealedsmilie:

I agree tho - it would be nice to hear something of substance....

 

[johnlarson66]

Yesterday around 1 pm -

Here is an interesting part of that quote also -



Is he really playing the confused card for Bio?

Followed by this -

Wiz mentioned something about scum voting for Lab, also just before nightfall, noods mentioned something and then mael responed -



I think it would be best to see the order of the votes on Lab -

(8) Lab - Ice(556), nood(559), annie(645), lady g(648), maelstrom(653) Dawg(708) DD(816) Lady G(844) JRR(865)

I agree that annie and JRR could have been blending in.

Then I get this -

Is it just me or is anyone else wondering where JL has disappeared to???

and this -

not just you. I have been curious about that myself.

as i said last night i have a feeling that i am being played or being too trusting of one i should not. I hope to figure that out today and quiet that nagging little voice in my head....


I have to fix breakfast for my poor hubby that has to work again on his "day off" but will be back in a while......

I have no idea why dawg and noods even care where I have been. Am I on their suspect lists? Is there something they need or want from me? Off all the players that have not posted in the last 20 hours, it is me that they ask about?

No thoughts on Bio's vote on JRR?

 

[johnlarson66]

Noods, it has not even been 24 hours and you have me MIA?

Really how had I been helpful before?

 

[johnlarson66]

...

JL - did seem to be working to help the town but has been MIA of late....RL issues? again IDK....

Other players really are not that active and as i said i just find it hard to believe that the entire scum team is playing quiet. But i guess it is a possibility....

This post is really bothering me. How did I seem to be working to help the town? Give some sort of examples. How long is "off late", I posted yesterday, what else is there to add? No RL issues, just real life. It is the weekend, I am off work and the weather is decent.

Then you make a comment implying that I am part of the scum team.

 

[johnlarson66]

noods, going to pick a fight with me and walk away?

 

[dirtydawg10]

Yesterday around 1 pm -



Followed by this -



Then I get this -



and this -



I have no idea why dawg and noods even care where I have been. Am I on their suspect lists? Is there something they need or want from me? Off all the players that have not posted in the last 20 hours, it is me that they ask about?

No thoughts on Bio's vote on JRR?

I was just wondering because up until the past 20hrs you had been extremely active in this thread. The others who haven't posted in the past 20hrs weren't posting anyway.

 

[noodles62]

Pulled this because it has been brought up/questioned:

LOL

We all have our suspects. Do you guys think if we ask the receiver of the message to come out we could tell if they are truthful or if they are scum trying to look innocent? It gives the evils a hit target but could give us valuable info.

Just caught this...

ice, I dont think we can trust the person at all since the message may have gone to the scum anyways. then again you can always lynch and find out later...

Shhhhhh.... I knew that. I was trying to trick them if evil into trying to tell us something and out themselves...


J/K I forgot they carried the same equipment.

oooohhh a famous Ice trap? lol

The ice trap caught Lab, did it not?

true, true

{SNIP}
As far as the player coming out with the random results - I say no due to that it could have been a scum that got the results and we cannot afford to be led astray with bogus info right now.....{SNIP}

Ice, you are correct; Mael and I are the only two that even commented on the idea of the the player coming out. (unless I missed someone). Could be that you stated it was a trap so no one else bothered to comment?? I would love to know the results but not knowing if it was scum or townie that got the info how can we trust it? I feel that we can't afford to follow possible bogus info....JMO



Quoted this cause i thought it was worth reiterating:


QUOTE=IceH2O;2342458]There is a post where she digs at DD for understanding one of my posts it didn't carry over for some reason,I thought I clicked it but guess not.She also got into it a bit with Wiz. Also Noods at the end of Day 1 for the vote switch.

These are all Day 1 posts, I think its safe to say we can put all these names below the evil line. Don't think to much distancing was going on at the time as Lab wasn't in any real trouble. I say we concentrate on those not listed above.

Thats 9 names plus we know Mad LG and Kash and ILM are innocents bring a total to 13. That leaves just 5 possibilities of evils. We know Lab was so we really just need to narrow it down between 4 players.

Those 4 would be

Bio
CCM
JRR
Rich[/QUOTE]

just thought it was worth thinking about: most votes, including JRR are on Bio; DD is on CCM; Rich and Bio are on JRR;.....Rich has not votes on him and is voting along with Bio....