Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[noodles62]

ok, so now we have Dawg and JL that we can trust as innocents but that still gives us not absolute info on who is scum.....

JL/Dawg, what are your thoughts on Wiz?

 

[noodles62]

oops - "no" absolute info....

 

[johnlarson66]

I am still trying to figure out how I feel about annie, bio and ccm.

I am voting on annie with Wiz. There are some points that he has made that I like. The problem is there was some points that mael made that I liked also.

 

[johnlarson66]

Annie and CCM have not even tried to defend themselves. That seems to be the evils thing so far.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

I think Bio and CCM are both scumbags.

How in the hell I'm in a three horse race with them is amazing. I am tempted to move my vote to CCM, because I trust Dawg.

However, if the town wants a coin toss, then a coin toss it will get. My vote stays on Bio.

 

[noodles62]

I am still trying to figure out how I feel about annie, bio and ccm.

I am voting on annie with Wiz. There are some points that he has made that I like. The problem is there was some points that mael made that I liked also.

Me too - that is when I started getting that nagging feeling. I have backed Bio down on my list. I am really starting to believe her story of just trying to figure out the game. (Heck, I have been playing for a long time and I still cant figure it out!) Of course second guessing myself seems to get me in trouble more times then not.

I still feel pretty good about my vote on CCM....out of the three, that is my choice anyway.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

Annie and CCM have not even tried to defend themselves. That seems to be the evils thing so far.

On D1, I was the first to vote Lab.

On D2, I was the kill vote on Lab.

If you look at Maels posts, she has been blowing smoke my way since about the middle of D2. Had I been here, I would have happily switched my vote to Mael.

If you think I am part of a team that sacrificed Lab to gain the towns trust, then I can see your vote for me John. Otherwise it doesn't make alot of sense.

What was the case against me again?

 

[noodles62]

I think Bio and CCM are both scumbags.

How in the hell I'm in a three horse race with them is amazing. I am tempted to move my vote to CCM, because I trust Dawg.

However, if the town wants a coin toss, then a coin toss it will get. My vote stays on Bio.

Why would you just give up instead of moving your vote to make certain you are not in the coin toss?

 

[noodles62]

On D1, I was the first to vote Lab.

On D2, I was the kill vote on Lab.

If you look at Maels posts, she has been blowing smoke my way since about the middle of D2. Had I been here, I would have happily switched my vote to Mael.

If you think I am part of a team that sacrificed Lab to gain the towns trust, then I can see your vote for me John. Otherwise it doesn't make alot of sense.

What was the case against me again?

What makes you think Mael is a she?

 

[IceH2O]

Okay so I went back to Day 1 and decided to look over posts. Mael was questioning Wizes post pretty hard so I think Wiz is innocent and over analyzing.

But while looking the posts over I noticed DD.

This is Day 1 and the 1st post of Day 2.

wait a second, thuis would be going on the assumption that FF believes Labby is a more experienced player than he is.... I don't know which started playing mafia first, Labby or FF...but I would consider them to have about as much experience as the other... that said, perhaps Labby needs some looking into... however, her discussion in regards to speaking to us as a group seemed a bit different from FF's who's seemed to come from no where.

I am beginning to wonder if you wish you would have told FF to keep quiet like Ice did when they were on an evil team together.

ok, so then you would also consider FF to have thus same thought process... I am not so sure about that.

I was not sure what he thought before he role-played, however, the role playing could be to back you up, I don't know.

You forgot about Lady G and ILM. Neither has added any substance to the game. However, I doubt all 3 are mafia and using the same tactic...

I find it interesting though that Annie has posted just after your thought.

UGH!! Got in late and I think I am caught up... the posts leading up to last night were interesting as far as having the three way tie, and then the two way tie... and then the Lab and Ice conversation and the time zone thing...

and man, never saw Kash getting hit, coming... I woulda thought it would have been smarter going for a newbie to put up with FF... must be some mafia team...

From before night, I had this that stuck out...

eesh, I really don't like when people come out and just say blatantly that they are innocent... this has raised my suspicion of Bio..

and Lab's post... I guess I can see it being read in 2 ways... the way Ice is reading it and as if she were just posting a thought... I dunno... originally, I might have been thinking more along Ice's line of thinking until it felt like he was sort of pushing it a bit hard by making the post so big and colored and all that... the problem I am struggling with is has Ice really found something, which would lean me to trusting Ice.... which is scary or has labby just sputtered out nonsense from a long day... I am not liking the idea of rushing to vote on this, I think Labby, you need to explain...

This is from after night call:


care to say why, JRR?

Big time defense of Lab.



I think DD is evil.