Mafia #70: The Time Vortex

[jbradt]

Here is the link to that game again, so you can all see. I just don't see how it can't be that game to many things add up to it IMO.

I don't see where you're going with this line of thought, LG. The only thing I can see to link the two games is that Pap said it was 1963. I don't think it makes enough of a difference to go back and look, but was there a game set in 1963? Besides that, despite the game the day is based on, the number of scum is set... we're still only looking for 3. Or did I miss something?

What else are you seeing that makes you think it's that game in particular? And why does it matter? It seems to me our job is to find scum, not figure out where/when we are.

 

[jbradt]

I don't see where you're going with this line of thought, LG. The only thing I can see to link the two games is that Pap said it was 1963. I don't think it makes enough of a difference to go back and look, but was there a game set in 1963? Besides that, despite the game the day is based on, the number of scum is set... we're still only looking for 3. Or did I miss something?

What else are you seeing that makes you think it's that game in particular? And why does it matter? It seems to me our job is to find scum, not figure out where/when we are.

Right, sorry; I forgot about the "colder than usual" part of your original post... something to think about, but it still seems like a moot point to me.

What does not seem moot is that you seem to be so interested in figuring it out.

 

[Lady G]

OK, so have we come to the colclution that this day is based on the 50/50 game that ice modded, also known as game 63? If so can we move on to the bigger matters of the bad feeling i get when i look at the wiz/JL/HN thing?

WELL, did you forget your happy pills today FF?

I don't see where you're going with this line of thought, LG. The only thing I can see to link the two games is that Pap said it was 1963. I don't think it makes enough of a difference to go back and look, but was there a game set in 1963? Besides that, despite the game the day is based on, the number of scum is set... we're still only looking for 3. Or did I miss something?

What else are you seeing that makes you think it's that game in particular? And why does it matter? It seems to me our job is to find scum, not figure out where/when we are.

It seems pretty clear to me the year is 1963 the game number was 63, his hint said the town is split between the good and bad guys, that game was a 50/50 game (SPLIT), and it seems a bit colder then usual, Ice was the mod....ICE IS COLD.

 

[Lady G]

Right, sorry; I forgot about the "colder than usual" part of your original post... something to think about, but it still seems like a moot point to me.

What does not seem moot is that you seem to be so interested in figuring it out.

And why wouldn't we try to figure out which game format we are playing...seems like a pretty important thing to me.

 

[Madcrawdad]

I have no idea, so im not going to try to find a reason. If it seems fishy (lol) then feel free to vote for it.

I'd just go for 'peculiar' over 'fishy'.

cant

What does this mean?

OK, so have we come to the colclution that this day is based on the 50/50 game that ice modded, also known as game 63? If so can we move on to the bigger matters of the bad feeling i get when i look at the wiz/JL/HN thing?

I don't see where you're going with this line of thought, LG. The only thing I can see to link the two games is that Pap said it was 1963. I don't think it makes enough of a difference to go back and look, but was there a game set in 1963? Besides that, despite the game the day is based on, the number of scum is set... we're still only looking for 3. Or did I miss something?

What else are you seeing that makes you think it's that game in particular? And why does it matter? It seems to me our job is to find scum, not figure out where/when we are.

I disagree with FF and JB here. According to the rules, JPap will be assigning identities/abilities based on previous games. Therefore, it'd be nice to have even a vague idea of what's going on in terms of identities/abilities.

There's certainly no harm in addressing it, and it's probably more helpful than hurtful to the town....assuming we don't get hung up on it to the point of distraction.

 

[Lady G]

I'd just go for 'peculiar' over 'fishy'.


What does this mean?





I disagree with FF and JB here. According to the rules, JPap will be assigning identities/abilities based on previous games. Therefore, it'd be nice to have even a vague idea of what's going on in terms of identities/abilities.

There's certainly no harm in addressing it, and it's probably more helpful than hurtful to the town....assuming we don't get hung up on it to the point of distraction.

Yes, I agree we shouldn't spend all our time running in circles around which format we are in right now. It is important to me however, especially since in that set up the mafia started with one and could send in a name to try to get on their team. What scares me a little about that is at this point I don't think the mafia can communicate, if they are starting with three does that mean each of them would get to send in a name, possibly getting 3 more on there team?

 

[Lady G]

OK, so have we come to the colclution that this day is based on the 50/50 game that ice modded, also known as game 63? If so can we move on to the bigger matters of the bad feeling i get when i look at the wiz/JL/HN thing?

At this point, I see it as day one bantering. Could mean something, but not worth going on and on about as of now. Something to watch and think about though for sure.

 

[Lady G]

Yes, I agree we shouldn't spend all our time running in circles around which format we are in right now. It is important to me however, especially since in that set up the mafia started with one and could send in a name to try to get on their team. What scares me a little about that is at this point I don't think the mafia can communicate, if they are starting with three does that mean each of them would get to send in a name, possibly getting 3 more on there team?

Ok, scratch that...looking more into the rules of that game, only the boss can send in a name. More then likely, they can each send in a name in hopes to find another mafia member so they can communicate. IF it is based on that game right now, I would think at this point they can not communicate with each other.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I'd just go for 'peculiar' over 'fishy'.


What does this mean?

Its a correction to a previuse post.

At this point, I see it as day one bantering. Could mean something, but not worth going on and on about as of now. Something to watch and think about though for sure.

Day 1 bantering that leads to votes? And i dont think that HN was bantering, he/he just jumped onto wiz when ogre led the way. The whole thing just gives me bad vibes.

 

[Lady G]

Its a correction to a previuse post.



Day 1 bantering that leads to votes? And i dont think that HN was bantering, he/he just jumped onto wiz when ogre led the way. The whole thing just gives me bad vibes.

Votes can and do change quite a bit on day one, especially early day one. I wont say you have no reason for "bad vibes", I just don't read to much into these things when they first start out. IMO it is better to watch and see what happens, where it goes that kind of thing.