Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[rich311k]

well, just got back from a wonderful luncheon at Outback (I am so full!) and nothing has gone on. Since the evil(s) dont really want to play, why don't they just concede so we can get on with other activities?

Did you have a steak? I hate being on a diet dont see why the wife wants me to live forever.

As for playing I think we have covered every possibility though feel free to bring up a new theory. I have said my piece for the moment.

 

[noodles62]

lol...thanks Noods. The funny thing is it's the same way you came up with your vote on DD.

FYI...I have looked at the voting records of you, Rich and DD as well as your posts and that's how I came to my conclusions. If you don't like it too bad. Don't forget that the "Noods freak out" is also a scum tell for you so thanks for completing that portion of my investigation as well.

All I know is that things seem to be between You, DD and Rich. I'm not 100% convinced on any of you three but you are highest on my list to be scum. So the best thing you've got to do is attack a known innocent rather than post why you are not scum? To me that's scummy. Especially when (as I said before) it's similar to the way you came to your conclusions on DD except I believe I've done more looking then you have. If I'm wrong so be it. It won't be the last time either. Unfortunately I probably won't be around at nightfall so my vote will just stay where it is. You may want to try to convince someone else to move their vote to DD because mine is staying where it is. It looks like it may come to a coin toss between you and DD which is fine with me.

(FYI ~ that was not a "freak out")

I came to my conclusion on DD based on the opposite of your findings. I think her and Mael were definately distancing. It was day 1 BS that went no where. She only voted for Mael when it was apparent there was no other choice based on the info that was received. As far as "attacking a known innocent", I dont see it that way. I posted why I think your theory is ridiculous and by doing so shows that if viewed from my perspective the scum is someone else... Not really sure how I could "prove my innocence" anyway, since there are no team mates or PR factors that could be thrown out there.
I am perfectly fine with being lynched tonight. we still have the numbers to pull it off, unless of course there are in fact 2 scum left.
If there are 2; 1 innocent gets lynched, 1 innocent gets hit; that leaves it 2 vs. 2, which gives the scum the win.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

Annie, if the scum has not yet taken Dawg out, what makes you think they will take him out tonight?

Well, I just figured since he's practically a confirmed innocent...(though the thought had crossed my mind that he handed us Mael on a silver platter to gain our trust and he's really a scumbag...that can't be true can it??...this game makes me so paranoid sometimes I swear)...and he's doing a good job digging for clues so he'd be the next logical choice.

That being said, I vote to lynch Noods.

 

[dirtydawg10]

(FYI ~ that was not a "freak out")

I came to my conclusion on DD based on the opposite of your findings. I think her and Mael were definately distancing. It was day 1 BS that went no where. She only voted for Mael when it was apparent there was no other choice based on the info that was received. As far as "attacking a known innocent", I dont see it that way. I posted why I think your theory is ridiculous and by doing so shows that if viewed from my perspective the scum is someone else... Not really sure how I could "prove my innocence" anyway, since there are no team mates or PR factors that could be thrown out there.
I am perfectly fine with being lynched tonight. we still have the numbers to pull it off, unless of course there are in fact 2 scum left.
If there are 2; 1 innocent gets lynched, 1 innocent gets hit; that leaves it 2 vs. 2, which gives the scum the win.

Thanks...that's what I was hoping to see. I was actually trying to get you to freak out but you didn't go there. So for now I believe you and I have been slowly coming over to you side but didn't want to show my cards before I moved. I think that is also the reason DD has been quiet recently. So I hope I'm doing the right thing.

I retract my vote for Noods and vote to lynch DD

The main thing that started me moving my ideas was based on your voting record. You have voted scum every night so far and voted early on a few nights. So this isn't just a spur of the moment thing. I also went back and looked at the singleton vote DD had on Mael and reread the discussions between Mael and DD it I can see where it may have been distancing. DD has also voted her share of scum but it has usually been late in the game. There you go. See you after nightfall and hopefully it is celebrating a win.

 

[noodles62]

I thought I would go back and check on a few things......
this is from night 3 when the scum missed their hit:


DD chimes in 37 minutes after nightfall!

WOOHOO!! man, the mafia are really off their game!! and I can't belive Jrr was the doc... sucks to lose him... but really, where is he?

I am good for 24 hours...

Nice call, Dawg!! I vote to lynch Bio

Jsut for the record: Rich's comments after nightfall...

If the mafia had a hit that they did not use that narrows the list quite a bit. Bio has not played much, CCM and Annie were not around much.

I vote to lynch Bio. I am giving CCM a good long look though.

sure ya are....

Bio's response to Ice when he stated she has 24 hours to convince us she is not scum...note her benign comment about DD

Dude, I couldn't do it in the LAST 48-or-whatever-it-was hours. I doubt I shall convince you in the next 24.
Unfortunately, any "proof" I would try to provide would likely be said to be me playing reverse psychology.
I'll do anything I can to help till you lynch me though.

My scum team suspects are CCM and Annie. DD has been really quiet too. The last game, while it lasted, she was MUCH more active and chatty.

Next is Rich's response to Bio - no one has questioned DD about forgetting a hit at this point.....

I do not see DD forgetting a hit.

Bio - correcting Rich regarding her post....

Didn't say she forgot a hit. Said she was chattier last time.

Just sayin......:lipssealedsmilie:

 

[noodles62]

whew! You had me scared there Dawg! I hope we are both right about DD.

Thanks for acknowledging my voting record. I thought I was doing pretty good with the exception of Bio. She had quite a few of us confused. (Bio - defend yourself woman!!!)

 

[rich311k]

I thought I would go back and check on a few things......
this is from night 3 when the scum missed their hit:


DD chimes in 37 minutes after nightfall!



Jsut for the record: Rich's comments after nightfall...

sure ya are....

Bio's response to Ice when he stated she has 24 hours to convince us she is not scum...note her benign comment about DD



Next is Rich's response to Bio - no one has questioned DD about forgetting a hit at this point.....


Bio - correcting Rich regarding her post....




Just sayin......:lipssealedsmilie:

That was a reason why I did not think DD was scum. Not a direct answer. As you well know. I should not even bother to clarify it but why not.

 

[rich311k]

I think DD is innocent. We shall see.

 

[noodles62]

g/o oh, and yes, I had steak. (it was a predetermined menu for our luncheon but it was a good choice!) :drool: (I only eat red meat a couple times a month, so I thoroughly enjoyed it)....g/o

 

[noodles62]

Well, I just figured since he's practically a confirmed innocent...(though the thought had crossed my mind that he handed us Mael on a silver platter to gain our trust and he's really a scumbag...that can't be true can it??...this game makes me so paranoid sometimes I swear)...and he's doing a good job digging for clues so he'd be the next logical choice.

That being said, I vote to lynch Noods.

Well, annie if it could be true for Dawg it could be equally true for you.