Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[IceH2O]

I don't think there are 3 left,possible but doubtful.

I don't really like that there are 3 up there. I think we should be voting who we think is evil not having horse races. If there are 3 evils they can't control the lynch unless we spread out the field. Even if we only put 2 players up the innocents should vote for who they think is evil, not try and place votes strategically for a coin flip.

I only moved for response, I wasn't going to let it end in a coin flip.

CCM wasn't around for night fall and seemed rush, now he is bent out of shape over a game because he is being pointed at for being scum, yes JRR did also but I think he is using that to his advantage.

For that reason I'll be voting CCM.

I retract my vote on JL and vote to lynch CCM.

If there are 3 it would be you and Wiz.

If only 2 more I'm not sure if its you or Wiz. I think Wiz has been trying to hard and you haven't been trying enough.

 

[noodles62]

noods, what are your thoughts on annie?

I have had a hard time "placing" Annie this time. (like i am ever any good at placing anyone! rofl) He was on Labby both nights and was the kill vote night 2. Not saying this clears him in my mind, just not sure....

I feel like we are totally overlooking Rich and possibly DD too. I dont want to miss anyone at this point in the game.

 

[johnlarson66]

Ice, you seemed so sure of Bio. Now Bio is with me and wiz.

Want to explain this whole exorist thing?

 

[noodles62]

crap! senor cranky is home....gotta go for now. back in a bit.

 

[johnlarson66]

I have had a hard time "placing" Annie this time. (like i am ever any good at placing anyone! rofl) He was on Labby both nights and was the kill vote night 2. Not saying this clears him in my mind, just not sure....

I feel like we are totally overlooking Rich and possibly DD too. I dont want to miss anyone at this point in the game.

So being on Labby both nights and being the "kill" vote on night 2 does not clear him. So you are neutral on annie. He could be innocent or scum, you are just not sure.

There are plenty of other players, but you bring up rich and DD. Did you bring them up because you have them as suspects or to dilute the conversation I wish to have about annie, who I am voting for. Now if you were voting for rich or DD I would love to talk about them.

I wanted to know your thoughts on my top suspect.

 

[johnlarson66]

Ice,

Any thoughts on annie?

Really, does anyone have anything to say about annies 8 posts.

 

[IceH2O]

I already explained how JL. Its not 100% but at this point we have nothing to lose. Why are you against it? Its funny Mael was against the EVP coming out too.

I'm more sure of CCM then Bio right now based on the missed hit.

I need to cut some grass since I didn't do it over the weekend due to threat of rain and then the race yesterday. I'm only doing the front so I should be back in about an hour or so.
Do me a favor and hit me tonight so I can finish the rest of the grass tomorrow.

 

[IceH2O]

Based on voting I think Annie is innocent. Only way I could see him being evil was if he got caught on Lab and wasn't around to move or it was to late to move.

 

[johnlarson66]

I have re-read annies 8 posts.

Here is the vote switch -

I retract my vote for FF and vote to lynch LabRat.

My reasons for this are simple:

She is voting Ice, because she thinks he is playing mind games.

She had an agenda to twist Ice's posts, when it was clear to any reasonable person what his plan has been all along and what he meant by his post.

Lab knew the plan, in fact, isn't that why she voted Ice in the first place?

Here is the day 2 post -

I vote to lynch Lab.

I am unsatified with her explanation of her contradictory post.

I am doing my best to stay caught up, but have admittedly had to skim through a great deal of posts yesterday, and have had no time to go back and read more thouroughly. Unfortunately I don't have that time now either, but I hope Friday things will start to calm down around here.

Having said that, I'm going to throw out a suspect list that I will try to add to when I am able to more carefully review D1.

LabRat- was quick to vote Ice early D1 after he mentioned he would welcome a lynch. She has doggedly insisted he is the scummiest so far, that is until Noods moved her vote, at which point she stated Ice is innocent. I'm sure this post will add me to the "scumspiracy", and my name will quickly appear on her list of suspects.

JL- I admit I'm really only looking at JL at The Wiz's insistence. The Wiz has really stepped it up, and to be quite honest, I find myself agreeing with much of what he has posted. He seems adamant that JL is a threat to the town, definately seems worth looking into further.

Here is a repsonse to my post about 4 posts and some more explainations -

I know, its pretty ridiculous. I have been so busy I haven't really had time to keep up, I've skimmed most of the game at this point. I wish I hadn't signed up for this one, but I'm not going to quit or UD either.



Yeah, I certainly do feel bad, I should not have played, I was well aware my time would be limited. Turns out its even more limited than I expected.
Luckily, this town is full of great players, and I think we're gonna win this one anyway.

I will not be back on until Saturday morning, when I will review the thread and try to make sense of it all. Until then I'm comfortable with my vote on Lab.

The only way annie is scum if the plan on day one was to sacrifice Lab at some point. So if annie is scum then everything changes.

 

[johnlarson66]

I already explained how JL. Its not 100% but at this point we have nothing to lose. Why are you against it? Its funny Mael was against the EVP coming out too.

I'm more sure of CCM then Bio right now based on the missed hit.

I need to cut some grass since I didn't do it over the weekend due to threat of rain and then the race yesterday. I'm only doing the front so I should be back in about an hour or so.
Do me a favor and hit me tonight so I can finish the rest of the grass tomorrow.

I am not against it, I just am not sure how to prove it. We can narrow it down to whoever voted for mael, would you agree that the exorist voted for mael?