Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!

[user_name]

I like how you went from sounding newbie to trying to sound more professional in a period of only a few posts. That seems.... scumish

If you're going to attempt to accuse me of being scummish, at least try to come up with a half-good reason.
I do agree with you, jm is either seer, hunter, or alpha wolf. I'm thinking alpha wolf, he's just a bit too skittish.

I like how you are pointing fingers towards jm. I mean me and just about everyone else sorta jumped on him. And actually if you read that page you would notice how scummy those posts were. Ps. You seem awfully defensive....

 

[user_name]

Well, we are almost at nightfall, what is everyone thinking???

 

[the wizard]

Ok, I need to leave for work.

I need to post a vote in case I don't get back in time. I can see a few places to vote and not be faulted for voting that way but don't feel comfortable at this time voting that way. I need to see more from those players to feel comfortable with my vote being on them.

I will say that it seems to me LG has been, as mentioned a little more finger-pointy than normal, especially for D1. I also think that D1 is a little early to play the confused card.

I was planning to watch her more closely for this reason.

You are better than that from my experience with you in these games although I don't recall you being scum in any of the games we have played together. So I really don't know how you play when scum.

Your play just seems a little "off" to me at this point in time. Not what I have come to expect from you.

I am also used to seeing a little more activity from LR than we have seen at this point.

And Dag has I believe made 2 posts. I will check after work.

In order to avoid UD,

I flipped a coin to determine my vote, sorry it is the best I can do at this time.

I vote to lynch LG

 

[Lady G]

So trying to figure where to put my vote, since most likely I wont be here to change it before nightfall. Hopefully I will be and will have more to go on, but I do not want to take a chance of UDing.
There are so many things that make me think hmmm, but none of which make me think OMG...WW!!!
JM, his comments about not seeing "joke votes"...maybe he is really thinking that, but I find it hard to believe.

Pap/Zaff and their "almost feels like one" posts. Pap quickly turns it into a vote for JM, Zaff ends up voting Pap....even though they seem to think pretty much the exact same thing.

User, with his "can we post/vote"...now I realize he was taken out day 1 last game, but I would think/hope he followed along with the rest of the game he should know how it works. Also bringing up the PR, just doesn't sit good with me at all.

Piranha, asking Kash why she would want to know how many WW we have, then posting a pretty big number as to his guess, bringing up the PR.

JB, seemed (to me) he was pulling posts from everyone in a pretty "accusing" kinda way in a attempt to get anyone to jump on anything.

I need to look back through and decide where to place my vote.

 

[Lady G]

Ok, I need to leave for work.

I need to post a vote in case I don't get back in time. I can see a few places to vote and not be faulted for voting that way but don't feel comfortable at this time voting that way. I need to see more from those players to feel comfortable with my vote being on them.

I will say that it seems to me LG has been, as mentioned a little more finger-pointy than normal, especially for D1. I also think that D1 is a little early to play the confused card.

I was planning to watch her more closely for this reason.

You are better than that from my experience with you in these games although I don't recall you being scum in any of the games we have played together. So I really don't know how you play when scum.

Your play just seems a little "off" to me at this point in time. Not what I have come to expect from you.

I am also used to seeing a little more activity from LR than we have seen at this point.

And Dag has I believe made 2 posts. I will check after work.

In order to avoid UD,

I flipped a coin to determine my vote, sorry it is the best I can do at this time.

I vote to lynch LG

Ok, this cracked me up.
As for the "finger pointy" remarks, I really have no idea where ya'll are seeing this but ok, if you say so. If goofing off is pointing fingers well so be it I spose.
Nope, don't think I've ever been evil when playin with ya, and I find it funny how ppl say they expect more from me, that I'm better then that...cracks me up every game. I don't think I have ever played a game that ppl didn't say I seemed to be "playing off"

 

[Lady G]

just how everyone seemed to jump the gun this early in the game. i do agree with you kash(cant believe i just said that) that JMs posts seem scummy, and i will keep an eye on him

JB, you are always on my scummy list, same with Jpappy.

lady G, i noticed you got close to saying the words "i am going to eat you" or something like that (Jpap already beat me to it and fixed your quote for you...)


opcorn:opcorn:opcorn:

so far, not sure if LG is innocent or not.

incase i dont get here tomorrow night, i better get a real vote in now...


I Retract my vote on FF, and vote to lynch Zaffy, just so i dont UD

sorry zaf, it looks like i may have started a train on you, i didnt try, honestly.:liar:

Well, I vote to lynch Rocker

After looking back through his post just strike me the most...
Trying to use Pap's reworded post against me, I mean really come on...you were trying pretty hard there to turn words I didn't say against me.
Then saying you don't know about me...DUH, unless you are WW you wouldn't..not sure why of all posts that had been made you would say something about not being sure about me.
Then after I am pretty much the only one you talked about you vote Zaff, adding "opps didn't mean to start a train"
Yep, this is where my vote is going.

 

[Lady G]

Also wanted to add about the first post I pulled, why would you "agree" with Kash...several ppl had posted thoughts about JM, so do you not agree with them....I like how you "single" ppl out on things that could go toward several players.

 

[rocker92]

im honered you voted for me LG!

 

[Zaffy]

I may or may not be home in time for nightfall, depends on traffic. I expect to be.

I vote to lynch Jpap. Mostly because I like to vote for him. Never have a clue what he is. I think JM is in the clear and no one else stands out to me. I plan to be back read the new stuff and hopefully make a better decision.

Can you explain why you think JM is clear?

So trying to figure where to put my vote, since most likely I wont be here to change it before nightfall. Hopefully I will be and will have more to go on, but I do not want to take a chance of UDing.
There are so many things that make me think hmmm, but none of which make me think OMG...WW!!!
JM, his comments about not seeing "joke votes"...maybe he is really thinking that, but I find it hard to believe.

Pap/Zaff and their "almost feels like one" posts. Pap quickly turns it into a vote for JM, Zaff ends up voting Pap....even though they seem to think pretty much the exact same thing.

User, with his "can we post/vote"...now I realize he was taken out day 1 last game, but I would think/hope he followed along with the rest of the game he should know how it works. Also bringing up the PR, just doesn't sit good with me at all.

Piranha, asking Kash why she would want to know how many WW we have, then posting a pretty big number as to his guess, bringing up the PR.

JB, seemed (to me) he was pulling posts from everyone in a pretty "accusing" kinda way in a attempt to get anyone to jump on anything.

I need to look back through and decide where to place my vote.

I don't mean to pick on you LG, or maybe I do because you're really into it. But could someone compile a side by side comparison of how Pappy and I are echoing each other. I see this theme posted a lot, and since so many people are using it as their basis of their thoughts I think it'd be really helpful for the town to have it all in one place. I would do it myself, but there are issues of subjective bias, and the fact that I'm leaving for work in a minute and I can't multiquote on my phone.

 

[Lady G]

Kash did a pretty good job of it in this post...I don't have time now to go back to pull my own quotes...but this one pretty much sums it up Zaff

Zaffy and Pappy pull the same quote and both respond to it in a similar tone.





Okay, so they were on the thread at the same time and saw/responded to the same post. By itself, that isn't anything, I know.

Then here, Zaffy goes on to jump on Pappy in response to JB... but for what? Because Pappy agrees with what Zaffy's been saying too?



You know, guys. You're both sounding like dual cross-examiners here. Don't get me wrong, you're both making good points about different people that I agree we should examine. But the two of you sound almost interchangeable and this tag team thing with alternating posts directed at whoever posted last is making my head spin.

After that, this post was directed to Chill from Zaffy.



And that was followed by this post to Rocker from Pappy.



However...... at this same time, both of you totally overlooked a direct question I posted earlier to all the experienced players. I posted that because I really want to know what others think.... including you.

@Pappy - How many werewolves do you think we should estimate there are in this game?

@Zaffy - How many werewolves do you think we should estimate there are in this game?

And, again... I'm not directing that question only to Pappy and Zaffy. I'd also like some input about this from Chill, Dag, Lab Rat, Lady G, Rich, and Wizard. (And yes, I'll repeat that again to each of you, if you don't respond to this.)

I think in this game it's important for us to discuss numbers. We usually do that anyway very early in the game whenever it's a non-standard game format.

In this round we have 15 players. The town side has 3 non-communicating PRs and 3 townies who communicate but have no power. That's almost half the field. Then on the scum side, they get an opportunity to possibly turn people.

How does everyone figure we should factor that in to make a best guess at the number of werewolves we're dealing with?